Analysis Redo the 2018 Draft

[Wargreymon90]

mine are:
1. Butters
2. B. King
3. Rozee
4. Walsh
5. B. Smith

 

[JPetro83]

the 2018 draft will be the reason why port play in the GF this year..

 

[Yoda_]

Hey eth-dog
This is Nic Martin’s draft cohort, correct?

He’s be almost top 5 if it were done again?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[eth-dog]

Hey eth-dog
This is Nic Martin’s draft cohort, correct?

He’s be almost top 5 if it were done again?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Nope. 2019 draft

 

[Del165198]

Still early, but serious questions must be asked as to whether this will be the greatest draft of all time. Compare it to the drafts around it and there's no competition.

These players all look like being varying degrees of guns:

• Walsh
• Luko
• Rankine
• King bros
• Rozee
• Smith (down on output but his ceiling is very good)
• Blakey
• Butters
• Quaynor
• Hill
• Briggs

Plenty of other serviceable types as well, or players with a lot of potential.

2001 is generally regarded as the best of all time but could it be surpassed? Lou codge, Ablett jnr and Judd were pretty good.

 

[NetworkNerd]

Still early, but serious questions must be asked as to whether this will be the greatest draft of all time. Compare it to the drafts around it and there's no competition.

These players all look like being varying degrees of guns:

• Walsh
• Luko
• Rankine
• King bros
• Rozee
• Smith (down on output but his ceiling is very good)
• Blakey
• Butters
• Quaynor
• Hill
• Briggs

Plenty of other serviceable types as well, or players with a lot of potential.

2001 is generally regarded as the best of all time but could it be surpassed? Lou codge, Ablett jnr and Judd were pretty good.

2001 will be very hard to pass. Talent everywhere

GAJ
Judd
Hodge
Mitchell
Bartel
Luke Ball
James Kelly
Steve Johnson
Dane Swan
Brian Lake

Then a pile of other players stiff to not make the top 10
David Hale
Ashley Sampi
Brent Reilly
Ash Hansen
Rick Ladson
Matt Maguire
Mark Seaby
Lewis Roberts Thomson
Campbell Brown
David Rodan
Leigh Montagna
Jarrad Waite

Plus some interesting late/rookie picks
Mick Martyn
Paul Salmon
James Podsiadly
Mark Jamar
Quinten Lynch
Matthew Boyd
Aaron Sandilands
Ben Rutten
Tony Lockett
Scott Cummings
Aaron Lord

 

[Blackhawk42]

2001 will be very hard to pass. Talent everywhere

GAJ
Judd
Hodge
Mitchell
Bartel
Luke Ball
James Kelly
Steve Johnson
Dane Swan
Brian Lake

Then a pile of other players stiff to not make the top 10
David Hale
Ashley Sampi
Brent Reilly
Ash Hansen
Rick Ladson
Matt Maguire
Mark Seaby
Lewis Roberts Thomson
Campbell Brown
David Rodan
Leigh Montagna
Jarrad Waite

Plus some interesting late/rookie picks
Mick Martyn
Paul Salmon
James Podsiadly
Mark Jamar
Quinten Lynch
Matthew Boyd
Aaron Sandilands
Ben Rutten
Tony Lockett
Scott Cummings
Aaron Lord

2013 is still criminally overlooked.

Bontempelli
Cripps
Merrett
Sicily
Barrass
Josh Kelly
Salem
Impey
Matt Crouch
McStay
Hewett
Amon
Alex Pearce
Billings
Aish
Sheed
Luke MacDonald
J.Kolodjashnij
Acres
Lobb
Aliir
Byrne-Jones
Jayden Hunt
Charlie Cameron

Premiership players, All Australians and club captains everywhere.

Dane Rampe, Rory Laird, Jeremy McGovern and Zac Williams were all elevated off the rookie list in this draft as well.

 

[HTPunter]

Still early, but serious questions must be asked as to whether this will be the greatest draft of all time. Compare it to the drafts around it and there's no competition.

These players all look like being varying degrees of guns:

• Walsh
• Luko
• Rankine
• King bros
• Rozee
• Smith (down on output but his ceiling is very good)
• Blakey
• Butters
• Quaynor
• Hill
• Briggs

Plenty of other serviceable types as well, or players with a lot of potential.

2001 is generally regarded as the best of all time but could it be surpassed? Lou codge, Ablett jnr and Judd were pretty good.

6 norm smiths. 7 brownlows.

Plus cogs in multiple flags such as Kelly, Hale, LRT and single flags such as Boyd, Ball, Brown, Lynch, Hansen, Seaby.

Can’t see it being overtaken. Ablett, Judd, Hodge, Mitchell is the best quartet from one draft ever I’d say, with guys like Swan, Johnson, Bartel & Lake not in that conversation.

 

[HTPunter]

2013 is still criminally overlooked.

Bontempelli
Cripps
Merrett
Sicily
Barrass
Josh Kelly
Salem
Impey
Matt Crouch
McStay
Hewett
Amon
Alex Pearce
Billings
Aish
Sheed
Luke MacDonald
J.Kolodjashnij
Acres
Lobb
Aliir
Byrne-Jones
Jayden Hunt
Charlie Cameron

Premiership players, All Australians and club captains everywhere.

Dane Rampe, Rory Laird, Jeremy McGovern and Zac Williams were all elevated off the rookie list in this draft as well.

Bont and Cripps are still 2 & 3 flags respectively from even pushing the top 5 of the 2001 draft though

 

[Blackhawk42]

Bont and Cripps are still 2 & 3 flags respectively from even pushing the top 5 of the 2001 draft though

Oh absolutely, however the 2018 class is constantly talked up (with good reason), and yet I still rate 2013 higher. I think people just forget how significant that draft was to what the competition looks like right now.

 

[Drought Break]

2013 is still criminally overlooked.

Bontempelli
Cripps
Merrett
Sicily
Barrass
Josh Kelly
Salem
Impey
Matt Crouch
McStay
Hewett
Amon
Alex Pearce
Billings
Aish
Sheed
Luke MacDonald
J.Kolodjashnij
Acres
Lobb
Aliir
Byrne-Jones
Jayden Hunt
Charlie Cameron

Premiership players, All Australians and club captains everywhere.

Dane Rampe, Rory Laird, Jeremy McGovern and Zac Williams were all elevated off the rookie list in this draft as well.

Only Collingwood could stuff up 2 top 10 picks in this super draft.

 

[Blackhawk42]

Only Collingwood could stuff up 2 top 10 picks in this super draft.

Check out Carltons top 10 selections in the 2017 draft if you need a pick-me
up.

 

[Jonts]

Rozee the first to 2 AAs and Butters the first coaches MVP from 2018 draft class

 

[Papa G]

Top 3
Rozee 2x AA
Butters 1 x AA
Walsh 1 x AA

The rest

 

[demondavey]

Lukosius will be the one. He will turn into a multiple AA starting next year I reckon under Hardwick. Feel as though he will be one of the best players over the next 5 year period.

 

[Papa G]

Top 20 Based on what they have achieved so far

1. Z Butters
2. S Walsh
3. C Rozee
4. B King
5. B Smith
6. I Qaynor
7. N Blakey
8. I Rankine
9. M King
10. B Hill
11. J Rowebottom
12. L Schultz
13. J Clark
14. J Lukosius
15. C Idun
16. T Sparrow
17. L Vandermeer
18. N Answerth
19. J Caldwell
20. K Briggs

 

[Dazb86]

Top 20 Based on what they have achieved so far

1. Z Butters
2. S Walsh
3. C Rozee
4. B King
5. B Smith
6. I Qaynor
7. N Blakey
8. I Rankine
9. M King
10. B Hill
11. J Rowebottom
12. L Schultz
13. J Clark
14. J Lukosius
15. C Idun
16. T Sparrow
17. L Vandermeer
18. N Answerth
19. J Caldwell
20. K Briggs

For a supposedly 'good draft' this ones been a bit of a stinker.

 

[Papa G]

For a supposedly 'good draft' this ones been a bit of a stinker.

The 2017 Draft actually bats way deeper. From Pick 21 to 42 you have the following names: O Allen, N Balta, L Ryan, B Daniels, S Taylor, T De Koning, B Fritsch, T McCartin, H Petty, C Ballard.

 

[Freomaniac]

For a supposedly 'good draft' this ones been a bit of a stinker.

Not the worst draft since 2000.

I mean my dockers didn't do well in this draft. But there seems to be some solid players in this 2018 draft

 

[Orange crush]

Idun an absolute steal at 61

 

[SSSSSS]

Idun an absolute steal at 61

Some good players in the late picks.

Bedford was around pick 70 I believe (albeit as an NGA).

Wilkie, Butts and Atkins from the rookie list.

Keane and Callum Brown from Cat B.

 

[Ambrosia]

Some good players in the late picks.

Bedford was around pick 70 I believe (albeit as an NGA).

Wilkie, Butts and Atkins from the rookie list.

Keane and Callum Brown from Cat B.

Wilkie is a jet

 

[Bill Crouse]

Walsh: 1x AA, 1x B&F, 1x Gary Ayres
Rozee: 2x AA, 1x B&F
Blakey: 1x AA
Butters: 2x AA, 2x B&F, 1x AFLCA MVP
Hill: 1x Norm Smith
Wilkie: 1x AA, 1x B&F