Remove this Banner Ad

RDFL Thread 2007

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
alot of talk today gee whiz. alot of very critical talk bout certain players. i like matts list of top 10 but i would see it like this
1 Cornish
2 Kemp
3 Robbo
4 Barnes
5 Goudge
6 Colliver
7 Salter
8 King
9 Newham( injuries n suspension have prevented him from being higher)
10 Strayney
Im not going to say whose stiff to miss but i dont agree with sum of the selections. i know i have done nothin to date so im not suggesting anything. Suspension have hindered a few players n what not. maybe every1 is looking much too deep at the kilmore spectrum. if we dont make finals stiff shit, every1 knows what we will have to do next yr. i know that i want to get fitter, n stronger. to give 2008 a real crack in the blues jumper. i want to win a flag at this club, my old man won a flag at kilmore and it is definately the highest thing on my list of TO DO's atm, if anyone doesnt like that then bad luck
 
They loose one game which puts them back into the pack and bang......

Listen to the critics come out of the closet, where have you guys been all year?
Have the wheels fallen of the ban wagon up there or what? Questioning players commitments and ability to lead sides?

Interesting night on the track, No Terry, No Goudge, Robbo's ability in doubt! Time to sack Dayson perhaps? Nicholls get the boys together, and rally your troops son, the fat lady hasn't sung yet!!!
 
MustonMagic17 said:
your opinion is your opinion

I play with the man there is no better leader at the cub and robos team play this year has been better then previous years.His kicking hasn't been at 100% this year but is very important to not only kilmore but the RDFL.

Kempy n Corno are top footballers but i doubt corno would have had 70 shots on goal without robo i the side.I agree that they are quality tho.

If robo turned up at wallan?
Couldnt give him the paperwork fast enough!
Click to expand...

I'm pretty sure Bulldogz-Rox is not from Wallan but I am and your right Wallan would love to have Robbo. He played a couple of years at juniors with us and he is an outstanding player.
 
vantheman32 said:
alot of talk today gee whiz. alot of very critical talk bout certain players. i like matts list of top 10 but i would see it like this
1 Cornish
2 Kemp
3 Robbo
4 Barnes
5 Goudge
6 Colliver
7 Salter
8 King
9 Newham( injuries n suspension have prevented him from being higher)
10 Strayney
Im not going to say whose stiff to miss but i dont agree with sum of the selections. i know i have done nothin to date so im not suggesting anything. Suspension have hindered a few players n what not. maybe every1 is looking much too deep at the kilmore spectrum. if we dont make finals stiff shit, every1 knows what we will have to do next yr. i know that i want to get fitter, n stronger. to give 2008 a real crack in the blues jumper. i want to win a flag at this club, my old man won a flag at kilmore and it is definately the highest thing on my list of TO DO's atm, if anyone doesnt like that then bad luck
Click to expand...

Is this where i say your stiff to miss out Van?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Hawker28 said:
They loose one game which puts them back into the pack and bang......

Listen to the critics come out of the closet, where have you guys been all year?
Have the wheels fallen of the ban wagon up there or what? Questioning players commitments and ability to lead sides?

Interesting night on the track, No Terry, No Goudge, Robbo's ability in doubt! Time to sack Dayson perhaps? Nicholls get the boys together, and rally your troops son, the fat lady hasn't sung yet!!!
Click to expand...

I keep telling them that. The players at Kilmore need to get a bit more mongrel (pardon the pun Deano) in them and show some fight. Forget about the opposition and just go out and play arrogant footy. It is their only option this week.
 
Any of the Kilmore boys can answer this, but did not having Ahern coach on the weekend against diggers, did that effect your team at all.
 
im not sure if it did or didnt, i thought Jamie Archer did a pretty good job on saturday, just diggers strength and experience and sheer desire to win more than us. they were too good on the day, simple.
 
matt_nicholls said:
You're entitled to your opinion, I see some merit in it. I don't think Robbo is the best leader at the club, and perhaps shouldn't be captain. But that is a club issue. The fact is, toe-to-toe, there are few better players in this competition.

Ice, the club probably need to start thinking about it now. Don't want to get to a stage where you are fighting time to join the league. Get Neal Langborne to ring Scott McCartney and he'll probably come and speak to you. I'm sure the RDFL would want 12 clubs, not 11. So you may need to try and convince someone like Trentham to come across.
Click to expand...


I am not 100% on neil thoughts on weather he wants to switch back to RDFL or stay in the NFL. Your interview if you get one with him should be good reading and may just get the ball rolling.
 
Iceman27 said:
Any of the Kilmore boys can answer this, but did not having Ahern coach on the weekend against diggers, did that effect your team at all.
Click to expand...

If Tez had of coached, perhaps the scoreline would have been closer, but I think the result would have been the same. Arch is pretty passionate about his footy and had the boys prepared as usual, so I can't see it making much difference.

The Wallan boys played better under Gibbo's coaching on Saturday, will Watson get the arse :D
 
vantheman32 said:
alot of talk today gee whiz. alot of very critical talk bout certain players. i like matts list of top 10 but i would see it like this
1 Cornish
2 Kemp
3 Robbo
4 Barnes
5 Goudge
6 Colliver
7 Salter
8 King
9 Newham( injuries n suspension have prevented him from being higher)
10 Strayney
Im not going to say whose stiff to miss but i dont agree with sum of the selections. i know i have done nothin to date so im not suggesting anything. Suspension have hindered a few players n what not. maybe every1 is looking much too deep at the kilmore spectrum. if we dont make finals stiff shit, every1 knows what we will have to do next yr. i know that i want to get fitter, n stronger. to give 2008 a real crack in the blues jumper. i want to win a flag at this club, my old man won a flag at kilmore and it is definately the highest thing on my list of TO DO's atm, if anyone doesnt like that then bad luck
Click to expand...

So just Moedt out of pickles top 10 Jobby
 
matt_nicholls said:
If Tez had of coached, perhaps the scoreline would have been closer, but I think the result would have been the same. Arch is pretty passionate about his footy and had the boys prepared as usual, so I can't see it making much difference.

The Wallan boys played better under Gibbo's coaching on Saturday, will Watson get the arse :D
Click to expand...

Gibbo only coached a quarter and a half when watson had to go to hospital but no doubt he will make a good coach one day.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

he wasnt the only one mate, just an opinion,not degrading moedt i think hes done a good job this yr. how are the ribs there mate?
 
no good mate unlucky. i feel a bit better except i got a killer cold right now gone through about 10 hankees today its all good though
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

matt_nicholls said:
Next week's paper will have a big spread on the RDFL and my views on a two division competition. It will hopefully also involve the Wallan, Broadford and Gisborne presidents on their views as to whether they would consider returning.
Click to expand...

Dont even bother putting Broadford into the equation mate, will only mean wasting premium space and providing less space to discuss legitimate contenders to enter your comp. Can anyone please remind why clubs such as Gisborne, Sunbury, Melton's, Darley, Jacana and Craigieburn left originally and why on earth things have changed for them to return?
 
still a chance this week we will have to wait n see, yeah got a cold to the docs worried about pneumonia with breathing dificulties, did you like discos top 10
 
Doona2 said:
Dont even bother putting Broadford into the equation mate, will only mean wasting premium space and providing less space to discuss legitimate contenders to enter your comp. Can anyone please remind why clubs such as Gisborne, Sunbury, Melton's, Darley, Jacana and Craigieburn left originally and why on earth things have changed for them to return?
Click to expand...

The competition is now much stronger and had a guaranteed future now, whereas eight or so years ago it was looking shaky. It'll probably never happen, but it makes for good reading and discussion.
 
discoduck said:
who are you? what are you trying to hide? before, your avatar said you were from wallan, now it says melbourne. i hope you are just stirring it up, because you are talking a fair bit of crap here today.

i've only been around a month or so, but he seems very well liked amongst the players and is a goer on the ground. if there are players within the club who dislike him, they don't make it clear to him or anyone else, so maybe they should pipe up and gets things out in the open and make it a better club all round (not that i think that's what is going on)
Click to expand...

He sounds a lot like 1 of my "Friends" duck !

They think because its so easy to post under many new names it makes them smart, he sould have taken his mates advice & kept of our Forum, before he hurts someone he loves Irrevocably !
 
bulldogz_rok said:
omg ppl what game are u watchin lol...how can anything he does on feild imspire a team..he just kicks the ball in the air with no real purpose..he has no maturity...and no leadership qualities at all..he obviously aint that good i mean he only plays for kilmore there not the best team now are they if he was as good as everyone pretends he is then hed b playin afl..he is just to up himself to realise that half his team dont really like him...and ppl just follow him around like lost sheep or love sick puppies its disgusting...maybe it is time that everyone did wake upto the fact that maybe if u had a better leader who was a better footballer then they could possibly be a real good team and maybe have a chance at the flag....
Click to expand...

AN OPPONENTS PERSPECTIVE ON ROBBO

i would be more than happy to play on any onballer in the competition.
but if i was given the job on robbo this thursday night,i doubt whether id get much sleep between then and the game.he is tall,super mobile
has a fantastic leap,reads the play beautifully,and to put it mildly he is head and shoulders above 99 percent of the rdfl players.if u dont like the guy at least respect his football talent.bulldog u obviously have issues with robbo,perhaps it would be a better idea to prove your points about him on the field,rather than from the sideline:thumbsdown:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top