Review A Superstar Week1 Edge

Kahuna

Norm Smith Medallist
Suspended
Joined
Jan 23, 2006
Posts
5,927
Likes
11
Location
Adelaide, EAST SIDEEE
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Redbacks
Thread starter #1
Alright new thing that I am going to start up. Each week I will choose a Superstar and we will review them on three categories. First up in Edge.

1. Ring Skills Rate out of 40
Basically how good is the superstar in the ring. Are they boring are they always entertaining?. Can they change there style of wrestling to suit different opponents. Are they unexperienced and make too many mistakes at important parts in the match?

2. Mic Work give a rating out of 30
Is the Superstar boring on the mic? never feel confident on what they are saying? Do they have the ability to get over the fans with their mic work?

3. Potential give a rating of 30
Where do you see this superstar in 3 years time. Will they be main eventing Wrestlemania or not even be in the WWE. Will they evolve into a great superstar or will they just fade away.

At the end you will end up with a rating out of 100. I will average the results up and we will see who you believe is the best in the WWE.

PM me if there is a superstar that you really desperately feel must be done,.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

rota69

Club Legend
Joined
Nov 25, 2004
Posts
1,774
Likes
198
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Furies
#2
Kahuna said:
Alright new thing that I am going to start up. Each week I will choose a Superstar and we will review them on three categories. First up in Edge.

1. Ring Skills Rate out of 40
Basically how good is the superstar in the ring. Are they boring are they always entertaining?. Can they change there style of wrestling to suit different opponents. Are they unexperienced and make too many mistakes at important parts in the match?

2. Mic Work give a rating out of 30
Is the Superstar boring on the mic? never feel confident on what they are saying? Do they have the ability to get over the fans with their mic work?

3. Potential give a rating of 30
Where do you see this superstar in 3 years time. Will they be main eventing Wrestlemania or not even be in the WWE. Will they evolve into a great superstar or will they just fade away.

At the end you will end up with a rating out of 100. I will average the results up and we will see who you believe is the best in the WWE.

PM me if there is a superstar that you really desperately feel must be done,.
ring skills 35
mic work 25
potential 27
 

LukeParkerno1

Make me an Admin!
Joined
Sep 23, 2005
Posts
91,735
Likes
33,120
Location
Sydney
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Sydney Swans
#6
28- There is still room for improvement but he has played his character well in the last 12 months.

26- Good on the mic, but doesn't have a catchphrase and that is probally what he needs.

28- I think he has a lot of potential in the WWE if they use him right.
 
Joined
Nov 8, 2000
Posts
74,148
Likes
53,121
Location
Ask me tomorrow
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Cronulla, Dallas Cowboys, Forest
Moderator #7
Ring Skills - 35: Adaptable. He has come a long way from being basically a large cruiserweight. Can do ladder matches, plenty of aerial ability but also has the size to be credible when taking on and beating super heavyweight types. Has good finishing moves with the spear and the Edgecution and what not. Can do the submission moves, work on the mat, work in the air and work in backstage brawls. I'm leaving a little room for improvement in this but Edge isn't really lacking in too many ring skills IMO.

Mic Skills - 27: What's not to like? Has been heavily involved in feuds with all manner of superstars. As a face, he got a decent pop with his long hair, leather coat, rocking intros and his moves. He just needed a decent angle to cash in on it all. The affair with Lita has done that. Turned heel and now as the R Rated superstar, he entertains. Doesn't stumble over his words, has attitude and charisma and as a heel plays the devious role to perfection. Originally pegged by the WWE as a high mid carder/tag teamer, he seems to have worked his arse off to earn a stint as heavyweight champion.

Potential - 25: Hard to stay at the top too long unless your initials are H, H & H or you have an infallible gimmick like the Undertaker. Edge has the moves and the mic skills to reinvent himself but he will go through peaks and troughs. Has plenty of time left and more roles to play.
 

Jabso

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Apr 13, 2001
Posts
20,512
Likes
440
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Tottenham
#11
1. 32 - Better than average but I have never been a fan of his style. Does great in cage/ladder matches and so on. Pretty good "story telling" wise in matches.

2. 28 - He is very good at this and has improved out of sight. I took of at least one point just because I never rated his mic skills as a face.

3. 22 = Not as young as people think but stil has plenty of years left.

82/100.

90's - Very good, excellent, top of their business
80 - Great wrestler, certainly main event deserving
70 - Good, solid wrestler
60 - great, better than average but not one of the best
50 - average
lower = crap
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Top Bottom