Rd 17 Discussion

[Donakebab]

Seriously, Shenton the sub... Richardson you massive ****ing campaigner! Was expecting him to just make break even and trade out next week after my hand being forced elsewhere.

Going to have to roll the dice that Sam Lloyd won't be the sub.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Breust & D.Swallow v. Jaensch & Dal Santo

Would love one more opinion on this before the North game is locked out! Still can't decide..

 

[hoddo]

Shenton the sub will only be a problem for me if a forward is a late out.
Decided to go with StevieJ as captain and to keep Langford's score.

StevieJ (c), Selwood, Bartel, Montagna and Harvey with Brown on the ruck bench in today's first 2 matches.

Breust & D.Swallow v. Jaensch & Dal Santo
Would love one more opinion on this before the North game is locked out! Still can't decide..

Option 1 by a long way IMO.

 

[toxic]

Breust & D.Swallow v. Jaensch & Dal Santo

Would love one more opinion on this before the North game is locked out! Still can't decide..

Jaensch and dal

 

[SCchamp]

Breust & D.Swallow v. Jaensch & Dal Santo

Would love one more opinion on this before the North game is locked out! Still can't decide..

Dude just got with what you think will be the right option....I don't understand how one more opinion will help with your decision

 

[SnappyHappy]

Dude just got with what you think will be the right option....I don't understand how one more opinion will help with your decision

I'm not great at making decisions haha

 

[AnthonyBPC]

Stevie J off to a flyer

 

[Spanish Sahara]

heck up Bartel and SJ

 

[GOAUS!]

Stevie J off to a flyer

And this is why I didn't go with Jelwood or SJ as captain. Too inconsistent.

 

[DT_35]

Bartel wtf are you doing

 

[AnthonyBPC]

And this is why I didn't go with Jelwood or SJ as captain. Too inconsistent.

Yeah, Selwood only has 10 touches half way through the first quater.

 

[manboob]

Stevie J off to a flyer

Inspired VC choice by me there.

 

[AnthonyBPC]

Inspired VC choice by me there.

+1

 

[JasRulz63]

Keep going VC Selwood

 

[manboob]

Keep going VC Selwood

 

[GOAUS!]

Yeah, Selwood only has 10 touches half way through the first quater.

Only scored 84 last week.

 

[Knighta21]

Selwood on track for 50 possies

 

[Donakebab]

Yeah, Selwood only has 10 touches half way through the first quater.

Yet last week he had 13 for the entire game. So yeah, inconsistent.

 

[AnthonyBPC]

Yet last week he had 13 for the entire game. So yeah, inconsistent.

Been inconsistent for the last 6 weeks or so, but has had incredible consistency over the course of his career. We judge our guns too harshly at times IMO.

 

[GOAUS!]

Last minute help!

Bringing in Honeychurch should I keep Shenton or Ambrose for one more week?

Ambrose.

 

[GOAUS!]

Been inconsistent for the last 6 weeks or so, but has had incredible consistency over the course of his career. We judge our guns too harshly at times IMO.

I'm viewing this purely in terms of SC, they're great players. But they've been inconsistent SC wise this year so unlikely to get the C when the VC has failed.

 

[Donakebab]

Been inconsistent for the last 6 weeks or so, but has had incredible consistency over the course of his career. We judge our guns too harshly at times IMO.

No ones calling him a spud, just the opinion of some is he's been too inconsistent to back in as C/VC. Hardly anything wrong with that.

 

[JuddgementDay]

I'm viewing this purely in terms of SC, they're great players. But they've been inconsistent SC wise this year so unlikely to get the C when the VC has failed.

Thats why vc is the go

 

[AnthonyBPC]

I'm viewing this purely in terms of SC, they're great players. But they've been inconsistent SC wise this year so unlikely to get the C when the VC has failed.

I reluctantly (because no one likes backing down) agree with you.

 

[JasRulz63]

Melbourne
38 Jeremy Howe 39
12 Dom Tyson 27
21 Cameron Pedersen 25
23 Bernie Vince 24
13 Jordie McKenzie 23
2 Nathan Jones 19
6 Chris Dawes 18
31 Jack Grimes 17
27 Aidan Riley 16
45 Matt Jones 16
8 James Frawley 15
7 Jack Viney 14
40 Mark Jamar 14
35 Luke Tapscott 12
16 Dean Kent 10
20 Colin Garland 9
44 Rohan Bail 9
39 Neville Jetta 8
14 Lynden Dunn 5
4 Jack Watts 3
46 Dean Terlich 0 (SUB)
25 Tom McDonald 0

Geelong
14 Joel Selwood 52
17 Hamish McIntosh 43
44 Corey Enright 42
32 Steven Motlop 38
46 Mark Blicavs 30
36 Brad Hartman 29
29 Cameron Guthrie 25
7 Harry Taylor 25
28 Allen Christensen 23
26 Tom Hawkins 22
9 James Kelly 21
23 Josh Caddy 21
20 Steve Johnson 20
25 Jared Rivers 19
4 Andrew Mackie 14
3 Jimmy Bartel 13
13 Tom Lonergan 13
39 Shane Kersten 12
5 Travis Varcoe 11
21 Jordan Murdoch 9
22 Mitch Duncan 1
33 George Horlin-Smith 0 (SUB)