Preview Rd 14 - The Best Team of the Last 3 Years vs The West Coast Bradbury's

Remove this Banner Ad

Always takes two seasons for the establishment to wake up to a young player's worth unless they're a dominant first season mid.
Bakes is a deadset star, but there's also a plethora of running small backs across the league. We've got Houli, Short and Baker, and Vlastuin would be competing with them for AA recognition as well, even though he plays a different role. Then you have Brodie Smith, Laird, Docherty, Kade Simpson, Petrevski-Seton, Maynard, Crisp, Saad, Salem, Byrne-Jones, Hurn, Sheppard, Whitfield, Z.Williams, JJ, Daniel, Crozier, Lloyd, Bailey Williams (first break-out year and overshadowed by JJ and Daniel but killing it), Harbrow (the most underappreciated player in the role), Bowes and others. Lachie Weller kills it when he plays there. Any of those blokes could step into Shorty's role and we'd either gain, or lose nothing.

Short getting an AA gong would be equivalent to Suckling getting one when the Hawks were dominant. But to repeat, I'm ok with him as long as he goes when it's his turn, and is defensively accountable (watch the behind goals vision of Port's first goal of the last quarter against us - Short goes one way, Butters goes the other and they get the easiest of goals. Short spent the next 10 minutes or more on the bench.).
 
Bakes is a deadset star, but there's also a plethora of running small backs across the league. We've got Houli, Short and Baker, and Vlastuin would be competing with them for AA recognition as well, even though he plays a different role. Then you have Brodie Smith, Laird, Docherty, Kade Simpson, Petrevski-Seton, Maynard, Crisp, Saad, Salem, Byrne-Jones, Hurn, Sheppard, Whitfield, Z.Williams, JJ, Daniel, Crozier, Lloyd, Bailey Williams (first break-out year and overshadowed by JJ and Daniel but killing it), Harbrow (the most underappreciated player in the role), Bowes and others. Lachie Weller kills it when he plays there. Any of those blokes could step into Shorty's role and we'd either gain, or lose nothing.

Short getting an AA gong would be equivalent to Suckling getting one when the Hawks were dominant. But to repeat, I'm ok with him as long as he goes when it's his turn, and is defensively accountable (watch the behind goals vision of Port's first goal of the last quarter against us - Short goes one way, Butters goes the other and they get the easiest of goals. Short spent the next 10 minutes or more on the bench.).
Short went one way because Balta had the ball. It’s not his fault Balta muffed the handball.
 
Short went one way because Balta had the ball. It’s not his fault Balta muffed the handball.
No, he went well before Balta got the ball. One-point game, start of the last quarter, ball goes to a contest in their forward 50, stay on your man. That's why he spent so long on the bench straight after. Dragged. Rightly.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Bakes is a deadset star, but there's also a plethora of running small backs across the league. We've got Houli, Short and Baker, and Vlastuin would be competing with them for AA recognition as well, even though he plays a different role. Then you have Brodie Smith, Laird, Docherty, Kade Simpson, Petrevski-Seton, Maynard, Crisp, Saad, Salem, Byrne-Jones, Hurn, Sheppard, Whitfield, Z.Williams, JJ, Daniel, Crozier, Lloyd, Bailey Williams (first break-out year and overshadowed by JJ and Daniel but killing it), Harbrow (the most underappreciated player in the role), Bowes and others. Lachie Weller kills it when he plays there. Any of those blokes could step into Shorty's role and we'd either gain, or lose nothing.

Short getting an AA gong would be equivalent to Suckling getting one when the Hawks were dominant. But to repeat, I'm ok with him as long as he goes when it's his turn, and is defensively accountable (watch the behind goals vision of Port's first goal of the last quarter against us - Short goes one way, Butters goes the other and they get the easiest of goals. Short spent the next 10 minutes or more on the bench.).

Short plays a different role to Baker, no more comparable in roles than Vlaustin, IMO, who you do differentiate.

Most of the rebounders you list are behind Short, IMO, none more than Harbrow (except maybe Simpson in the twilight of his career). Aside from early days with GC, he's been on a huge slide for years from what he did with the Dogs, they would have been very frustrated by what he's contributed for what they paid. Hanley has taken a bit of heat off him in recent seasons by being an even worse attempt to buy in senior rebound.

Fact is, Short has pace, endurance, penetration by foot and kicking efficiency at a level that few of them do in combination, most are missing one or more of those key attributes.
 
Short plays a different role to Baker, no more comparable in roles than Vlaustin, IMO, who you do differentiate.

Most of the rebounders you list are behind Short, IMO, none more than Harbrow (except maybe Simpson in the twilight of his career). Aside from early days with GC, he's been on a huge slide for years from what he did with the Dogs, they would have been very frustrated by what he's contributed for what they paid. Hanley has taken a bit of heat off him in recent seasons by being an even worse attempt to buy in senior rebound.

Fact is, Short has pace, endurance, penetration by foot and kicking efficiency at a level that few of them do in combination, most are missing one or more of those key attributes.
Couldn't agree less.

AA selectors don't differentiate roles.
 
Couldn't agree less.

AA selectors don't differentiate roles.

Of course they do.

Rightly or wrongly, if a player has been in the top few rebounding defenders in a season they'll leap ahead of the far bigger glut of man-on-man small and medium defenders who provide some rebound.

There's two HBF's in every recent AA side who are selected mostly for their elite rebound capacity, not because they're great defensive defenders.
 
Im liking the way we're looking atm. Not a perfect game but we've certainly stepped up a notch tonight! Starting to really look the goods. 😊
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top