Rich - Poor when it counts

[Hollow Knight]

That's a tough ? to ponder. Unlike Daniel Rich, Steele Sidebottom didn't impersonate Chuck Norris & go MIA (in September). 30 disposals on Bernie Vince, who was the inform player of the AFL, in a finals win & easily our best player.:

Awesome. Maybe you can rest Sidebottom all year, play Leon in the home and away season and then sub Sidebottom in for him come September.

As for Rich going missing in September...

Rich collects ball... pinpoint pass to Brown... goal.

Rich wins ball, clearance, goal.

Rich wins clearance, kicks to space... Bradshaw... goal.

All this while copping a hard tag from Andrew Walker. Who was tagging Sidebottom? Ahh no one... I see.

Rich doesn't play, Brisbane lose. Thanks for playing.

 

[Hollow Knight]

& if you take out Fremantle & the Geelong VFL squad, Rich wouldn't have received a Brownlow vote..

Interesting logic.

Give Rich a break... he's in his debut year and he's only 7 Brownlow votes away from being a better player than Dane Swan.

 

[The Panther]

Awesome. Maybe you can rest Sidebottom all year, play Leon in the home and away season and then sub Sidebottom in for him come September.

We're a fan of the Rotation policy at Collingwood. 2010 will bring Sidebottom playing all games (he is 6 months younger than the manchild) & show like Beams (the kid who should have been drafted by the QLD club) did in 09, another draft steel. All Rich has to look forward to is taking on Brisbane's midfield when Black, Power & co retire in the next 2 years

 

[MacMum]

Just wondering..

Did any 1st year melbourne players get two 3 votes last night?..Hhmm?

 

[Grimreepah]

& if you take out Fremantle & the Geelong VFL squad, Rich wouldn't have received a Brownlow vote..

If you need to exclude games to get across a point, maybe you need to consider whether your point is valid.

We're a fan of the Rotation policy at Collingwood. 2010 will bring Sidebottom playing all games (he is 6 months younger than the manchild) & show like Beams (the kid who should have been drafted by the QLD club) did in 09, another draft steel. All Rich has to look forward to is taking on Brisbane's midfield when Black, Power & co retire in the next 2 years

Can't have it both ways. Either we factor in physical development, in which case Redden has a lot more upside than Beams, or we ignore it, and Rich shits all over Sidebottom. Take your pick.

 

[The Panther]

If you need to exclude games to get across a point, maybe you need to consider whether your point is valid.

If you take out the St Kilda and Geelong games, Sidebottom had a very good finals series.

Maybe you need to talk to yourself to consider whether your point is valid

 

[Grimreepah]

Maybe you need to talk to yourself to consider whether your point is valid

Swoosh

OK then, if we include the games against St Kilda and Geelong, Sidebottom had a crap finals series. Happy now.

 

[Hollow Knight]

Panther is way out of his depth here.

He is struggling to grasp his own argument, let alone that of others.

 

[The Panther]

Panther is way out of his depth here.

Saying 1 is winning/losing an argument is the first sign of insecurity

 

[Grandmaster_B]

Perhaps I was a bit harsh on Daniel Rich.

He is more versatile than I gave him credit for.

After all he is not just poor when it counts, but he is poor when it doesn't count too.

 

[Wonaeamirri33]

Yeah, that's why every troll thread from these Bris Lions boys directed at us contains at least a page or two of continuous self-congratulation, to make them feel all safe and secure

 

[Hollow Knight]

Saying 1 is winning/losing an argument is the first sign of insecurity

I didn't say you were winning or losing. I simply said you were struggling.

Grim nailed you with your own logic. I notice you haven't responded.

 

[Grimreepah]

Perhaps I was a bit harsh on Daniel Rich.

He is more versatile than I gave him credit for.

After all he is not just poor when it counts, but he is poor when it doesn't count too.

Why are you trolling a first year player who has outperformed your entire list? Even Wonna admitted it makes you look silly.

 

[Hollow Knight]

Yeah, that's why every troll thread from these Bris Lions boys directed at us contains at least a page or two of continuous self-congratulation, to make them feel all safe and secure

Just like every thread has 20 posts by you saying the same thing over and over again? Maybe when you say things 30 times they might become true... but I won't hold my breath.

 

[Wonaeamirri33]

Even Wonna admitted it makes you look silly.

Well no I didn't, actually, but nice try...

 

[The Panther]

I didn't say you were winning or losing. I simply said you were struggling.

Grim nailed you with your own logic.

You said I was getting nailed, which is basically inferring losing an argument. As I said, saying 1 is losing/winning an argument is a sign of insecurity & an inability to debate. Typical of someone educated in Australia's redneck state.

You don't take out the Adelaide game, which your bosom buddy is trying to do. It clearly shows that Steele outperforms Rich when it matters most..

 

[Hollow Knight]

You said I was getting nailed, which is basically inferring a losing argument. As I said, saying 1 is losing/winning an argument is a sign of insecurity.

Where does avoiding questions altogether rate on your "signs of insecurity" list?

 

[Grimreepah]

Well no I didn't, actually, but nice try...

Your aversion to naming Melbourne players who have had a better year than Rich tells me that you think it is a point of embarrassment for the Melbourne Football Club and their supporters.

 

[Hollow Knight]

Since we're discussing signs of insecurity... where does waiting for a first year player to play 24 consecutive games without a rest just so you can pot him rate? Is the aforementioned insecurity heightened by the need to completely pretend that his match winning burst the previous week didn't happen?

Our 19 year old short-armed boy wonder has done much this year, but perhaps elliciting such a fear response from so many people is his greatest achievement yet.

BAM BAM!!!!

 

[Crimson Azure]

Why are you trolling a first year player who has outperformed your entire list? Even Wonna admitted it makes you look silly.

Stop defending Rich he has already surpassed what anyone expected of him by being able to scratch his own nose.

What I really can’t understand is why he is called T-Rex. They were an animal that was strong, respected & feared, there is obviously no comparison between the two other than there arms. I suggest that he be called Wallaroo as he small & in no way intimidating.

Please refer to the photo for reference:

Pretty in pink.

 

[Hollow Knight]

I reckon the average punter would find that Wallaroo considerably more intimidating than...

 

[The Panther]

first year player to play 24 consecutive games without a rest

The rest is irrelevant. All it says is that Brisbane have poor midfield depth.

 

[Crimson Azure]

The rest is irrelevant. All it says is that Brisbane have poor midfield depth.

Your right Rich is the poor mans Swan as his arms & legs are even shorter & torso makes up 75% of his height.

 

[Wonaeamirri33]

Just like every thread has 20 posts by you saying the same thing over and over again? Maybe when you say things 30 times they might become true... but I won't hold my breath.

Oh man... this just continues to get funnier

And how many times has LD posted the exact same post about Watts now? 1000 times would it be?

Not to mention the tidal wave of incredibly dull and turgid repetition about Watts, and the number of times you guys have done the same sniping about Jack Grimes' injuries now (classy )

Then there's the posting of the same inaccurate YouTube clip about Cale Morton continuously for a few months, and the endlessly repeated lame trolls about MFC - and even about individual posters... hell, you lot have run the same dodgy lines, childish namecalling etc. directly about me in one form or another for a very long time now...

 

[WA ROO]

Oh man... this just continues to get funnier

And how many times has LD posted the exact same post about Watts now? 1000 times would it be?

Not to mention the tidal wave of incredibly dull and turgid repetition about Watts, and the number of times you guys have done the same sniping about Jack Grimes' injuries now (classy )

Then there's the posting of the same inaccurate YouTube clip about Cale Morton continuously for a few months, and the endlessly repeated lame trolls about MFC - and even about individual posters... hell, you lot have run the same dodgy lines, childish namecalling etc. directly about me in one form or another for a very long time now...

Rinse and repeat