Revamp for National Cup

mighty tiges

Premiership Player
Aug 21, 2002
4,120
5,942
oneeyed-richmond.com
AFL Club
Richmond
Revamp for national cup

Caroline Wilson
The Age
June 26, 2012

THE AFL will radically redesign next year's Foxtel Cup with the national second-tier competition under fire from Victorian clubs and struggling for relevance among Fox Footy Channel's crowded Saturday line-up.

While the AFL has resisted pushes to abandon the competition - it has a contract with Foxtel for second-tier content for the remainder of the broadcast deal - the cup could be moved to a Tuesday night prime-time spot next season on Fox Footy.

AFL executive Simon Lethlean said the Foxtel Cup could also be halved with the 16-team competition cut to eight teams.

Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/revamp-for-national-cup-20120625-20yje.html#ixzz1yp7gD1P6
 

mighty tiges

Premiership Player
Aug 21, 2002
4,120
5,942
oneeyed-richmond.com
AFL Club
Richmond
No doubt there needs to be a change but it would be disappointing if the comp. was reduced to just 8 teams. It would deprive mostly the top NEAFL sides of testing themselves against the more traditional states' clubs. Morningside for instance wouldn't have qualified in an 8 team Foxtel Cup and they are now in the semis after being Port Adelaide. Neither would it prevent heavily one-sided clashes given Claremont flogged West Adelaide by 101 points this year. Moving games to the morning this year is what has hurt the Foxtel Cup. People don't have the habit of watching footy at any level at 10am or 11am.

I'm not sure how playing Tuesday night solves the BYE problem. No way can modern professional footballers play midweek games after a normal weekend league match anymore. They spend 2-3 days after a match just recovering from soreness and preparing their bodies so they are right to go the following weekend. It's not the old semi-pro Escort Cup days anymore. If the AFL means instead showing the Saturday games on tv on Tuesday nights that would struggle to attract an significant audience as well. People want live footy. You also still will have the BYE issue.

The other issue is the lack of a crowd. Playing so-called curtainraisers at AFL venues sometimes 6 or 7 hours beforehand just makes for a total lack of atmosphere and it doesn't help showing games on tv played in big empty stadiums. If they are now willing to make all Foxtel Cup games stand alone then they should also allow teams to play at their smaller home grounds so home club fans can at least go and tv viewers can hear some cheering and booing rather than crickets.
 
Jan 26, 2006
40,446
31,699
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
East Fremantle
N

I'm not sure how playing Tuesday night solves the BYE problem. No way can modern professional footballers play midweek games after a normal weekend league match anymore. They spend 2-3 days after a match just recovering from soreness and preparing their bodies so they are right to go the following weekend. It's not the old semi-pro Escort Cup days anymore. If the AFL means instead showing the Saturday games on tv on Tuesday nights that would struggle to attract an significant audience as well. People want live footy. You also still will have the BYE issue.

The other issue is the lack of a crowd. Playing so-called curtainraisers at AFL venues sometimes 6 or 7 hours beforehand just makes for a total lack of atmosphere and it doesn't help showing games on tv played in big empty stadiums. If they are now willing to make all Foxtel Cup games stand alone then they should also allow teams to play at their smaller home grounds so home club fans can at least go and tv viewers can hear some cheering and booing rather than crickets.

All three of the major leagues have byes anyway so there isn't really a problem with playing on tuesday.

I do agree that matches should be played at the Suburban grounds.
 

brucetiki

Guest of Her Majesty
Nov 7, 2002
24,839
17,139
Wentworth Detention Ctr
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Adelaide, Centrals
The only issue with playing at suburban grounds would be the TV set-up. While the ABC manages to do this well for the SANFL/WAFL/VFL, remember the problems Fox had doing a NAB Cup match from Eureka Stadium.
 

mighty tiges

Premiership Player
Aug 21, 2002
4,120
5,942
oneeyed-richmond.com
AFL Club
Richmond
Looks like the Thursday night Grand Final is a sign of things to come for the Foxtel Cup next year. Play the matches Thursday night most likely following the AFL team changes announcement to give to the comp. some prime time exposure rather than being hidden away on a Saturday morning as the comp. was this year. A better time and day to attract Pay TV viewers although the games will still suffer crowd wise at that time.
 

The_Sherrin

Debutant
Apr 3, 2012
115
14
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
With Sydney Swans Reserves and Brisbane Lions Reserves both making Grand Finals for their respected conferences, are the 2 AFL clubs eligible for the Foxtel Cup?

The problem is the VFL,SANFL and WAFL having AFL registered players on their lists, in the case of the NEAFL they don't. Morningside made the Semis with no (0) AFL registered players on the clubs list. It doesn't seem fair that the NEAFL is the poorer cousins to the VFL,SANFL and WAFL in general, then has to play the Foxtel cup against A VFL club that has upto 6 AFL players on the VFL team. Take the 6 AFL players off the VFL club and give them to the NEAFL club and watch the comp even up! The NEAFL is already at a disadvantage , so then why make it even more of a disadvantage? It doesn't make sense!
 

royaldave

Senior List
Jan 6, 2004
155
10
Perth
Other Teams
East Perth, Leeds United
While they could perhaps exclude AFL players to create a "fairer" playing field it would not help the tv ratings so don't expect that to happen.

I don't know if there's any ruling in place for AFL reserves sides, but given the way the lions etc have their "top up" players supplied it may not be practical for the NEAFL AFL reserves sides to compete in the foxtel cup so they may just opt out anyway.

As for the WAFL and SANFL there's a lot of movement afoot by the eagles, crows etc to get their own reserves sides together, so who know what the future holds..
 

kid_a

Club Legend
Apr 5, 2010
2,317
1,177
Perf
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Hammarby IF, East Freo, Glory
The AFL really need to tweak this comp to make it easier for fans to follow and relevant for the competing clubs' communities.
I think the 4 premiers (or as close to as possible, because of not allowing AFL clubs to compete) of the VFL,SANFL,WAFL and NEAFL all go straight through to the 2nd round.
The other 8 teams to qualify enter in the 1st round.
The four first round winners then advance to the 2nd round where from there until the final its staright knockout.
In rounds 1 and 2 the club who had finished higher in their respective leagues should host the game, whilst in the semi finals and final the team(s) which have a higher percentage (from their previous foxtel cup games) earn the right to play hosts.
Games to be played on Thursday Nights.
With the possibility of the final being played as a stand alone game on a sunday afternoon in early august, the AFL to have a split round at about this time thus leaving a sunday free of AFL football when the Foxtel Cup final will be played.
Somewhat of a gap between the rounds to allow clubs to adjust other fixtures.
As many matches as possible to be played (as close as possible) at competing clubs home grounds.
So using last year state league results, this season competition would look like this:

1st Round-
Match 1: Burnie (TSL 1st) v NT Thunder (NEAFL NC 2nd). Thursday May 2, 7.45pm (local)
Match 2: East Fremantle (WAFL 2nd) v North Adelaide (SANFL 3rd). Thursday May 9, 7.15pm local/8.45pm (SA)
Match 3: Werribee (VFL 3rd) v Swan Districts (WAFL 3rd). Thursday May 16, 7.45pm (local)
Match 4: West Adelaide (SANFL 2nd) v Williamstown (VFL 4th). Thursday May 23, 7.45pm (local)/8.15 (EST)

2nd Round-
Match 5: Port Melbourne (VFL 2nd) v winner match 1. Thursday Jun 6, 7.45pm (local)
Match 6: Queanbeyan (NEAFL 2nd) v winner match 2. Thursday June 13, 7.45pm (local)
Match 7: Norwood (SANFL 1st) v winner match 3. Thursday June 20, 7.45pm (local)/8.15pm (EST)
Match 8: Claremont (WAFL 1st) v winner match 4. Thursday June 27, 7.15pm (local)/9.15pm (EST)

Semi Finals-
Match 9: winner match 5 v winner match 6. Thursday July 4, 7.45pm (local)
Match 10: winner match 7 v winner match 8. Thursday July 11, 7.45pm (local)

Final-
Match 11: winner match 9 v winner match 10. Sunday August 4, 3pm (EST)

Total clubs from each league-
VFL- 3
SANFL- 3
WAFL- 3
NEAFL- 2
TSL- 1
I think with the format the comp would gain so much more exposure and interest, and clubs would be more inclined to really try and succeed in it.
 
May 30, 2006
17,516
10,292
Canberra
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Due to the naming of teams, there is already plenty of footy programming for Thursday nights.
I was surprised they went to Tuesday nights given the additional costs, but it is about as much a "dead night" for footy as you can get.
Monday night has review programs, MRP, etc. Thursday team selections and the like. That really leaves Tuesday and Wednesday needing the filler which, unfortunately, is about all this cup is seen as.
 

kid_a

Club Legend
Apr 5, 2010
2,317
1,177
Perf
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Hammarby IF, East Freo, Glory
yeah just used thursdays as an example, for reasons mentioned just above wednesdays could be more viable.
 
Jul 2, 2010
37,953
36,136
Adelaide
AFL Club
Carlton
With Sydney Swans Reserves and Brisbane Lions Reserves both making Grand Finals for their respected conferences, are the 2 AFL clubs eligible for the Foxtel Cup?

The problem is the VFL,SANFL and WAFL having AFL registered players on their lists, in the case of the NEAFL they don't. Morningside made the Semis with no (0) AFL registered players on the clubs list. It doesn't seem fair that the NEAFL is the poorer cousins to the VFL,SANFL and WAFL in general, then has to play the Foxtel cup against A VFL club that has upto 6 AFL players on the VFL team. Take the 6 AFL players off the VFL club and give them to the NEAFL club and watch the comp even up! The NEAFL is already at a disadvantage , so then why make it even more of a disadvantage? It doesn't make sense!

couldnt agree more. AFl listed players have their chance in the sun with the AFL, the foxtel cup is supposed to be about the next level.
 
Back