Autopsy Roast & Toast vs Carlton and Changes for R2 vs GWS

Best 5 vs Carlton?


  • Total voters
    193
Status
Not open for further replies.
Nov 23, 2000
57,838
125,444
Country Victoria
AFL Club
Richmond
can you imagine how many extra wins we'd have now since 2017 if we had the pies or dogs umpring

they get fondled every week
We'd be in a league of our own.
In cricketing terms.
17 other clubs would pick up their bat n ball and go home.
 
Nov 23, 2000
57,838
125,444
Country Victoria
AFL Club
Richmond
GWS will have 5,yep,at least 5 x top 10 draft picks rotating thru the midfield on Sunday...YIKES !!!
That's been their norm since game 1.
Only a gf appearance to show for it.
As they say A champion team will always best a team of champions.
 

Grrr

Brownlow Medallist
Aug 16, 2009
11,553
26,232
mildura
AFL Club
Richmond
with the crystal ball out and in hindsight caddy should have played ahead of aarts, jack graham and soldo who were all rubbish

and yes its hindsight, but if caddy was selected thursday and plays well most likely we win. because JR was useless after breaking a thumb early and caddy would have been handy close to goals as well as when prestia limped off he could've and would've been more use with his big frame and mean attitude than a flagging JG, a fumbly Aarts and a out of sorts soldo

and dont give me me that codswallop about miller being a better option at the moment going in to a vital clash......he's played 5 minutes forward against carlton ressies in a scratch match where caddy has set us alright in finals and can tag team with dusty...

depending on form, injury and teamlists, caddy is unlikely to be at tigers in 23. so no doubt will get a farewell game or two or 3, if this is the case...get him in now...how often does someone playing for their careers get a 2nd wind.
Miller is 22 years old, Caddy 29. Caddy has played 8 and 9 games in the last two years, He is not part of the future, not now, not for a few years, that is pretty obvious. I would much prefer trying something new than someone who might go okay at best. At last they are playing him forward, he was recruited as a forward ruck, so it is not new to him.

Who know how Miller will go. According to the VFL report, Miller played forward the entire game and went okay. Unlike other attempts at playing another tall forward, Soldo at FF last week enough said, at least he has the tools for it. Quick and athletic and a very good kick.

I would rather Cumberland come into the side to replace Jack than Caddy also. He goes for his marks, is very quick and athletic and has x factor to burn. It's about time we took a bit of a gamble on players who at least have the physical attributes for the game. They have punted on unfairly on Martin and Ryan who were not physically up to it. They also punted on Stack and Mansell who were.
 

SumTingWong

Norm Smith Medallist
Dec 10, 2011
8,216
16,723
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Liverpool, NY Giants, NY Mets
1648080461007.png
 

RobsJourney

Premiership Player
Oct 13, 2010
4,724
12,707
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Worst case scenario this week:

Broad, Tarrant, Gibcus
Short, Grimes, Rioli
McIntosh, Cotchin, Pickett
Edwards, Balta, Baker
Castagna, Lynch, Cumberland
Soldo, Graham, Ross
Ralphsmith, Aarts, Dow, Parker

As much as I hate to say it, Aarts will stay in as there are just too many forced outs.

OUT: Dusty, Nankervis, Bolton, Prestia, Riewoldt
IN: Parker, Ralphsmith, Cumberland, Dow, McIntosh


We are in BIG trouble already.
 

RJK Tiger

Premiership Player
Oct 29, 2020
3,622
8,745
AFL Club
Richmond
couple days off, club expecting him to play on sunday

sick of the media and their lies
lol get a grip. This is a massive story even if he plays.

For years Rance floated reasons for concern that he may "do a Barty" & eventually did. They are all warning signs for people that he very well could be at a point in his life where he wants to re-evaluate his priorities. Media are just doing their job on this one
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back