Redo the 2009 draft.

[Donkey Chop]

Anyone who has Jetta in their top 10 is having a laugh. Sort of frontrunner who is up only when the team is up.
Anyone who doesn't have Black in the top 10 is also having a laugh, I would even take him ahead of Cunnington.

100% agree. If you feel like a laugh go and have a look back through the thread and see the abuse Daz got when he had Black at 6. It was actually quite bizarre.

 

[ArjenTheGreat]

Right now:

1. Nathan Fyfe
2. Dustin Martin
3. Michael Barlow
4. Jake Carlisle
5. Aaron Black
6. Ben Cunnington
7. Allan Christensen
8. Daniel Talia
9. Mitch Duncan
10. Lewis Jetta
11. Ryan Bastinac
12. Jake Trengove
13. Jake Melksham
14. Ben Stratton
15. Tom Scully
16. Majak Daw
17. Sam Reid
18. Gary Rohan
19. Stewart Crameri
20. Mitch Golby


Morabito and Menzel stiff, but can't have them on future prospects[/quote]

 

[democritus]

Right now:

1. Nathan Fyfe
2. Dustin Martin
3. Michael Barlow
4. Jake Carlisle
5. Aaron Black
6. Ben Cunnington
7. Allan Christensen
8. Daniel Talia
9. Mitch Duncan
10. Lewis Jetta
11. Ryan Bastinac
12. Jake Trengove
13. Jake Melksham
14. Ben Stratton
15. Tom Scully
16. Majak Daw
17. Sam Reid
18. Gary Rohan
19. Stewart Crameri
20. Mitch Golby


Morabito and Menzel stiff, but can't have them on future prospects

[/quote]

Sorry, but no way does Daw get in ahead of guys like Gunston, Roberton, Vardy or Touhy. One game doesn't maketh the man.

No. Just, no.

 

[tribey]

Would be disappointed if Andrew Moore didn't go some way to justifying his original pick next year. Had a rather solid second half of the year with limited midfield minutes.

Looked exceptional in bits and pieces. Increasingly so.

 

[ArjenTheGreat]

Sorry, but no way does Daw get in ahead of guys like Gunston, Roberton, Vardy or Touhy. One game doesn't maketh the man.

No. Just, no.[/quote]

You obviously don't work in the marketing department.

 

[democritus]

You obviously don't work in the marketing department.

Evidently not. Objectively and on exposed form, there's no way you could justify having Majak that high up the draft order.

I understand the hype, I want the kid to dominate but it's more image than impact so far.

 

[The Bomb]

Evidently not. Objectively and on exposed form, there's no way you could justify having Majak that high up the draft order.

I understand the hype, I want the kid to dominate but it's more image than impact so far.

give him a break, he only got 4 North players in the top 16.

 

[nickrebellious]

Can someone explain how Black is being rated higher than Gunston?

 

[Donkey Chop]

Can someone explain how Black is being rated higher than Gunston?

For a start Gunston looks like he'll struggle to put on much size because of his narrow frame.

 

[Daz]

I think Black's speed sets him apart from Gunston. I'm sure Gunston has better stats at the moment but he's got a pretty good thing going being a 3rd tall in what is by far the best attacking team in the comp.

 

[Yelle]

Right now:

1. Nathan Fyfe
2. Dustin Martin
3. Michael Barlow
4. Jake Carlisle
5. Aaron Black
6. Ben Cunnington
7. Allan Christensen
8. Daniel Talia
9. Mitch Duncan
10. Lewis Jetta
11. Ryan Bastinac
12. Jake Trengove
13. Jake Melksham
14. Ben Stratton
15. Tom Scully
16. Majak Daw
17. Sam Reid
18. Gary Rohan
19. Stewart Crameri
20. Mitch Golby


Morabito and Menzel stiff, but can't have them on future prospects

[/quote]
You sure you don't want to throw Cruize Garlett and Brayden Norris in for good measure?

 

[ArjenTheGreat]

I think Black's speed sets him apart from Gunston. I'm sure Gunston has better stats at the moment but he's got a pretty good thing going being a 3rd tall in what is by far the best attacking team in the comp.

4th tall.

Buddy, Roughy, Buddy Hale and then Gunston plays on an undersized defender.

I don't know what to say other the thread is about re-doing the draft and in what order they would be taken.

 

[melbournehammer]

Carlise would be top 3 imo. How many 200cm players with his marking ability have the mobility and talent to play all of FF, CHF, CHB, FB???

Just for the sake of saying it - sam reid may not be quite that tall but can play all of those positions quite confortably.

 

[Ambrosia]

Just for the sake of saying it - sam reid may not be quite that tall but can play all of those positions quite confortably.

Not sure he has the strength/positioning to play on the likes of Cloke.

 

[melbournehammer]

Not sure he has the strength/positioning to play on the likes of Cloke.

no-one from the dons thought teddy did either !

I can assure you that if sam was playing full back his ectomorph body would be more than capable of reaching over and spoiling any of the full forwards, centre half forwards in the league.

 

[Thewlis Dish]

Can someone explain how Black is being rated higher than Gunston?

I would assume because he'll be a better player. Gunston is very good though.

 

[Shinboner '07]

1. Fyfe
2. Cunnington
3. Martin
4. Black
5. Bastinac

 

[democritus]

1. Fyfe
2. Cunnington
3. Martin
4. Black
5. Bastinac

Nah

1. Cunnington
2. Bastinac
3. Black
4. Daw
5. Macmillan

You guys killed it.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Lol Black, lol cunnington, lol bastinac
Deluded north fans

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Please see below my top 20, I am not bias and think this is a fair view. I may have missed one or two, so let me know if you think I have...

1. Fyfe
2. Martin
3. D.Talia
4. L.Jetta
5. Carlisle
6. Stratton
7. Gunston
8. Rohan
9. Duncan
10. Black
11. Bastinac
12. Scully
13. Cunnington
14. Menzel
15. S.Reid
16. Trengove
17. Christensen
18. D. Grimes
19. Morabito
20. Melksham

Menzel, Morabito & Rohan all would have been higher if not for such bad injuries.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Lol Black, lol cunnington, lol bastinac
Deluded north fans

All 3 are ahead of any Carlton player in that year, by the way.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Lol Black, lol cunnington, lol bastinac
Deluded north fans

Kane. Lucas.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

All 3 are ahead of any Carlton player in that year, by the way.

Not saying they aren't..a awfully defensive arent you.
I'm just saying theyre no where near where many North posters have them, typical north delusions, make a final series get obliterated, then dont even make the finals, still theink their team is good

 

[Vindicater]

Please see below my top 20, I am not bias and think this is a fair view. I may have missed one or two, so let me know if you think I have...

1. Fyfe
2. Martin
3. D.Talia
4. L.Jetta
5. Carlisle
6. Stratton
7. Gunston
8. Rohan
9. Duncan
10. Black
11. Bastinac
12. Scully
13. Cunnington
14. Menzel
15. S.Reid
16. Trengove
17. Christensen
18. D. Grimes
19. Morabito
20. Lucas

Menzel, Morabito & Rohan all would have been higher if not for such bad injuries.

Would you really take Jetta before Carlisle???

Lucas before Melksham???

My god.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Would you really take Jetta before Carlisle???

Lucas before Melksham???

My god.

Yes, when Jetta is fit I would love to have him, he did kick 40 goals off a wing last year, and hasn't been fit this year, his output is fantastic when fit. I rate Carlisle as well, but truly rate Jetta with his outside run and line breaking, also a huge X-Factor player.

I forgot about Melksham, he is definitely ahead of Lucas, I have put him in instead of Lucas at 20.