Remove this Banner Ad

Richmond's most useless

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Originally posted by tigermania
David Honeybun, Andy McKellar, Jackson (from West Coast), Matthew Dundas, Donati

That is awesome. Five of the most unco-ordinated players ever. We are just a revolving door for circus freaks.

What was that guys name that played full back in the mid-late eighties? Quite stocky, slightly balding. Ablett used to have a field day on him. Should never have pulled boots on.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Originally posted by Otto's ladder

What was that guys name that played full back in the mid-late eighties? Quite stocky, slightly balding. Ablett used to have a field day on him. Should never have pulled boots on.


Was it Notting ???? Dean I think.
 
Todd Menegola ....... now there is a man who has slipped though all your nets . Came over from WA with huge fanfare . Was barely up reserve grade standard but they had to give him a few games just to try and save themselves comlete embarassment .

Drum Roll............... and the prize for the worst player to play 100 games goes to ............. AAAAAAAAAAAAndy Goodwin ( clap )

John Mrakov Michael Roberts ( yes the newsreader )

Tim Gepp Athos Hyrousilakis ( have i spelt it right ?)

Todd Breman Steven O` dwyer

It`s scary when you really think about it
 
Originally posted by IDGAF
Drum Roll............... and the prize for the worst player to play 100 games goes to ............. AAAAAAAAAAAAndy Goodwin ( clap )


Just beat me to that one IDGAF ... I was just in the process of posting Andy Goodwin when I had a quick glance at your post.

Total nuffy.
 
Originally posted by IDGAF
Todd Menegola ....... now there is a man who has slipped though all your nets . Came over from WA with huge fanfare . Was barely up reserve grade standard but they had to give him a few games just to try and save themselves comlete embarassment .

Drum Roll............... and the prize for the worst player to play 100 games goes to ............. AAAAAAAAAAAAndy Goodwin ( clap )


aghhh Andy G, unfortuanetly never had the ability to meet his ambitions, never fault enthusiasm, I have a feeling he still plays local footy...I get more frustrated at the likes of strawbs O'dwyer, Brennan, BLUMFIELD that all came to RFC with at least some semblance of a reputation only to be worse than the likes of Goodwin....In recent times it's good fortune rather than good management that some youngsters actually defy the environment they're in and succeeds
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Originally posted by IDGAF

Drum Roll............... and the prize for the worst player to play 100 games goes to ............. AAAAAAAAAAAAndy Goodwin ( clap )


watched him play for Wandin in a grand final a few years ago.

Won the game off his own boot believe it or not.

I remember reading the Fleas book and he basically said we would never win a flag with players like Goodwin in it.

Who Remembers his last game playing in the two's for Melbourne in a GF. He went absoulutly crazy.
 
Just wondering if the likes of messrs. Laffy, Lounder, Goodwin, Menegola et al are into Big Footy and have read this????

Come on Spud, bet you've had a peek and could offer some nominations from the current list... do tell!
 
Originally posted by Fishfinger
I'm with froars & rfcta.

CJH, Adam Slater kicked a bag of goals for East Burwood a couple of weeks ago. Someone was probably swinging his leg for him.

I've posted this before, I was at a game where we were getting flogged and a dog ran onto the field. A bloke in front of me was screaming his head off at the Richmond bench to leave the dog on and take Laffy off.:D

I laughed the 2nd time I read this as much as the 1st.

Peter Czerkaski and Gary Frangalas for me.

Andy Goodwin was one of the few bright spots for me. I think he was one of our most reported players. He wasnt there to play footy, just to thump players.

I wont forget the game where Dermott Brerton knocked Czerkaski out cold and they stretchered him off. On came Goodwin who didnt even wait until the ball went up the other end of the ground. He just thumped Brereton on the spot and knocked him on his ars.

It was for these moments we kept going to the footy every week, and Andy rarely disappointed me.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Originally posted by Leper
Just wondering if the likes of messrs. Laffy, Lounder, Goodwin, Menegola et al are into Big Footy and have read this????

Come on Spud, bet you've had a peek and could offer some nominations from the current list... do tell!

Spud wouldn't have to think hard. He could nominate 95% of the current crop he coaches.
 
Ian Satori - definetly the worst richmond player i have seen in 30 years of watching the tigers.

followed by the two H's

Ian Herman
Wayne Herneman

then

Chris Pym
David Williams (ex demon)
another williams guy - No:28 back in the 80's
Todd Mengola

I'll come up with some more.

P.S. David Honeybun does not belong on this list. as mentioned played some very good games until his back went. Remember the story that he had to lie down in the back of benny Gales S/wag all the way to Geelong. Jurica kicked 5 followed by a 4 in succesive weeks.
 
Originally posted by 1980GFVideo
Ill be nobody remembers these names.......

Robert Schaefer

Ian Scrimshaw

Schaefer - number 27, came from adelaide

Scrimshaw - number 36 - a real hack. - came from Hawthorn.

hey what about Kim Kershaw !!!!!!!
 
Originally posted by 1980GFVideo
Ill be nobody remembers these names.......

Robert Schaefer

...

He was one of the many ruckmen we managed to trade to Collingwood. I think there were 4 altogether in the 90's before they finally wised up! From what I remember, he made David Bourke look like Arnie Schwarzenegger!


The ruckmen we traded to Collingwood are Schaefer, Brad Smith, Matthew Francis and Stunning Steve McKee.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Richmond's most useless

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top