What I've seen from Garthwaite says no way he makes it. Mcbean mach 2.It is a huge downgrade on Astbury. Astbury is one of the best marks in our team. Excellent reader of the player and sets up so well behind the ball. Garthwaite is a lockdown defender and based on what we've seen at AFL level, and we can only judge it from what we've seen - an average one at that. Garth is still young and developing but right now he's nowhere near ready to take on the elite forwards of the competition.