Richmond Phantom Trading Thread

[mighty tiges]

Port Adelaide needs to know if the three way trade b/w itself, WCE and Richmond is still on.

 

[dascman03]

I may be in the wrong.... are we using priority picks or not. I thought we are, so i was going on the official list. If I am wrong, cancel the Matera trade as it needs to be re-negotiated.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Richmond doesnt have a clue what is going on

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Originally posted by dascman03
I may be in the wrong.... are we using priority picks or not. I thought we are, so i was going on the official list. If I am wrong, cancel the Matera trade as it needs to be re-negotiated.

Yes we are.

 

[NUCKLE]

Originally posted by dascman03
I may be in the wrong.... are we using priority picks or not. I thought we are, so i was going on the official list. If I am wrong, cancel the Matera trade as it needs to be re-negotiated.

Settle pettle.

The trade has been done. Either way you lose your second round pick Milne & Schwarze for Phillip Matera.

 

[mighty tiges]

Would this be any better rfc?

Pick 13 and B.Holland to Richmond
Pick 5, Pick 15 & Richardson to West Coast
Picks 11,23(or 25?) and Cousins to Port Adelaide.

 

[NUCKLE]

Originally posted by mighty tiges
Port Adelaide needs to know if the three way trade b/w itself, WCE and Richmond is still on.

I am still willing for the trade. But Richmond seem to want a KPP for the loss of Richo.

Maybe we can work it like this.

Pick 5, 15 & Richo to the Eagles
Pick 23 & Cousins to the Power
Pick 13 & Brent Staker to Richmond

WCE would be reluctant to give up Cousins, Staker & Pick 11 so they offer pick 23 instead.

 

[mighty tiges]

Originally posted by NUCKLE
I am still willing for the trade. But Richmond seem to want a KPP for the loss of Richo.

Maybe we can work it like this.

Pick 5, 15 & Richo to the Eagles
Pick 23 & Cousins to the Power
Pick 13 & Brent Staker to Richmond

WCE would be reluctant to give up Cousins, Staker & Pick 11 so they offer pick 23 instead.

Port is not willing to give up all 3 first round picks in the deal.

 

[NUCKLE]

Originally posted by mighty tiges
Port is not willing to give up all 3 first round picks in the deal.

Change it then.

Pick 5, Pick 15 & Richo ----> WCE

Pick 23 (WCE) & Staker -----> Richmond

Pick 25 (RICH) & Cousins -----> Port

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Richmond asks the question:

Is Staker #23 worth Richardson and #25?

 

[mighty tiges]

Originally posted by NUCKLE
Change it then.

Pick 5, Pick 15 & Richo ----> WCE

Pick 23 (WCE) & Staker -----> Richmond

Pick 25 (RICH) & Cousins -----> Port

Pick 13 (Port) and B.Holland (Port) to Richmond
Pick 5 (Port), Pick 15 (Port) & Richardson (Rich) to West Coast
Picks 11 (WCE) , 25 (Rich) and Cousins (WCE) to Port Adelaide.

 

[Russian]

Here's the original draft list which means Kangaroos traded 24 to West Coast and beyond

PRIORITY
1 W/Bulldogs
2 Carlton
3 Melbourne

ROUND 1
4 W/Bulldogs
5 Melbourne
6 Richmond
7 Geelong
8 St Kilda
9 Kangaroos
10 Hawthorn
11 West Coast
12 Fremantle
13 Essendon
14 Adelaide
15 Pt Adelaide
16 Sydney
17 Collingwood
18 Brisbane

ROUND 2
19 W/Bulldogs
20 Melbourne
21 Richmond
22 Geelong
23 St Kilda
24 Kangaroos
25 Hawthorn
26 West Coast
27 Fremantle
28 Essendon
29 Adelaide
30 Port Adelaide
31 Sydney
32 Collingwood
33 Brisbane

ROUND 3
34 W/Bulldogs
35 Carlton
36 Melbourne
37 Richmond
38 Geelong
39 St Kilda
40 Kangaroos
41 Hawthorn
42 West Coast
43 Fremantle
44 Essendon
45 Adelaide
46 Pt Adelaide
47 Sydney
48 Collingwood
49 Brisbane

ROUND 4
50 W/Bulldogs
51 Carlton
52 Melbourne
53 Richmond
54 Geelong
55 St Kilda
56 Kangaroos
57 Hawthorn
58 West Coast
59 Fremantle
60 Essendon
61 Adelaide
62 Pt Adelaide
63 Sydney
64 Collingwood
65 Brisbane

 

[NUCKLE]

Originally posted by mighty tiges
Pick 13 (Port) and B.Holland (Port) to Richmond
Pick 5 (Port), Pick 15 (Port) & Richardson (Rich) to West Coast
Picks 11 (WCE) , 25 (Rich) and Cousins (WCE) to Port Adelaide.

WCE will not give up Cousins with a 1st & 2nd round pick and I am sure that Richmond do not want B. Holland back.

 

[NUCKLE]

Originally posted by rfctigerarmy
Richmond asks the question:

Is Staker #23 worth Richardson and #25?

Richmond stated that they wanted a KPP & 2nd round pick for Richo and they get it in this deal.

Staker is a young up & comer and pick 23 is early in the second round WCE thinks Richmond is trying to delay the deal waiting for something better.

WCE will also offer Morrison with Staker & pick 23 if that is more to the liking of the other clubs.

 

[mighty tiges]

Originally posted by NUCKLE
WCE will not give up Cousins with a 1st & 2nd round pick and I am sure that Richmond do not want B. Holland back.

WCE would be giving up Cousins and a 1st round pick for Richo and two 1st round picks. Not your 2nd round pick as well.

Replace Holland with A.Morgan (194cm) then.

 

[NUCKLE]

Originally posted by mighty tiges
WCE would be giving up Cousins and a 1st round pick for Richo and two 1st round picks. Not your 2nd round pick as well.

Replace Holland with A.Morgan (194cm) then.

WCE agree to the proposed deal.

That sees the Eagles lose Cousins & pick 11

but gain pick 5, pick 15 & Matthew Richardson

The deal is pending on the approval of Richmond & Port

 

[mighty tiges]

Originally posted by NUCKLE
WCE agree to the proposed deal.

That sees the Eagles lose Cousins & pick 11

but gain pick 5, pick 15 & Matthew Richardson

The deal is pending on the approval of Richmond & Port

Pick 13 (Port) and B.Holland/A.Morgan (194cm) (Port) to Richmond
Pick 5 (Port), Pick 15 (Port) & Richardson (Rich) to West Coast
Picks 11 (WCE) , 25 (Rich) and Cousins (WCE) to Port Adelaide.

Port Agree.

Lose 5, 13, 15, Holland or Morgan

Gain 11, 25 and Cousins.

Waiting on Richmond

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Fine.. deal...

Holland BTW.

 

[waspy]

Originally posted by rfctigerarmy
wapsy Im interested in Manton and Beaumont

who r u willing to trade for them
give me a list of youg tradeable players and i'll pick


...by the way
livingstone ----->dogs,
simon wiggins, pick 34 ------>blues

tank and i agreed to this yesterday

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Originally posted by waspy
who r u willing to trade for them
give me a list of youg tradeable players and i'll pick

Richmond Trade Bait:

Craig Biddiscombe (M/B)
Marc Dragicevic (B)
Tim Fleming(M)
Rory Hilton (B/F)
Adam Houlihan (F)
Chris Hyde (M)
Andrew Mills (B)
Bill Nicholls(F)
Kayne Pettifer (F)
Royce Vardy (B/F)

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Anyone interested in Rodan and Krakouer?

 

[dascman03]

Waspy

Lawrence and Wulf for Livingston????

 

[waspy]

manton and beaumont for fleming and vardy

 

[waspy]

Originally posted by dascman03
Waspy

Lawrence and Wulf for Livingston????

livingstone has already been traded...

anyone else u want though?

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Originally posted by waspy
manton and beaumont for fleming and vardy

Hilton/Nicholls instead of Flem?