Rhyce Shaw = Captain

[F/D]

He is not captain material.



James Clement should get the capatincy after this season and Collingwood should let Nathan Buckley play freely and as a forward.

 

[Jabso]

He has the desire of a captain but I don't think he is big on leadership and obviously he's only a decent player, however if he were to become a good solid consistant player he'd be ok.
At 2007 if we have the 1 captain and 3 vice captain system it should be Clement captain and Fraser, Johnson, Rocca the vc's.

 

[WhyWilliams]

The whole captain debate is interesting. Bucks clearly has it for as long as he wants it and that is until he stops playing.

Anthony is the next best leader by so far and plays the hardest position on the ground.

If neither of them are around then lets talk about it but I hope that does not happen for 5 years.

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Rhyce Shaw = Captain

Love the thread.title

 

[FIGJAM]

I stand corrected. What about "Leon Davis = Captain"?

Please don't. It's been a heavy festive period and deleting threads is expending energy which I don't have!

 

[Stoney]

You want a captain who squibs contests? Shaw is your man



Good player, not captain material.

Do u suffer short term memory loss? U just said he 'squibs contests' and then 5 words later u say he's a 'good player'

any player who squibs a contest is far from good - maybe when u realise this ur football career might take off past the suburban level

 

[Lensen]

Do u suffer short term memory loss? U just said he 'squibs contests' and then 5 words later u say he's a 'good player'

any player who squibs a contest is far from good - maybe when u realise this ur football career might take off past the suburban level

Yeah, that Craig Bradley was a real dud.

Squibbed a hell of a lot of contests - but a star of the game.

 

[FIGJAM]

I just want Rhyce to at least equal his form of last year.

I'm not going to award him the captaincy just because he's worked on his guns during his stint on crutches!

On a side note TheClokes, can you please think before posting threads? This one and the Dale Thomas thread are embarrassing!

 

[The Majestic]

I just want Rhyce to at least equal his form of last year.

I'm not going to award him the captaincy just because he's worked on his guns during his stint on crutches!

On a side note TheClokes, can you please think before posting threads? This one and the Dale Thomas thread are embarrassing!

Could be worse I suppose.

 

[F/D]

Do u suffer short term memory loss? U just said he 'squibs contests' and then 5 words later u say he's a 'good player'

any player who squibs a contest is far from good - maybe when u realise this ur football career might take off past the suburban level

Sinclair squibs contests.





I classify him as a good player, neat skills and can be damaging off a HBF.



Thanks Mr.Racist

 

[Lensen]

I just want Rhyce to at least equal his form of last year.

I'm not going to award him the captaincy just because he's worked on his guns during his stint on crutches!

On a side note TheClokes, can you please think before posting threads? This one and the Dale Thomas thread are embarrassing!

Just to be clear, I'm in no way advocating Rhyce for the captaincy yet. No way is he near Clement, Rocca, Licuria, Burns, Holland etc.

Rather Shaw than Tarks or Josh though!

 

[Johnson#26]

Shaw does not 'squib' contests. Yes, he did at times in 2003, but he has improved a lot. Remember how he didn't shirk the issue when crunched by Mark Johnson on Anzac Day? Plenty of players would have heard the footsteps, like Shaw on GF day in 2003, but that is now behind him.

He is not yet an option/candidate for the captancy, but he could end up a very important player for us over the best part of the decade, using his run and pace to break the lines.

 

[adam69]

Could Rhyce Shaw one day be our Captain?

Something in me tells me he might.

Rhyce is not overly blessed with skill. Pace on the other hand he has an abundance of. when he's fit and working his butt off he's able to break into our best 22, let's not get carried away with a pre-season photo and start reading ability into a bit of bulk. He has matured well and is starting to improve his delivery thank f***. As he gains more experience he may well be viewed as an on field leader but not skipper..

 

[The Majestic]

You know it could have been much worse, he could have said Chad Morrison for captain.

 

[Murray]

You know it could have been much worse, he could have said Chad Morrison for captain.

Ouch!!!

 

[Hollow Knight]

Licuria should be the next Pie captain.

 

[FIGJAM]

You know it could have been much worse, he could have said Chad Morrison for captain.

[surpressedmemory]Who's Chad Morrison??[/surpressedmemory]

 

[The Majestic]

Maybe suggesting Morrison captain was a tad harsh

 

[The Majestic]

[surpressedmemory]Who's Chad Morrison??[/surpressedmemory]

Wait he wasn't the guy we delisted was he?

 

[Jabso]

Licuria should be the next Pie captain.

Licuria would make a great captain but he has been a bit unlucky with his timing. Clement or Rocca should take over after Buckley for a while and when they move on Licuria will only be a year or two away also and they may opt for a longer term captain. I don't know why Licuria hasn't been named a Vice Captain especially since Lockyer is still a VC.