thylacine60
Premium Platinum
- Banned
- #151
you wrote him off........
Preview Rd 22 - Carlton v St Kilda Sat 17th Aug 1.45pm @ MCG - Team Post #237
- Thread starter BlueGum
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
ESKIE
Keeping it Cool.
- Feb 28, 2009
- 31,762
- 53,215
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Never
SufferingS8INT
Club Legend
- Dec 17, 2017
- 1,259
- 3,262
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Brilliant! You’re right, Hanners and Stuv are relatively new to the game so doubt they have ever copped attention from oppo before!
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Moderator
- #154
Brilliant! You’re right, Hanners and Stuv are relatively new to the game so doubt they have ever copped attention from oppo before!
Are you lost?
Been a great pick up, considering the cost
In. Tdk, Kennedy & Dow
Out. Jones, Lang & Fisher
Levi to defence. Tdk forward & relief ruck.
I'm glad that little pest Gresham is not playing for them. Ed to shutdown Steven.
Our best tall defender, Weiters to Membrey.
Love to beat this mob, which has a tragic history & whose supporters claim is a great club, yet have only won one flag in over 150 years, albeit, a lucky kick by Breen out of a pack, to dribble through for for a point for their only flag in over 150 years.
Let's show them a REAL club. Let's do it for Crippa and the other milestoners. Go Blues.
Out. Jones, Lang & Fisher
Levi to defence. Tdk forward & relief ruck.
I'm glad that little pest Gresham is not playing for them. Ed to shutdown Steven.
Our best tall defender, Weiters to Membrey.
Love to beat this mob, which has a tragic history & whose supporters claim is a great club, yet have only won one flag in over 150 years, albeit, a lucky kick by Breen out of a pack, to dribble through for for a point for their only flag in over 150 years.
Let's show them a REAL club. Let's do it for Crippa and the other milestoners. Go Blues.
- Apr 4, 2018
- 14,938
- 28,918
- AFL Club
- Carlton
As reported by Sarah Olle (foxsports) we did really well 2 weeks in a row to remain competitive against this years likely grand finalists.
A win this week and a competitive one against the handbaggers will be strong indications that we will climb the ladder rapidly next year and well and truely make the 8 the following year.
A win this week and a competitive one against the handbaggers will be strong indications that we will climb the ladder rapidly next year and well and truely make the 8 the following year.
Not to many changes for me:
In: Kennedy & Dow
Out: Jones & Lang
Casboult goes back.
Harry, McGov, Kennedy the marking options up forward. Good balance.
TDK has been injured a lot this year, let him develop and introduce him next year.
This is a must win game, we are not just giving kids games anymore (I know tdk has been playing well for a few weeks)
In: Kennedy & Dow
Out: Jones & Lang
Casboult goes back.
Harry, McGov, Kennedy the marking options up forward. Good balance.
TDK has been injured a lot this year, let him develop and introduce him next year.
This is a must win game, we are not just giving kids games anymore (I know tdk has been playing well for a few weeks)
- Banned
- #160
Yep gotta agree with everyone else, Casboult back to cover for Jones. Goddard not up to it at the moment. Harry & Gov to be our talls with Kennedy the 3rd 'tall' fwd.
Otherwise you could bring TDK in for another taste and play him fwd/2nd ruck with Casboult still going to the backline and not 2nd ruckman.
Otherwise you could bring TDK in for another taste and play him fwd/2nd ruck with Casboult still going to the backline and not 2nd ruckman.
Sad to say that Fish has been awful the last few weeks, and needs to earn his spot back or work on his forward craft over the PS.
I'd bring Lang (offered little) and Fish out, with Kennedy back and Cunningham for the last fortnight. Could bring Dow back if we want a third change, but I'd rather see O'Brien get another chance. He definitely didn't perfect in the wet.
I'd bring Lang (offered little) and Fish out, with Kennedy back and Cunningham for the last fortnight. Could bring Dow back if we want a third change, but I'd rather see O'Brien get another chance. He definitely didn't perfect in the wet.
- Aug 22, 2014
- 13,670
- 49,635
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Brilliant! You’re right, Hanners and Stuv are relatively new to the game so doubt they have ever copped attention from oppo before!
Name checks out...
Cuners won't play
Gibbons and Fisher won't be dropped
Doubt Faz will get a run
I would try Garlett for Lang
Last edited:
- Banned
- #165
Not sure how anyone would want to drop Gibbons. Been very good the past 4-6 weeks. Had a down game against the tigers but not droppable. Especially as the cupboard is bare at VFL level (and don't give me Fasalo, Garlett etc as replacements - scrap heap for them)
Macca43
Premiership Player
- Mar 10, 2011
- 4,214
- 11,106
- AFL Club
- Carlton
In. Tdk, Kennedy & Dow
Out. Jones, Lang & Fisher
Levi to defence. Tdk forward & relief ruck.
I'm glad that little pest Gresham is not playing for them. Ed to shutdown Steven.
Our best tall defender, Weiters to Membrey.
Love to beat this mob, which has a tragic history & whose supporters claim is a great club, yet have only won one flag in over 150 years, albeit, a lucky kick by Breen out of a pack, to dribble through for for a point for their only flag in over 150 years.
Let's show them a REAL club. Let's do it for Crippa and the other milestoners. Go Blues.
That is what I have been thinking as well, Casboult is a much better option back than Goddard and it gives us a chance to see what TDK can do.
Also agree on Lang out (for absolutely anyone TBH) and Dow seems the most logical.
I watched the game again last night and I didn't think Fisher was anywhere near as bad as people on here have been making out, when he was involved good things tended to happen. Strangely I would be happier to see De Luca out instead of Fisher if we want Kennedy in, De luca worked really hard but his disposals generally ended up with the Tigers and he should have ended up with 2 goals but didn't score at all.
A lot of people putting Cuningham in the Ins - do we know why he didn't play VFL last weekend?
I can't imagine him playing in either of the last two games at the minute with hardly any game time since the bye.
In - Dow, Kennedy
Out - Lang, Jones (inj)
Lang has had his chance, he's not offering much. May as well put a kid like Dow in even if he is out of position.
As others have mentioned, Casboult to float back as required. Harry, Kennedy, Gov up forward.
I can't imagine him playing in either of the last two games at the minute with hardly any game time since the bye.
In - Dow, Kennedy
Out - Lang, Jones (inj)
Lang has had his chance, he's not offering much. May as well put a kid like Dow in even if he is out of position.
As others have mentioned, Casboult to float back as required. Harry, Kennedy, Gov up forward.
- Mar 19, 2014
- 3,568
- 8,003
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Denver Broncos
You can't blame them, they have monstered us in the past.
- Sep 25, 2017
- 668
- 5,361
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
In the 00s it was 12-3, this decade it's 9-6. It's definitely evening up and it's likely you'll shoot straight past us.
Hopefully we won't be back to the old days. During the previous century we only won 30 and lost 190.
I'm really looking forward to this week. It's arguable that you guys have more to play for. One more excellent effort should seal the job for Teague. And it may just sway Cogs to put pen to paper.
With Jones out I think we'll win, but i sure as hell aint confident. Finally, I'm hoping Rowe plays, it'd be nice to have a feelgood story instead of the usual negatives. It'd be fantastic to see both sets of supporters cheering a great club man.
Anyway, good luck baggers, let's hope it's a great game.
- Moderator
- #170
Brilliant! You’re right, Hanners and Stuv are relatively new to the game so doubt they have ever copped attention from oppo before!
1966!
- Moderator
- #171
In the 00s it was 12-3, this decade it's 9-6. It's definitely evening up and it's likely you'll shoot straight past us.
Hopefully we won't be back to the old days. During the previous century we only won 30 and lost 190.
Anyway, I'm really looking forward to this week. It's arguable that you guys have more to play for. One more excellent effort should seal the job for Teague. And it may just sway Cogs to put pen to paper.
With Jones out I think we'll win, but i sure as hell aint confident. Finally, I'm hoping Rowe plays, it'd be nice to have a feelgood story instead of the usual negatives. Good luck, baggers, let's hope it's a great game.
We have 15 more Flags!
In the 00s it was 12-3, this decade it's 9-6. It's definitely evening up and it's likely you'll shoot straight past us.
Hopefully we won't be back to the old days. During the previous century we only won 30 and lost 190.
Anyway, I'm really looking forward to this week. It's arguable that you guys have more to play for. One more excellent effort should seal the job for Teague. And it may just sway Cogs to put pen to paper.
With Jones out I think we'll win, but i sure as hell aint confident. Finally, I'm hoping Rowe plays, it'd be nice to have a feelgood story instead of the usual negatives. It'd be fantastic to see both sets of supporters cheering a great club man.
Anyway, good luck baggers, let's hope it's a great game.
Will be a good test for where both sides are at, late in the season
Although, the result is not really an indication of what is to come for both sides.
Not disrespect to your young talent, guys like Gresham, Billings, Battle etc continue to show they can reach new levels, but I still prefer our youth moving forward
Hopefully it will be a cracker game
- Sep 25, 2017
- 668
- 5,361
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
We have 15 more Flags!
C'mon Aph, you know i meant recent history...Just had to sneak that in there huh?
All good mate. The progress of Clark and Marshall this year has me seeing some light for the future. Hopefully, this time next year, both our clubs are fighting it out in the top half of the ladder.
- Moderator
- #174
C'mon Aph, you know i meant recent history...Just had to sneak that in there huh?
Of course I did.
You want history, I will give you history ......
Games played - 220
Carlton have won 162, lost 2 and drawn 2.
thylacine60
Premium Platinum
- Banned
- #175
earn his spot back? there's one game left in the season.......
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
