Rd 17 Discussion

[TheOz]

Loving my JPK trade for GAJ right now, hopefully gets bumped up to 140+.

Paker, Malceski, Smurph, McVeigh, love you all! Simmo 85 not too bad.

 

[toxic]

Scores level
Pendles C + calward

V

Fyfe C trent cotchin and Wingard

Who wins?

 

[Gene Simmons]

Hey guys,

I'm thinking I may take JPK's score as my captains loophole but unsure if I can...

See my situation below, I am thinking of putting Goddard on field and slapping the 'C' on him and placing Fyfe on the bench as an emergency...

However, I already have Zac O'Brien (BL) selected as an emergency even though he wasn't selected to play... ?

As they take the 'lower' scoring emergency, does that mean they would count O'Brien's score of 0 or Fyfe's score?



Cheers

 

[Donakebab]

Scores level
Pendles C + calward

V

Fyfe C trent cotchin and Wingard

Who wins?

Option B by lots.

 

[Chronz]

Spud Hanley and Gardiner (filling in for Hibberd) ruined an otherwise great night with JPK, Parker, McVeigh, Buddy and Simpson.

 

[PoopingHindi]

backline total of 6/436 at an avg of 72

plus a 20 in midfield and Wingard hasnt even played yet
i just want this round to end


hopefully Sandilands is rested....its no like it will ruin my week

 

[Chronz]

Scores level
Pendles C + calward

V

Fyfe C trent cotchin and Wingard

Who wins?

Depends if Wingard can get a touch sitting in the pocket all ****ing day.

 

[Ed_Gein]

Terrific performance by the umpires in this one, only robbed Carlton by around 7 goals either end and totally turned the momentum in favour of team AFL.

Bwahahaha. Bitter much?

 

[Feerits Elf]

2005/17 (C)

Bartel the only disappointment.

Dusty, Fyfe, Sandi, Pendles, Beams to go.

 

[hoddo]

Hey guys,

I'm thinking I may take JPK's score as my captains loophole but unsure if I can...

See my situation below, I am thinking of putting Goddard on field and slapping the 'C' on him and placing Fyfe on the bench as an emergency...

However, I already have Zac O'Brien (BL) selected as an emergency even though he wasn't selected to play... ?

As they take the 'lower' scoring emergency, does that mean they would count O'Brien's score of 0 or Fyfe's score?

View attachment 67388

Cheers

No, only playing emergencies count so you would get Fyfe's score

 

[karaoke]

Scores level
Pendles C + calward

V

Fyfe C trent cotchin and Wingard

Who wins?

Not grimshaw,

 

[Kadog]

Final scaled

 

[TheOz]

Bwahahaha. Bitter much?

Not really, never expected to win this game, doesn't mean team COLA should be getting dodgy 50s, marks that are paid even though they're dropped and non-decisions for clear holding the ball and deliberate out of bounds. They already have enough of an advantage off field.

 

[Kadog]

Scores level
Pendles C + calward

V

Fyfe C trent cotchin and Wingard

Who wins?

I'd say you're in pole position there toxic...but beware SBS.

 

[hoddo]

Wow, still 100 points to go round in the Brisbane West Coast match.

And yet somehow Zorko and Hurn both managed to get scaled down

 

[PowerForGood]

Hey guys,

I'm thinking I may take JPK's score as my captains loophole but unsure if I can...

See my situation below, I am thinking of putting Goddard on field and slapping the 'C' on him and placing Fyfe on the bench as an emergency...

However, I already have Zac O'Brien (BL) selected as an emergency even though he wasn't selected to play... ?

As they take the 'lower' scoring emergency, does that mean they would count O'Brien's score of 0 or Fyfe's score?

View attachment 67388

Cheers

As I understand it, OBrien didn't play therefore in your situation, the lowest scoring emergency would by Fyfe, therefore JPK's score as captain would stand.

However, I'm not the expert so take with a grain of salt.

Maybe look to a different non playing emergency if you have one.

 

[GOAUS!]

1776/16.

Martin, Pendles, Beams, Fyfe (C), Pav and Sandi tomorrow.

In my league match

Pav, Fyfe + 185 vs
Gray, Hartlett, Lobbe and Swan.

 

[Kadog]

Final scaled

 

[toxic]

As I understand it, OBrien didn't play therefore in your situation, the lowest scoring emergency would by Fyfe, therefore JPK's score as captain would stand.

However, I'm not the expert so take with a grain of salt.

Maybe look to a different non playing emergency if you have one.

You are correct.

Means one line will have no emergency tho

 

[DT_35]

1,674/14+C

Wingard, Gray, Lobbe, D.Martin, Pendles, Swan, Beams & Mumford to come

 

[Saints_87]

1851/15 .. martin, pendles (c), mumford, beams and sandi to go .. rocky being out hurts, had to take honeys 35

 

[GOAUS!]

1851/15 .. martin, pendles (c), mumford, beams and sandi to go .. rocky being out hurts, had to take honeys 35

Geez.

 

[hoddo]

7/779 tonight for a total of 17(c)/2066.
Beams, Gray, Cotchin, Sandi and Pavlich to play ... on SBS.

 

[DT_35]

1851/15 .. martin, pendles (c), mumford, beams and sandi to go .. rocky being out hurts, had to take honeys 35

How is that from only 15 players if you only have 5 players remaining?

 

[JasRulz63]

1888 (captain played) with 6 left (Pendles, Beams, Martin, Sandi, Fyfe and Wingard)