Rolling 2025 All Australian Team

[bigboysdontcry]

Early days - My team on current form

B: Zorko H.Andrews L.Ash

HB: Sinclair S.Taylor Whitfield

C: Wanganeed-Milera McCluggage A.Brayshaw

HF: T.Greene S.Darcy R.Thilthorpe

FF: B.King J.Treacy J.Higgins

Followers: T. De Koning , Z.Merett , N.Anderson

Inter:
Serong
N.Daicos
M.Rowell
B.Smith

 

[JHF1870]

Glad someone started this.

Here's my top 20 players up to today. I've created my own system which is showing to be rather interesting. Collingwood clearly having the best team structure.

Number of votes is simply the votes given for each game, total score is the total impact score

	POTY (Round 6)	Games	Vote	TotalScore
1​	George Hewett	6​	19​	418.5​
2​	Andrew Brayshaw	6​	17​	397.5​
3​	Noah Anderson	5​	16​	339.5​
4​	Max Gawn	6​	15​	372​
5​	Nick Daicos	6​	15​	379.5​
6​	Matt Rowell	5​	15​	362​
7​	Hugh McCluggage	6​	15​	349​
8​	Tom De Koning	6​	14​	372.5​
9​	Touk Miller	5​	14​	332.5​
10​	Jack Macrae	5​	14​	335​
11​	Connor Rozee	5​	14​	296.5​
12​	Tom Green	5​	13​	330.5​
13​	Izak Rankine	6​	13​	362​
14​	Caleb Serong	6​	12​	378.5​
15​	Jordan Dawson	6​	12​	372.5​
16​	Ed Richards	5​	12​	287.5​
17​	Tom Liberatore	5​	11​	320.5​
18​	Sam Darcy	5​	11​	319.5​
19​	Jake Soligo	6​	11​	336​
20​	Lachie Neale	6​	10​	313.5​

 

[TheUnicorn]

Glad someone started this.

Here's my top 20 players up to today. I've created my own system which is showing to be rather interesting. Collingwood clearly having the best team structure.

Number of votes is simply the votes given for each game, total score is the total impact score

	POTY (Round 6)	Games	Vote	TotalScore
1​	George Hewett	6​	19​	418.5​
2​	Andrew Brayshaw	6​	17​	397.5​
3​	Noah Anderson	5​	16​	339.5​
4​	Max Gawn	6​	15​	372​
5​	Nick Daicos	6​	15​	379.5​
6​	Matt Rowell	5​	15​	362​
7​	Hugh McCluggage	6​	15​	349​
8​	Tom De Koning	6​	14​	372.5​
9​	Touk Miller	5​	14​	332.5​
10​	Jack Macrae	5​	14​	335​
11​	Connor Rozee	5​	14​	296.5​
12​	Tom Green	5​	13​	330.5​
13​	Izak Rankine	6​	13​	362​
14​	Caleb Serong	6​	12​	378.5​
15​	Jordan Dawson	6​	12​	372.5​
16​	Ed Richards	5​	12​	287.5​
17​	Tom Liberatore	5​	11​	320.5​
18​	Sam Darcy	5​	11​	319.5​
19​	Jake Soligo	6​	11​	336​
20​	Lachie Neale	6​	10​	313.5​

Gawn is way too high

 

[JHF1870]

Gawn is way too high

Sorry, My bad, so that was based on match day votes, sorry. Here's players sorted by total score, and average score. Max obviously polled well in his games.

it's stat based on my algorithm. Basically takes into account every stat and weighs them on importance. Simple stats are worth zero, and go up from there.

Takes away any uncecessary bias. For example, the op has ignored Hewitt despite being one of Carltons best and most consistent players.

Here is the top 20 by TOTAL score, and Average Score
Sorted by Total Score

	POTY (Round 6)	Games	Vote	TotalScore
1​	George Hewett	6​	19​	418.5​
2​	Andrew Brayshaw	6​	17​	397.5​
3​	Nick Daicos	6​	15​	379.5​
4​	Caleb Serong	6​	12​	378.5​
5​	Tom De Koning	6​	14​	372.5​
6​	Jordan Dawson	6​	12​	372.5​
7​	Max Gawn	6​	15​	372​
8​	Matt Rowell	5​	15​	362​
9​	Izak Rankine	6​	13​	362​
10​	Adam Cerra	6​	9​	356.5​
11​	Hugh McCluggage	6​	15​	349​
12​	Toby Greene	6​	10​	348.5​
13​	Lachie Whitfield	6​	8​	341​
14​	Noah Anderson	5​	16​	339.5​
15​	Jy Simpkin	6​	9​	338​
16​	Patrick Cripps	6​	8​	336.5​
17​	Jake Soligo	6​	11​	336​
18​	Clayton Oliver	6​	4​	336​
19​	Jack Macrae	5​	14​	335​
20​	Josh Dunkley	6​	8​	333​

By Average

	POTY (Round 6)	Games	Vote	Average of Total
1​	Matt Rowell	5​	15​	72.4​
2​	Zak Butters	2​	8​	71.75​
3​	Peter Wright	1​	5​	71​
4​	George Hewett	6​	19​	69.75​
5​	Noah Anderson	5​	16​	67.9​
6​	Jack Macrae	5​	14​	67​
7​	Touk Miller	5​	14​	66.5​
8​	Andrew Brayshaw	6​	17​	66.25​
9​	Tom Green	5​	13​	66.1​
10​	Tom Liberatore	5​	11​	64.1​
11​	Jye Caldwell	3​	5​	64​
12​	Sam Darcy	5​	11​	63.9​
13​	Jai Newcombe	5​	9​	63.7​
14​	Nick Daicos	6​	15​	63.25​
15​	Caleb Serong	6​	12​	63.08333333​
16​	Jack Sinclair	5​	10​	62.6​
17​	Will Day	4​	10​	62.375​
18​	Tom De Koning	6​	14​	62.08333333​
19​	Jordan Dawson	6​	12​	62.08333333​
20​	Max Gawn	6​	15​	62​

 

[JHF1870]

Key Forwards

Darcy, Thilthorpe, Walker (I'll pick Walker simply because he plays a more true CHF position)

Walker, and Treacy neck and ned for the third spot assuming we're going for 3 talls and 3 smalls. Personally, I think the two talls in Darcy and Thilthorpe are adequate for the modern game. I think a third man up forward would be best for a 3rd tall but most AA selections are simply the best 3.

 

[JHF1870]

KPD, sorted by intercept marks

For the KPD it's pretty evenly contested but the standouts are Taylor, and Sicily.
Bit hard at this stage for the small to mid defenders.

I've got