Preview Rnd 6 - Carlton v Hawthorn Sunday April 28th 3.20PM @ UTAS - Team Post #1331

[cfc4life]

Hell yeah Cunners

 

[Opine]

JSOS and Simmo unlikely to be omitted; unless injured. Therefore Cas and Polson most likely to make way: though won't be overly surprised if Charlie doesn't get up and Cas remains.

 

[Eiffel 65]

Extended interchange bench:

Simpson
Garlett
Casboult
Silvagni
Cuningham
Kennedy
Polson
Charlie

That's the way I'd go into the match. Casboult unlucky to miss out but we can't have too many tall forwards.

 

[btdg]

All 4 ins named on bench for us, along with Polson, Casboult, Silvagni. Suggest either we aren’t clear on who will play or we don’t want them to know. O’Brien names on the field at half forward. Could still be out, of course.

Ins for them interesting too. Ceglar being named suggests more to Mcevoy’s injury than they are letting on, even if he is just a precaution. Shiels is also on the extended bench. Stratton named, so likely playing.

 

[HBF]

Like the ins, just hope we don't go in too tall like we did against GC.

 

[Dadda Dave]

This is the extended bench:

• 6 Kade Simpson
• 41 Levi Casboult
• 28 David Cuningham
• 1 Jack Silvagni
• 21 Jarrod Garlett
• 7 Matthew Kennedy
• 30 Charlie Curnow
• 29 Cameron Polson

Simpson and Silvagni won't get dropped.

So it's 2 of:

• 41 Levi Casboult
• 28 David Cuningham
• 21 Jarrod Garlett
• 7 Matthew Kennedy
• 30 Charlie Curnow
• 29 Cameron Polson

Logical choices are Cuningham and Charlie.

Polson out .Cuners in..
How will we fit them all in after last week.??

 

[Mr_Plow]

Polson out .Cuners in..
How will we got them all in after last week.??

Casboult is likely the casualty if Curnow is named and healthy. There really isn't another option on that bench to drop.

 

[GPep]

can a player selected in the 18 be omittedor do they have to be from the interchange players? I hate podding players but I don’t believe LOB is ready yet....in time yes but he needs to build his hardness

 

[Mr_Plow]

But I think at this stage, the only certain change is Cuningham for Polson. Imagine Charlie is still a wait and see.

 

[Dadda Dave]

Casboult is likely the casualty if Curnow is named and healthy. There really isn't another option on that bench to drop.

We're starting to get some handy depth and a healthy list ..

 

[Mr_Plow]

can a player selected in the 18 be omittedor do they have to be from the interchange players? I hate podding players but I don’t believe LOB is ready yet....in time yes but he needs to build his hardness

It's unusual for that player to be dropped, he's essentially holding Williamson's spot until he is ready, which is hopefully next week.

 

[Soapy V]

My guess: Casboult Simpson Silvagni & Charlie if fit. If not Cuningham for Polson

Only one change which is right

PS Williamson not even named in squad yet and LOB in the 18. What a surprise

 

[Opine]

Reckon there'll end up being a single change; Cunners for Polson. Though if Charlie comes up Cas will make way for him.

 

[Mr_Plow]

We're starting to get some handy depth and a healthy list ..

If Cuningham and Curnow are named, that is our strongest squad in years.

 

[Eiffel 65]

This is the extended bench:

• 6 Kade Simpson
• 41 Levi Casboult
• 28 David Cuningham
• 1 Jack Silvagni
• 21 Jarrod Garlett
• 7 Matthew Kennedy
• 30 Charlie Curnow
• 29 Cameron Polson

Simpson and Silvagni won't get dropped.

So it's 2 of:

• 41 Levi Casboult
• 28 David Cuningham
• 21 Jarrod Garlett
• 7 Matthew Kennedy
• 30 Charlie Curnow
• 29 Cameron Polson

Logical choices are Cuningham and Charlie.

I completely agree, but I have a feeling they'll select Polson.

 

[Mr_Plow]

My guess: Casboult Simpson Silvagni & Charlie if fit. If not Cuningham for Polson

Only one change which is right

I don't believe Charlie's fitness will have any impact on whether Cuningham plays or not. Cuningham is an automatic selection.

 

[My Hat]

If Curnow & Cuningham both come in and Jack stays, will this be the first time all of our 2015 draft picks play in the same match?

 

[Mr_Plow]

I completely agree, but I have a feeling they'll select Polson.

Would vomit so severely I'd end up in metabolic alkalosis.

 

[SkyhorseTamer]

If Curnow & Cuningham both come in and Jack stays, will this be the first time all of our 2015 draft picks play in the same match?

Kerr 2015?

 

[Dadda Dave]

I hope Jack stays in..

 

[HBF]

I hope Jack stays in..

So do I.
He was great against the doggies.

 

[Laphroaig]

Kennedy has to earn his spot, I'm not arguing he is a must include (lots of question marks about his fitness apparently) - the original post I made was agreeing with another posters view on Kennedy's game V Tuggers in 2018

It almost seems that the view in question is a reinvention inspired by hope. 2 kicks and two handballs in a quarter and a half of football looks to me like the antithesis of memorable.

also don't forget - I'm never ever wrong.

I did forget.

 

[Dadda Dave]

So do I.
He was great against the doggies.

He brings heaps of passion & determination..

 

[JustaBattler]

It almost seems that the view in question is a reinvention inspired by hope. 2 kicks and two handballs in a quarter and a half of football looks to me like the antithesis of memorable.



I did forget.

need i remind you the last time you disagreed with a view of mine on a player - was Walsh's likely impact in 'proper' AFL games?

Kennedy is a gun - cruelled by poor injury management last year - he wasn't alone..

 

[Soapy V]

He brings heaps of passion & determination..

Surely he stays. Brought so much to the side last week