That and including Nahas and Edwards in there
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Richmond List Changes
- Thread starter richolovesgoal
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
That and including Nahas and Edwards in there
Many a time he was taken to task over suggesting we would have upward of 7 delistings and therefore it's not silly at all especially when you now consider that many are now claiming we haven't cut deep enough . He wasn't flawless but on this case he was certainly correct .
As for our list management , he most certainly wasn't/isn't on his own in thinking that we have room for improvement , this thread is evidence of people questioning our list management.
ha not by a long shot. laffy played a whole game and went statless.
santa was saying 7 main list delistings and we are only at 5 i think. derickx is being kept as insurance as you still need ruck depth with at least 4/5 players able to do the job at varying levels of development.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Cheers Flea , I was of the opinion he mentioned complete list changes ?
Barnzy
Brownlow Medallist
Why wasn't Tom Derickx delisted with them? Does nothing in the VFL all year. Has struggled to hold a spot in the ruck or up forward with Coburg so he was pushed back. Was a little better but barely VFL standard. This guy is 25 and was a mature aged pick up. 2nd year on the list. As far as I'm concerned Browne >>>>>> Derickx by a mile. At least Browne could dominate VFL.
Also, Browne is a better option than Graham but Angus was contracted from a previous poor deal from Craig Cameron on decent coin. White, McGuane also need to go.
Also, Browne is a better option than Graham but Angus was contracted from a previous poor deal from Craig Cameron on decent coin. White, McGuane also need to go.
- Apr 21, 2012
- 4,115
- 5,124
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Whoever's playing Carlton.
- Banned
- #107
Then we won't have looked very hard if that happens.Not if they are replaced with players less capable
R.F.C 4 life said:
I'm fairly confident McGoof wouldn't kick 30 in a year, spuds like him might kick 2 or 3 in dead rubbers againdst crap sides but they invariably go missing in the pressure of important games against good sides.
Second chance? More like 9th chance. Sick of these hanging on to these hacks forever. How worse can an unproven kid or state player be than a proven dud? Experienced at being crap ain't experience worth a damn in my book.
i would think he is on the pessemistic side of the argument i would have thought.
tigers of old 1980
Draftee
I Agree get rid of Gus and keep Browne
What about we trade McGuane and get thornton for Carl Just are thought I Would get J Russell he would be GOOD GET
Barnzy
Brownlow Medallist
Agree. Well said.
But this is Richmond. Duds like McGuane and White will probably stay.
i also would like browne over gus and would like to rookie him. as for tom we still need ruck depth plus considering he still has had only 2 years into the afl system(1 injured) so i would have thought this is the reason. plus he is also able to play in various positions as well. i would give him another year.
Barnzy
Brownlow Medallist
Depth is only useful if they can come and play a role well to a decent standard. As I said above Derickx even struggled at VFL level. He was gifted a couple AFL games late on and was hopeless. As a 25 year old that should spell immediate delist.
I will be staggered if he stays on the list, absolute staggered. Definition of a list clogger.
CallMeAl
All Australian
No he doesnt.
He told his manager to get him a new deal, if not at richmond then anywhere, as long as he is playing football.
That's not right Flea- he had nine disposals http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pg-richmond-tigers--michael-laffy - but he was one of the players I thought of that big Tom had to beat (if that's the right term).
Sorry Flea- I misread footywire as pointed out by DeaDay below- I can see the game you mean- he actually had two handpasses but gave away four free kicks- classic
He played three seasons prior to that, 26 games in all, but FootyWire only has stats for games from 1990.That's not right Flea- he had nine disposals http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pg-richmond-tigers--michael-laffy - but he was one of the players I thought of that big Tom had to beat (if that's the right term).
And I think he was the sub for that game anyway
I have to say Tom didn't do anything impressive!!!! nothing to catch the eye so to speak, nothing that made my nuts twitch!
- Jan 7, 2010
- 14,905
- 43,674
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Adelaide Strikers
Tom D has to be better than Richard Lounder.
Disappointed to see Turner delisted. Only played about 5 games this year because of injury and when he did play he showed a bit could have easily kept him on the list for another year.
peejay
Brownlow Medallist
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
WATIGE
Club Legend
I think you know me too well!!!!
Dr Tigris
Brownlow Medallist
Looks like a fairly major cleanout again. 9 at the first opportunity. Looking to trade a few more and see what else happens. So I wouldn't be surprised to see another 2 at least. You can't really cut everyone that isn't great every year. It'd be too disruptive.
The lucky ones are Gus and X. I would expect from that the tiges will go after a ruck or two from the state leagues this year.
It'll be an interesting trade and draft period. We are after depth in trades and mids in the draft by the look of it. Completely agree with that.
The lucky ones are Gus and X. I would expect from that the tiges will go after a ruck or two from the state leagues this year.
It'll be an interesting trade and draft period. We are after depth in trades and mids in the draft by the look of it. Completely agree with that.
peejay
Brownlow Medallist
the tree did kick 4 in a game , until X does that he is behind him.
Ty Esler
Tim Barling
Johnny Manton played 59 games for us for god sake.
Blaz
Cancelled
are further delistings going to be made?
Pat Contin - rookied again, if not a late/last round pick for the main list.
White - no trade value - anywhere, ever...and as for the person who suggested McGuane could realise a 2nd round pick...parallel universe, perhaps?
White - no trade value - anywhere, ever...and as for the person who suggested McGuane could realise a 2nd round pick...parallel universe, perhaps?
Similar threads
