Scape Goat Rohan vs Menzel

[Man0gwaR74]

Straight swap with Sydney, like for like wasn't it?!?
A good barometer for how good our master Chris Scott is right?!?(You know that I wanna use this against him)
Should be interesting to see how it turns out but Rohan has largely been seen as the replacement for Menzel's inadequacies, so will Scott hit pay dirt as far as team needs go, or will Menzel get revenge on him by vindicating himself as an elite level forward?!?

...LET THE BATTLE BEGIN...

 

[Biggy_Boy]

like for like wasn't it?!?

Only really in the sense that they spend more time rehabbing than playing the game.

Rohan is more of a Murdoch replacement than Menzel.

 

[Man0gwaR74]

Only really in the sense that they spend more time rehabbing than playing the game.
Rohan is more of a Murdoch replacement than Menzel.

I'm sorry wrong thread, didn't you read the title?

 

[Spazz Cat]

If Menzel stays fit (he won't) he should do allright.
Swans desperately need another forward option so they'll play him.
Will get plenty of goals out the back with Buddy's long kicking inside 50.
Look I'm happy he's gone but he'll suit them more than us.
Rohan who knows???? Maybe he'll suit us more than them.

 

[Sticksman]

Straight swap with Sydney, like for like wasn't it?!?
A good barometer for how good our master Chris Scott is right?!?(You know that I wanna use this against him)
Should be interesting to see how it turns out but Rohan has largely been seen as the replacement for Menzel's inadequacies, so will Scott hit pay dirt as far as team needs go, or will Menzel get revenge on him by vindicating himself as an elite level forward?!?

Only time will tell

 

[Landgraft]

They're not suited to a 1v1 comparison.

(This ends my posting in the thread, there's nothing further to discuss)

 

[Spazz Cat]

They're not suited to a 1v1 comparison.

(This ends my posting in the thread, there's nothing further to discuss)

No it doesn’t.

 

[Man0gwaR74]

If Menzel stays fit (he won't) he should do allright.

This is another aspect of it, will Sydney's injury management of Menzel be more conducive to his performance, or maybe he would have been better off following his other injury plagued former team mates to the warmer climate of Brisbane?!?

Swans desperately need another forward option so they'll play him.
Will get plenty of goals out the back with Buddy's long kicking inside 50.

^Good insight!

Look I'm happy he's gone but he'll suit them more than us.
Rohan who knows???? Maybe he'll suit us more than them.

I've always been a bit of a fan of Rohan and I think he'll fit right in with the Cats, could be a mutually beneficial exchange for both clubs!

 

[sthmelb_dimmies]

Straight swap with Sydney, like for like wasn't it?!?

No, you also threw in Pick 61 to sweeten the deal for us. Thanks for that lol

 

[Man0gwaR74]

Only really in the sense that they spend more time rehabbing than playing the game.
Rohan is more of a Murdoch replacement than Menzel.

They're not suited to a 1v1 comparison.
(This ends my posting in the thread, there's nothing further to discuss)

Am looking forward to getting back to you guys about this during next season, dun worry there'll be more to discuss and you will hear from me again about it!

 

[sthmelb_dimmies]

This will be the new "who won the trade" after Callum Sinclair v Lewis Jetta.

 

[CatsDoItBetter]

Can I get some clarification? Is it Scott who does list management if you don’t like the decision? And Wells if you approve?

 

[dazbroncos]

This thread is set up to become a s**t fight and very little good can come from it.
Topics already covered in CS thread, trading, Rohan and Menzel thread.

Go Catters