This is bang on I think bar a couple of possible exceptions. I'd have Carlisle over Cunnington and both Pittard and Christensen over Jetta. Like one other said, I'd swing Sam Reid into #20 at the expense of Melksham.There have been 4 All Australians, a Brownlow Medallist, B&F winners, and an MVP from the 2009 Draft.
Right now I'd have:
1. Fyfe
2. Martin
3. Talia
4. Gunston
5. Beard
6. Stratton
7. Cunnington
8. Carlisle
9. Duncan
10. Rodent
11. Jetta
12. Christensen
13. Duryea
14. Pittard
15. MacMillan
16. Sheppard
17. Roberton
18. Melksham
19. Rohan
20. Bastinac
Apologies to Menzel, who's starting to once again show what he can do, and others on the fringe including Sinclair, Griffiths, Reid, and Colyer, who I expect would have made it without the year out.
The Beard is almost the most valuable, but needs more body of work to pass Talia, who is a former RS winner, Best & Fairest, and dual All Australian, as well as Gunston, who has slotted over 50 goals on 3 separate occasions.