Review Review v Collingwood

[Lazza16]

Lol come on. Negligible contact is reasonable but he knew exactly what he was doing.

Good decision I think......not much to it.

 

[PertRoosOsborne]

Not a big difference between the Waite fine and Cutler getting 2 weeks

Yep, very surprised Waite got off.

Walker rubbed out and Waite cleared is a big advantage for Norf this week.

 

[a mayes ing]

Starts around 3.18

1st time l seen it. That is ridiculous. Guy is injured and lions players are pushing into his shoulder. Disgrace imo

 

[3KZ is Football]

1st time l seen it. That is ridiculous. Guy is injured and lions players are pushing into his shoulder. Disgrace imo

Why have we re-opened this Pandora’s Box of Worms?

 

[Scubaveg]

1st time l seen it. That is ridiculous. Guy is injured and lions players are pushing into his shoulder. Disgrace imo

The guy choose to stay on the field, he waved away trainers and assistance. Just like any other player on the field in those circumstances. He made his choices and the boys treated him just like any other player.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[snooplions]

Witherden won the player of the round but personailly I thought Berry had the better game. In the second half of the game we were locked in our back half for a long period of time and I thought Witherden and co struggled to start any meaningful passages of play from the defensive 50.. Seemed like Berry really stood up when the pies were running over the top of us.

 

[Tom14]

Witherden won the player of the round but personailly I thought Berry had the better game. In the second half of the game we were locked in our back half for a long period of time and I thought Witherden and co struggled to start any meaningful passages of play from the defensive 50.. Seemed like Berry really stood up when the pies were running over the top of us.

Yeah I agree. I think the criticism Witho got on commentary and from blowhards like Finey has been way over the top but it wasn't his best game. Berry on the other hand was the only one winning the ball inside and set up two goals directly at least in the second half.

 

[jackess]

I often wonder if Berry plays forward in the first half to allow him to play a strong second half. Always seems to lift. Simliar to Tim Kelly.

 

[Bucking Beads]

I missed the game but I was just watching some highlights and it looked like young Starcevich had some very solid touches. Some good vision shown by him from what I did see.

 

[Rosscoe_666]

A different era but not as bad as what Chris Scott and Mal Michael did to Nick Riewoldt many moons ago.

Difference was that Riewoldt had gone off and had come back onto the ground, thus declaring himself fit to play. Zorks had only just gone down, so it was a very different scenario; Zorko also didn't cry.
BTW, I think it was Brad, not Chris.

 

[jackess]

10 Taylor Adams (COLL)
7 Jack Crisp (COLL)
4 Brodie Grundy (COLL)
3 Jordan De Goey (COLL)
2 Scott Pendlebury (COLL)
2 Levi Greenwood (COLL)
1 Harris Andrews (BL)
1 Dayne Beams (BL)

 

[Dylan12]

So all players related to the Beams trade got votes.

 

[jackess]

So all players related to the Beams trade got votes.

Yep, each of the 3 players they got as a result of that trade played better than our one.

 

[MacMum]

Darcy to have shoulder reconstruction tomorrow or wednesday....season over. Had scans today.

HUN

 

[jackess]

Darcy to have shoulder reconstruction tomorrow or wednesday....season over. Had scans today.

HUN

That's a shame. Might as well get him in for surgery and ready for pre-season.

 

[MacMum]

Agree....don't muck around, sort it out now.

 

[Tom14]

That's a shame. Might as well get him in for surgery and ready for pre-season.

Easily our most improved player and I think he'll be second in the b&f. Looking forward to more great things from him next year.

 

[jackess]

20 games is the most he's played in a season, 19 last year and 18 the year before.

 

[M Malice]

20 games is the most he's played in a season, 19 last year and 18 the year before.

Hopefully he continues the upward trajectory and plays 25-26 next season.

 

[Gadzorks]

Yep, each of the 3 players they got as a result of that trade played better than our one.

And this helps me deal with the beams leaving stuff - he was bought in by a crap administration that got so much wrong. Why would we expect it to be good for us in the long run?

 

[PattyKwasagun]

I genuinely don't think I would've given Beams a vote for that game. He got plenty of it but butchered it badly. I'd have Berry above him at least.

 

[jackess]

And this helps me deal with the beams leaving stuff - he was bought in by a crap administration that got so much wrong. Why would we expect it to be good for us in the long run?

We were unlucky with his injuries. He's physically not the player he used to be. Have no issues with what we gave up. deGoey probably wouldn't have hung around, pick 25 wasn't worth much and Crisp was out the door anyway and pretty replaceable.

Having 6 years of an A grade midfielder was pretty exciting at the time

 

[Gadzorks]

We were unlucky with his injuries. He's physically not the player he used to be. Have no issues with what we gave up. deGoey probably wouldn't have hung around, pick 25 wasn't worth much and Crisp was out the door anyway and pretty replaceable.

Having 6 years of an A grade midfielder was pretty exciting at the time

At the time I was all for it, but I was also excited about fev initially back in the day as well. Need to work on my fore- and now- sight.

Think I'm just a cranky bastard today- spent the day ferrying my son to surgeons for the third broken bone in 12 months. Hate Afl some days.

 

[dlanod]

I genuinely don't think I would've given Beams a vote for that game. He got plenty of it but butchered it badly. I'd have Berry above him at least.

I'm guessing Fagan --> Andrews, Buckley --> Beams.

 

[Cockliff38]

Buckley voted for Beams cause he was one of Collingwood's best