MVP Rd8 MVP Votes 2016 Geelong V Adelaide

[Cezz The Catter]

This board is so Danger bias haha. Battled all day no question but his influence wasnt enough for votes I dont think. Anyway this is how I saw it;

5 - Guthrie, undisputed.
4 - Motlop, quiet third but so important.
3 - Henderson, getting better by the week - Gun!
2 - Kersten, this guy is dynamite, I will forever be eating my words early days.
1 - Enright, too old? Too good.

 

[Turbocat]

5 motlop
4 guthrie
3 henderson
2 kersten
1 smith

 

[STP18]

5. Guthrie
4. Motlop
3. Henderson
2. Enright
1. Lang

 

[David the Cat]

5 Guthrie
4 Motlop
3 Henderson
2 Enright
1 Menzel

 

[catempire]

5. #guthintheguts
4. Motlop (#vestedinterests)
3. Hendo (can you believe we gave up a late first rounder???)
2. Boris (never retire)
1. #PFD

 

[InnocentBystandr]

5. Guthrie
4. Motlop
3. Kersten
2. Henderson
1. Enright

 

[iameviljez]

5) Guthrie
4) Motlop, as hungry for goals as he is for... well, pretty much anything else
3) Dangerfield
2) Henderson
1) Bartel

 

[DanA]

5. Guthrie
4. Motlop
3. Enright
2. Henderson
1. Kersten

Feels like I've been edging Kersten into my votes a bit lately.

 

[Herne Hill Hammer]

5. Motlop - for when your side kicks 20 behinds and wins by 4 goals and you kick 4 straight and gave that one to Menzel
4. Guthrie
3. Henderson
2. Enright
1. Kersten

Is there another side in the comp who has 3 players that are as explosive off the mark like Danger, Guthrie and Stanley?

 

[DrakeOMalfoy]

5. Guthrie
4. Motlop
3. Henderson
2. Danger
1. Kersten

Know Danger has been a bit of a talking point but his contested game was huge tonight. Wasn't able to be his usual outside effective self but his contested possessions and tackles numbers were huge

 

[Seeds]

5 motlop
4 guthrie
3 dangerfield
2 henderson
1 enright

Never been easier to pick.

 

[TheWoodenSlug]

Really struggled to split the top two, but Motlop's accuracy in front of goals got him over the line.

5. Motlop
4. Guthrie (stiff)
3. Henderson
2. Smith
1. Enright the Immortal

 

[Lester Burnham]

5. Guthrie
4. Motlop
3. Enright
2. Kersten
1. Hendo

 

[Spazz Cat]

5 Guthrie
4 Hendo
3 Mots
2 Stanley
1 Jimmy

 

[iameviljez]

This board is so Danger bias haha. Battled all day no question but his influence wasnt enough for votes I dont think.

I reckon it goes almost the other way... if Lang had 33 touches, how many votes do you think we'd give him?

 

[Mad_Hatter]

5. Umpires
4. Tex's mo.
3. Domsy's glass jaw.
2. That idiot crow fan flipping the bird at the camera.
1. The cheer squad member who made up a huge banner "No Danger, No problem".

HM to the pigeon who crapped on that moron crow fan abusing some young Cat families on the way out of the ground.



In seriousness however

5. Guthrie
4. Motlop
3. Hendo
2. Enright
1. Smith and Stanley.

 

[Vdubs]

5. Guthrie
5. Motlop
can't split them, so I won't
3. Henderson
1. Smith
1. Stanley

I missed Boris, he was immense, defies his age.

One of the greatest this club has produced.

Why not edit your ridiculous 1 vote then?

 

[vicpride]

5. Motlop
4. Guthrie
3. Caddy
2. Kersten
1. Henderson

Sent from my GT-I8730 using Tapatalk

 

[Nest of Cats]

5. Guthrie
4. Motlop
3. Kersten
2. Bartel
1. Menzel

 

[Cezz The Catter]

I reckon it goes almost the other way... if Lang had 33 touches, how many votes do you think we'd give him?

Well its all opinion mate and I respect everyones even though I may disagree. You have a valid point but I try to look beyond raw possession (even though its a massive factor).

 

[mac_cat]

5. Guthrie
4. Motlop
3. Henderson
2. Enright
1. Smith

 

[ChookNorris]

I've changed my own mind.
5. Guthrie
4. Motlop
3. Henderson
2. Smith
1. Dangerfield

 

[Boxhead_31]

5. Guthrie
4. Motlop
3. Henderson
2. Stanley
1. Kersten

 

[Cats408]

5 Guthrie
4 Mots
3 Hendo
2 Kersten
1 Jimmy

 

[Cezz The Catter]

5 motlop
4 guthrie
3 dangerfield
2 henderson
1 enright

Never been easier to pick.

What no Blicavs mate?