Reid Still Best DIv 2 Player.

[brissyboy]

Reid had a dissapointing carnival but his lead up games where A+ he was injured in the carnival gutsy effort if you ask me. Also i remember the game that they QLD played agaignst THe Northern Knights Reid and Grimes (rated as a top ten prospect) played on eachother all game and eventually reid got the best of him even though his team was getting rolled by ten goals.

Rioli would be the other great prospect except for his fitness. i would probably rate it a zero out of one its absolutely shocking these days to play AFL footy you have to be fit. Rioli is a gun player but is he getting more hype because of his name??

there is also bird gun player but is already with sydney so.
and The other would be marlon motlop.

what do use all think??

 

[PinCushion]

Rioli > Reid.

Any day of the week.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Yep - I'd say that Tom Collier, Tom Bellchambers and Aaron Joseph would be pushing Reid as well as Cyril Rioli and Marlon Motlop. In fact, I've got four of them ahead of Reid.

 

[brissyboy]

Yeh collier maybe but joeseph no way Dayne Zorko is the same type of player as joeseph and zorko is a much better player.

Reid is more of a modern day footballer and has alot more potential than rioli and others mentioned above. dont get me wrong rioli is a gun but his fitness will let him down.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Completely disagree about Joseph, and I think come draft day, recruiters will agree with me.

 

[tarrantcantkick]

rioli - each club has a full time sport science staff which happen to be paid good money to get players fit enough to play AFL football. he WILL be drafted and he WILL get smashed in the period of his contract for fitness. he will step up or be shown the door but pass up a freak footballer at your own risk. first round pick IMO

 

[Sherminator.]

Rioli > Reid.

Any day of the week.

Hope Brissy pinch both at 8 and 25.

And Marlon Motlop at 41.

 

[HBF]

Reid would have to be right up there with Bellchambers and Collier IMO. Three pretty different players, and it will be interesting to see where they fall come draft day.