Opinion RND 5 - Changes v Hawthorn

[The Falcon Strike]

Sheed and Karps are emergencies.

Still think there'll be another change.

Wellingham dicey I'd reckon

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Wellingham dicey I'd reckon

Maybe two changes then. We're too tall, especially with rain forecast.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Concerned that our best young midfielder can't even get a game with Mitchell out.

The podcast nailed it, he won't improve that defensive side of his game at WAFL level. Sheed simply has to be playing, simple as that.

 

[Ochre]

The podcast nailed it

Nah.

 

[Ochre]

Hearing Naitanui could be a late in for <whoever our shortest player is>

 

[numbat06]

Concerned that our best young midfielder can't even get a game with Mitchell out.

The podcast nailed it, he won't improve that defensive side of his game at WAFL level. Sheed simply has to be playing, simple as that.

Weow! he isn't our best young midfielder though, he wouldn't make a lot of teams midfields at the moment.
Don't understand the hate for Darling either.

 

[Chris_6678]

Concerned that our best young midfielder can't even get a game with Mitchell out.

The podcast nailed it, he won't improve that defensive side of his game at WAFL level. Sheed simply has to be playing, simple as that.

Barrass had the same problem last year and it worked out well for him. I do want Sheed in the side but we at least have Duggan in so lets hope he has good game!

I really want us to drop a tall as the Hawks are not tall and there is a chance of it raining and we all know how well we do in the rain!

 

[avishka5]

Weow! he isn't our best young midfielder though, he wouldn't make a lot of teams midfields at the moment.
Don't understand the hate for Darling either.

who do you rate as our best kid?

Alot of teams would take sheeds 2015 impact and i don't think sheed regressed either. He was injured for majority of last season as well. Sheed theorectically should be in there for duggan or even redden. He ain't gonna improve at WAFL level either.

 

[numbat06]

who do you rate as our best kid?

Alot of teams would take sheeds 2015 impact and i don't think sheed regressed either. He was injured for majority of last season as well. Sheed theorectically should be in there for duggan or even redden. He ain't gonna improve at WAFL level either.

2015 was awhile ago, his form hasn't been that since, we just have too many of the same sort of players through the middle hence why Duggan is getting a game. But Sheed should definitely be given a game before Hutchings.

 

[donpyke92]

Sheed in for Mitchell.
One of Giles/Vardy out for Darling.
I'd prefer Vardy to stay, Gov stay forward, stints back as appropriate. Gov/Darling chop out for Vardy in the ruck.
Vardy more mobile with wet conditions forecast.

 

[ziad]

Weow! he isn't our best young midfielder though, he wouldn't make a lot of teams midfields at the moment.
Don't understand the hate for Darling either.

well said- if he is that good perform

 

[wraglesweb]

Very tall for the MCG is a bit concerning !

 

[Quinz]

Don't like the selection. If we get torched at ground level it'll be a clear error by the match committee.

 

[avishka5]

2015 was awhile ago, his form hasn't been that since, we just have too many of the same sort of players through the middle hence why Duggan is getting a game. But Sheed should definitely be given a game before Hutchings.

dont believe he has regressed tho. He played some good games end of last year but was inconsistent due to lack of fitness. This year he had a decent preseason and had a bad opening game which isnt too surprising.

IMO he should be playing but like TB last year I think MC really want him to be hungry when he returns that they get him going a level/2 and really playing at a consistent level. The defensive bit might just be something minimal. But on the other side i think playing for the rabble that is ep might do the opposite.

 

[Keys]

Don't like the selection. If we get torched at ground level it'll be a clear error by the match committee.

This

Replacing a mid with a forward who plays tall makes no sense. Playing a tall side on the MCG hasn't worked for us in the past and if we get exposed at ground level team selection will be part of the problem

Unless there's a late change on the cards with Sheed coming in for one of the talls

 

[domo]

What about playing on 20m out from goal and getting caught? what about leading out; spilling a mark and stopping and looking at the umpire expecting ,and not getting , a free?Thats just one game!!Has all the physical attributes but serious heartlidge problems.

what about his ninja flips!!?
that is all

 

[Biggie]

This

Replacing a mid with a forward who plays tall makes no sense. Playing a tall side on the MCG hasn't worked for us in the past and if we get exposed at ground level team selection will be part of the problem

Unless there's a late change on the cards with Sheed coming in for one of the talls

I am at odds at to the selection. Mind boggling.

 

[Godfather32]

I am at odds at to the selection. Mind boggling.

Is it really though or is it just another in a long line of shit team selections by a bunch of people who don't know what they're doing?

 

[Biggie]

I'm not how we keyboard warriors and hardened couch sitters can continue to see this and they can't?

I just don't know.

 

[Godfather32]

I'm not how we keyboard warriors and hardened couch sitters can continue to see this and they can't?

I just don't know.

Maybe it'll work and we'll smash them....maybe....

 

[Biggie]

Maybe it'll work and we'll smash them....maybe....

Lets see how it goes....

Birchall is a massive out for them, his is very precise out of the back half.

 

[Crimson King]

Really poor team balance. Selected team is something straight outta Woosha's playbook of "lets load up with talls as we will overwhelm them with our aerial prowess". Never really worked.

 

[Biggie]

Really poor team balance. Selected team is something straight outta Woosha's playbook of "lets load up with talls as we will overwhelm them with our aerial prowess". Never really worked.

Carbine Chaos thread may be "woken up" this week.

 

[Godfather32]

Lets see how it goes....

Birchall is a massive out for them, his is very precise out of the back half.

Yeh and they have been pretty rubbish so far

 

[Biggie]

Yeh and they have been pretty rubbish so far

So we have zero excuses

Gee whiz we can put paid to some real doubts the players will no doubt have playing at the G this week....we simply must run them into ground.