AFL Toast RND 10: Dreamtime Winning

[rumply]

I don't know what I'm supposed to be looking at... you're allowed to spoil, you're allowed to play the ball, and incidental contact happens.

With the way the MRO has been adjudicating lately there might be some trouble, but I don't think it's even a free kick otherwise.

That said, you'd hope Drapes would have the hands to stick a mark like that in future.

There was no spoil though, just a straight whack to the head is all I see there.

 

[jmoo wan]

I don't know what I'm supposed to be looking at... you're allowed to spoil, you're allowed to play the ball, and incidental contact happens.

With the way the MRO has been adjudicating lately there might be some trouble, but I don't think it's even a free kick otherwise.

That said, you'd hope Drapes would have the hands to stick a mark like that in future.

you’re looking at high contact there Lore - it’s a free kick, you can’t just smack campaigner’s in the head with reckless abandon during a marking contest and expect the umpire to wave his hands and call play on

 

[Lore]

There was no spoil though, just a straight whack to the head is all I see there.

Definitely spoiled

 

[HirdsTheWord]

yeah s**t

u dont see us doing that often. wow

 

[Mr Bultitude]

Definitely spoiled

View attachment 1693016

Not sure it is. Looks like Draper fumbles the mark, ball slips from his hands and Neanderthal Nank spoils air straight into Draper, which makes it understandable the call was play on.

But then again, Tigers show creativity in their grubbiness...

 

[Zephyr Effekt]

 

[Lore]

Not sure it is. Looks like Draper fumbles the mark, ball slips from his hands and Neanderthal Nank spoils air straight into Draper, which makes it understandable the call was play on.

But then again, Tigers show creativity in their grubbiness...

Smacking the ball away from a marking contest is still a spoil, regardless of Draper's skill execution

Also I'm pretty sure high contact is adjudicated differently in a marking contest, given the number of people jumping on their opponents' heads and stuff that never get pinged. There are countless times every week with hands and faces colliding that are regarded as either negligible contact (below the threshold for a report) or a footballing action.

Probably one day the speccy will be banned for concussion reasons but as it currently stands I don't think it's inconsistent to let that go. It would have to fall under an 'unreasonable attempt' before it would become problematic.

 

[Mr Bultitude]

Smacking the ball away from a marking contest is still a spoil, regardless of Draper's skill execution

Also I'm pretty sure high contact is adjudicated differently in a marking contest, given the number of people jumping on their opponents' heads and stuff that never get pinged. There are countless times every week with hands and faces colliding that are regarded as either negligible contact (below the threshold for a report) or a footballing action.

Probably one day the speccy will be banned for concussion reasons but as it currently stands I don't think it's inconsistent to let that go. It would have to fall under an 'unreasonable attempt' before it would become problematic.

Def agree, it wasn't a free. Just enjoy finding a reason to use "Neanderthal Nank".

 

[Dave]

First time in 6 years I've been able to go to the match as I'm usually interstate. Amazing. Pre game entertainment was fantastic. The game was a great contest although wasn't especially skilful - so many turnovers. Was great to see the team persevere and get a win. Lost my voice. Couldn't sleep until 3am.

Up the Planes!!!

 

[Dave]

That bounce we got coming into the 50, when 3 of our players were lagging behind 3 of theirs.
SO LUCKY.

Was AFT the way it had bounced up 'til then.

 

[Mootsy]

He was rough like that for the whole game, didn’t like it to be fair.

 

[Dave]

OMG Mansell's miss.

Was sweet after the spray he gave Red Dog.

 

[tugga]

Well done to your players and coaching staff.
no whining about injuries, just rolled up their sleeves, went to work and got the job done.
unlike those at Geelong who did nothing but piss and moan and offer excuses.
respect.

 

[Dave]

Did anyone else say "handy point" when Tippa kicked that point?

"Seven point play" is my go to.

 

[Dave]

What a beautiful morning. How good is footy?

I love it.

 

[Darealrath]

He was rough like that for the whole game, didn’t like it to be fair.

Nank is probably my most disliked player in the league. Loves giving out cheap shots to players with their eye on the ball or already wrapped up in tackles.

 

[tha Freak]

Win the next 2 games(eagles/Nth) then get strengthen up with some in’s for Carlton, and win that. Go to 8/5 for the bye, that’s something to build on!

 

[mcgrath_truther]

He was rough like that for the whole game, didn’t like it to be fair.

he's been like that for years imo, he's a brute

 

[Yoda_]

Nankervis is a genuine grub with cheap shots and clumsiness made famous by big Shane Mumford

41

Shane Mumford

Age

37

Ht

198cm

Wt

105kg

Pos.

Ruck

Career

Season

Last 5

D

10.9

3star

K

3.0

1star

HB

8.0

5star

CL

3.0

4star

HO

29.9

5star

D

7.3

2star

K

1.3

1star

HB

6.0

3star

CL

2.3

4star

HO

18.5

5star

D

6.2

2star

K

1.6

1star

HB

4.6

4star

HO

12.4

5star

 

[outersanctum]

I work with a young fella, big tigers fan.. he doesn't watch any other games other than tigers games.. and thus reached his 10th birthday and had never seen us win. That makes this win special.

Building respect within the group is about making moments matter, games matter, kicks matter.. efforts matter. I think it is fitting that it was Merretts lunging, diving, 150% effort to try to slow down Martin that started a chain that resulted in us winning the game. If Merrett doesn't take complete and utter ownership of that moment.. Martin strolls away and probably slots the 'sealer' and leaves us lamenting our luck for yet another year. If Merrett didn't make up the ground, you wouldn't judge.. he had no right to make the ground, against a contested beast.. in the last minute of a game where he was 'best on'.. that is when personal integrity, group accountability and sheer heart come forward. That is the greatness that defines careers.. Merrett made himself accountable and it paid off.

So yeah.. its a win and we are still a long way from being a top team.. so we can't read too much into it.. but watching our captain leave it all out there gives me hope. Watching ridley actually be in the right spot and then give the correct release to redman who moved it decisively forward and we have a structure ahead of the ball.. seeing Stringer actually hit the top of the goal square instead of go for the freak goal.. point to a team of discipline. A team that understands it is about the collective.

So yep.. this one is special. Very special.

 

[Wahooti Fandango]

 

[rumply]

Definitely spoiled

View attachment 1693016

not totally convinced

 

[mike14]

Watching back through the highlights and we directly handed them 4 goals through poor disposal in our backline (Redman to Walla miss, Caldwell with the nothing snap, McGrath handball miss, McGrath kick miss). That's almost half their goal total that can be erased if we can find a way to take that next step in our disposal and decision making (noting we'll never play 100% mistake free footy). SO between us, and the paid mark that hit the deck that's 5 of their 10 goals that really shouldn't have occurred. We do make things hard for ourselves.

We also improved to 5-1 in Dreamtime games where we've had a Davey on the field

 

[fishardansin]

The Mrs wants a bit of action. I told her I'd be there in a minute and watched the mini match of last night on Kayo. It's just ended ... wish her luck folks.

 

[IggypopsTshirt]

Good evening,

My name is Iggy and I’m an addict.
I cannot stop watching the replay of the final 2 minutes of the 2023 Dreamtime game.