Ronnie Burns + Ben Marsh

[adelcrows]

RONNIE BURNS WAS A LIABILITY
He never should have got a call up and he should never again, he was basically giving West Coast a free man in defence (Wirripunda)and everything he did was a joke, he coughed the ball up on every occasion except one and made it too easy for west coast to get the ball out.He should be replaced by Massie this week

Ben Marsh.Enough said, he should be swapped for Perrie this week unless they dont want him in the team, then mabe a Hentschell, Rutten or Bock as another Big man.

Why would we drop Reilly, his form has been pretty good, he was on the bench for a fair bit against West Coast but all i think he needs to do is improve his goalkicking, he should definately stay, what a game to step up, A SHOWDOWN.

RONNIE + MARSH OUT.


Carn The Crows
Jason

 

[ScottWelshLuva]

Originally posted by adelcrows

Ben Marsh.Enough said, he should be swapped for Perrie this week unless they dont want him in the team, then mabe a Hentschell, Rutten or Bock as another Big man.

Why would we drop Reilly, his form has been pretty good, he was on the bench for a fair bit against West Coast but all i think he needs to do is improve his goalkicking, he should definately stay, what a game to step up, A SHOWDOWN.

Couldnt agree with you more, although i think we should stay with Ronnie.

Reilly doesnt deserve to be dropped at this stage, and like u said, the Showdown is a great opportunity for him to show what he is made of (although i think he already did that against collingwood when he took that hit). I agree that his form has been very good for a youngster up until yesterdays game, but i dont think yesterday is a cause for concern, he had been playing quite well before that!!!!

Plus i dont think Gary Ayres will drop him, he is young and still has a lot to learn, but i think Gary shows a lot of faith in him.

Totally agree with you on Ben Marsh, he isnt mobile enough and he is just too slow for AFL footy. Put him back in Westies i say!!! AND LEAVE HIM THERE HE HAS HAD HIS BLo0DY OPPORTUNITIES (ooh im scaring myself, i just REALLY hate him as a player)

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I don't recall any Crows supporter who thinks Marsh should get another game this week (or ever for that matter), so no arguement there.

Burns should have kicked the 1st goal of the game, missing a goal he would normally kick. Wirra is a class act & cleaned him up after that. However, he had good SANFL form before getting injured & deserves another chance. I hate it when players are brought in for 1 game, then dropped the next week. They need to be given a few games to show there wears - like Gags showed this week. On this theory, Reilly has been given a fair go & should return to the SANFL to recapture some form. BTW, for those who bring up Ben Marsh, he is an exception to the 1 game rule, as he should never have got a game in the 1st place!

 

[DaveW]

I thought Ronnie Burns was pretty ordinary on Sunday too. His efforts to chase looked so half-hearted. But I can think of one reason I want him in the side... I'm going down to Geelong for the round 10 match and I'd love to see him firing by the time he meets his old side. That sure would rile up the crowd who love to jeer their old players - see Colbert and Bizzell so far this year.

Yeah that's a pretty crap reason. At the rate he's going I'll have lost patience with him long before round ten.