Ross Lyon: Will He Coach Again?

Who will be the third team to be coached by Ross Lyon?

  • GWS

    Votes: 44 27.8%
  • Melbourne

    Votes: 43 27.2%
  • Ross Lyon will stay in the media

    Votes: 61 38.6%
  • Adelaide

    Votes: 14 8.9%
  • Noth Melbourne

    Votes: 12 7.6%
  • Geelong

    Votes: 6 3.8%

  • Total voters
    158

Remove this Banner Ad

Richo83

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 2, 2005
19,724
7,386
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
When he had the players he was quite aggressive in counter attack play, and if anything Richmond adopted this style, just with a much better list.

I already conclusively disproved this notion in the thread Richmond 2017 v Ross Lyon's Saints & Dockers.

Ross Lyon football involves manic pressure on the ball carrier and lots of forward pressure, but also involves keeping players behind the play to prevent high scoring. So when Lyon teams don't have the ball, they press hard. When they do, they play the cautious approach and build slowly using short passing and lots of uncontested marks.

Don't believe me? Have a look at the last two Ross Lyon teams to make the grand final:

In 2010 St Kilda were

10th for inside 50s per game
1st in disposals per inside 50
1st for uncontested marks per game
1st for uncontested marks per inside 50
2nd for uncontested marks per disposal
1st for uncontested possessions per inside 50
1st for uncontested possessions per game
2nd for percentage of possessions uncontested

In 2013, Fremantle were

15th for inside 50s per game
4th for disposals per inside 50
1st for uncontested marks per game
2nd for uncontested marks per inside 50
1st for uncontested marks per disposal
4th for uncontested possessions per inside 50
9th for uncontested possessions per game
8th for percentage of possessions uncontested

Now what's Richmond's style? Does it involve much uncontested disposals and marks? Is it fairly cautious in terms of how much it attacks? Well, no.

In 2017, Richmond were

3rd for inside 50s per game
17th for disposals per inside 50
17th for uncontested marks per game
18th for uncontested marks per inside 50
13th for uncontested marks per disposal
18th for uncontested possessions per inside 50
18th for uncontested possessions per game
18th for percentage of possessions uncontested

So Richmond attacked with abandon and pumped the ball in as soon as they won it, no chipping of the ball, no sideways kicks, quick and attacking ball movement. That's not just unlike Ross Lyon football, that's the antithesis of Ross Lyon football, which prides itself on careful ball movement.

Stats sometimes lie. They don't here. And before you give me some hoary bullcrap rant about how statistics don't matter, because you watch the game, so do I. And these figures say the same thing that my eyeballs do, Richmond's gameplan, especially with the ball was not classic Ross Lyon football.

Bigfooty seems obsessed with the fact that Richmond and Fremantle defended similarly and equally well without looking at their style of ball movement and ignoring the fact that most premiership sides, not just Richmond defend well and pressure. Hawthorn's pressure and defensive abilities were elite. They didn't have to defend that much because the ball was usually at the other end, but when they did, they did it better than anyone else. Lyon sides also pressure well, so do Sydney under Longmire.

What makes a premiership side a premiership side is what they do with the ball. Do they play a more simpler game based on attack and direct ball movement? Or do they try and hold up the play and control the ball, which is harder in finals as things become more contested and things go wrong? This is why I'm not really surprised Lyon sides can't win grand finals, because it's based on a keepings off uncontested brand of football which doesn't hold up in finals as it limits your chances to score and can easily be unraveled through pressure. It's great if you want to squeeze the bejeesus out of some bottom four team travelling to Perth and you restrict them to 39 points for the game, but not good if you come against a team with genuine attacking firepower that's harder to contain and a team which pressures back.

I wrote that in 2017, and not that much has chanced in Richmond's 2019 and 2020 premierships. Manic surging ball movement, one of the highest inside 50s rates of the competition, and a team which plays with risk, playing it long and direct. It's not "pretty" because it's not precise kicking and involves a lot of heavy forwardline pressure which leads to inside 50 scraps. Not because it's some cautious, slow, plodding, defensive gameplan a la Lyon.

I don't think looking at The scores is misleading to be honest.

Read what I wrote above.
 

Freomaniac

Brownlow Medallist
May 3, 2007
29,808
17,081
Parts Unknown
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Man City, Valencia, Lazio, Panthers
I already conclusively disproved this notion in the thread Richmond 2017 v Ross Lyon's Saints & Dockers.

Ross Lyon football involves manic pressure on the ball carrier and lots of forward pressure, but also involves keeping players behind the play to prevent high scoring. So when Lyon teams don't have the ball, they press hard. When they do, they play the cautious approach and build slowly using short passing and lots of uncontested marks.

Don't believe me? Have a look at the last two Ross Lyon teams to make the grand final:

In 2010 St Kilda were

10th for inside 50s per game
1st in disposals per inside 50
1st for uncontested marks per game
1st for uncontested marks per inside 50
2nd for uncontested marks per disposal
1st for uncontested possessions per inside 50
1st for uncontested possessions per game
2nd for percentage of possessions uncontested

In 2013, Fremantle were

15th for inside 50s per game
4th for disposals per inside 50
1st for uncontested marks per game
2nd for uncontested marks per inside 50
1st for uncontested marks per disposal
4th for uncontested possessions per inside 50
9th for uncontested possessions per game
8th for percentage of possessions uncontested

Now what's Richmond's style? Does it involve much uncontested disposals and marks? Is it fairly cautious in terms of how much it attacks? Well, no.

In 2017, Richmond were

3rd for inside 50s per game
17th for disposals per inside 50
17th for uncontested marks per game
18th for uncontested marks per inside 50
13th for uncontested marks per disposal
18th for uncontested possessions per inside 50
18th for uncontested possessions per game
18th for percentage of possessions uncontested

So Richmond attacked with abandon and pumped the ball in as soon as they won it, no chipping of the ball, no sideways kicks, quick and attacking ball movement. That's not just unlike Ross Lyon football, that's the antithesis of Ross Lyon football, which prides itself on careful ball movement.

Stats sometimes lie. They don't here. And before you give me some hoary bullcrap rant about how statistics don't matter, because you watch the game, so do I. And these figures say the same thing that my eyeballs do, Richmond's gameplan, especially with the ball was not classic Ross Lyon football.

Bigfooty seems obsessed with the fact that Richmond and Fremantle defended similarly and equally well without looking at their style of ball movement and ignoring the fact that most premiership sides, not just Richmond defend well and pressure. Hawthorn's pressure and defensive abilities were elite. They didn't have to defend that much because the ball was usually at the other end, but when they did, they did it better than anyone else. Lyon sides also pressure well, so do Sydney under Longmire.

What makes a premiership side a premiership side is what they do with the ball. Do they play a more simpler game based on attack and direct ball movement? Or do they try and hold up the play and control the ball, which is harder in finals as things become more contested and things go wrong? This is why I'm not really surprised Lyon sides can't win grand finals, because it's based on a keepings off uncontested brand of football which doesn't hold up in finals as it limits your chances to score and can easily be unraveled through pressure. It's great if you want to squeeze the bejeesus out of some bottom four team travelling to Perth and you restrict them to 39 points for the game, but not good if you come against a team with genuine attacking firepower that's harder to contain and a team which pressures back.

I wrote that in 2017, and not that much has chanced in Richmond's 2019 and 2020 premierships. Manic surging ball movement, one of the highest inside 50s rates of the competition, and a team which plays with risk, playing it long and direct. It's not "pretty" because it's not precise kicking and involves a lot of heavy forwardline pressure which leads to inside 50 scraps. Not because it's some cautious, slow, plodding, defensive gameplan a la Lyon.



Read what I wrote above.

I dont care about your stats.

The only stat that matters is the scoreboard.

You say that a team scoring 90 points a game in attack during the regular season is decieving.

I will tell you this.....

I enjoyed the 2013 Prelim final between Freo and the Swans. I also enjoyed the 2017 grand final between Richmond and Crows.


Actually, when I watched the 2017 Grand final. I enjoyed the 2nd and 3rd quarters of that grand final. Richmond tackled and bashed the crows midfield with agression and manic pressure to the point the crows gave up. Richmond scored 9 goals and 5 behinds compared to the crows 1 goal and 8 behinds in that 2nd and 3rd quarter period,

I enjoyed freos 2nd and 3rd quarters in that prelim final vs the swans for similar reasons too. Freo chased and tackled the swans to the point where they were worn down. Freo outscored the swans in those 2nd and 3rd quarters for a combined total of 9 goals 3 behinds to the swans 3 goals 4 behinds.


Again, go watch the 2nd and 3rd quarters of both the 2013 Prelim between Freo and swans and the 2017 AFL grand final.
 

Leeda

Talons B Sharp
Sep 26, 2012
9,063
1,550
AFL Club
Hawthorn
I dont care about your stats.

The only stat that matters is the scoreboard.

You say that a team scoring 90 points a game in attack during the regular season is decieving.

I will tell you this.....

I enjoyed the 2013 Prelim final between Freo and the Swans. I also enjoyed the 2017 grand final between Richmond and Crows.


Actually, when I watched the 2017 Grand final. I enjoyed the 2nd and 3rd quarters of that grand final. Richmond tackled and bashed the crows midfield with agression and manic pressure to the point the crows gave up. Richmond scored 9 goals and 5 behinds compared to the crows 1 goal and 8 behinds in that 2nd and 3rd quarter period,

I enjoyed freos 2nd and 3rd quarters in that prelim final vs the swans for similar reasons too. Freo chased and tackled the swans to the point where they were worn down. Freo outscored the swans in those 2nd and 3rd quarters for a combined total of 9 goals 3 behinds to the swans 3 goals 4 behinds.


Again, go watch the 2nd and 3rd quarters of both the 2013 Prelim between Freo and swans and the 2017 AFL grand final.
you are rocking it dude..
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Richo83

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 2, 2005
19,724
7,386
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
I dont care about your stats.

Because they're inconvenient to your narrative? Because they cut through the bullcrap of Fremantle supporters desperately trying to link a coach whose gamestyle doesn't work to a triple premiership coach who deliberately changed his gamestyle so he could win premierships?

The only stat that matters is the scoreboard.

Okay Mr Scoreboard. In 2013, Richmond averaged 98 points per game playing a possession-based kick and mark game. In 2018, they averaged 96 points per game playing a direct high play on, long kicking and handballing game. Completely different. The scoreboard tells me how much a team scores, not how they score.

You say that a team scoring 90 points a game in attack during the regular season is decieving.

I will tell you this.....

I enjoyed the 2013 Prelim final between Freo and the Swans. I also enjoyed the 2017 grand final between Richmond and Crows.

Actually, when I watched the 2017 Grand final. I enjoyed the 2nd and 3rd quarters of that grand final. Richmond tackled and bashed the crows midfield with agression and manic pressure to the point the crows gave up. Richmond scored 9 goals and 5 behinds compared to the crows 1 goal and 8 behinds in that 2nd and 3rd quarter period,

I enjoyed freos 2nd and 3rd quarters in that prelim final vs the swans for similar reasons too. Freo chased and tackled the swans to the point where they were worn down. Freo outscored the swans in those 2nd and 3rd quarters for a combined total of 9 goals 3 behinds to the swans 3 goals 4 behinds.

Great, and what did the teams do with the ball? The stats tell us that Richmond in 2017 used the ball much differently to how Fremantle in 2013 used the ball.

It's also deceiving because teams score points for certain reasons. Maybe their forwardline is efficient or inefficient. Maybe they play in a lower scoring era, like today. Maybe they play a negative conservative style of football which, despite it working in home and away where sides don't have great attacking firepower, doesn't work in finals.

I will admit though that Lyon is a bit unlucky having come against Thompson's cats and Clarkson's hawks. But those sides made their own luck by playing an aggressive style of football.

Again, go watch the 2nd and 3rd quarters of both the 2013 Prelim between Freo and swans and the 2017 AFL grand final.

I've seen the 2017 grand final roughly 10 times. I don't need to watch it again to know that premiership era Hardwick and Lyon's Fremantle and St Kilda play a different gamestyle. I mean, Hardwick himself has had a massive change in his gamestyle.
 

General Giant

Hall of Famer
Apr 12, 2012
43,258
37,306
AFL Club
GWS
I suppose so.

Strange Saints would let him in after he did a runner and with some of the talk around the place but hey good luck to em.
 

Sttew

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 28, 2006
25,653
25,280
Who's asking?
AFL Club
Geelong
You have to wonder whether Saints told Ross the Boss not to go for the Bombers job because there would be a vacancy at St Kilda. That was in early September!!
 

Altum Volantes

92 - 94 - 06 - 18
Aug 4, 2003
21,370
20,255
WA
AFL Club
West Coast
Ross is smarter this time - surrounding himself with Sacred Cows like Harvs and Lenny.

If he can just get Zac Dawson back to the club, he’ll be all set.
 

JackFlash

Norm Smith Medallist
Jul 28, 2012
9,918
9,055
Docklands
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
QPR, Buffalo Bills
Is Ross Lyon the Saddam Hussein of the AFL?

JackFlash , your thoughts mate? LoL
Maybe "Chemical Ali?" In all seriousness, he's conned them into giving him a four-year deal worth a fortune, puzzling when you consider they have Harvey and Hayes back at the club. St Kilda has a list that pales in comparison to what he had at the start of his coaching tenure in 2007. Who is going to win this team any games? They did stuff all at the trade table and are light years behind the top teams who all did extremely well and it's very doubtful the Saints will win 5 or 6 games for the entire year in 2023? They should consider themselves lucky the Roos, Eagles and Hawks are so bad... If they finish any higher than 12th he's achieved a miracle!
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Freomaniac

Brownlow Medallist
May 3, 2007
29,808
17,081
Parts Unknown
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Man City, Valencia, Lazio, Panthers
Dont think so.

Twice has come close to a flag but failed, and then left the list in a mess.

If he was coaching this year his team would struggle to kick a score above 20 each week. Not great for membership numbers during a pandemic and financial crisis.
Oh really?
 

Freomaniac

Brownlow Medallist
May 3, 2007
29,808
17,081
Parts Unknown
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Man City, Valencia, Lazio, Panthers
A finisher that never finished? Both Saints and Freo were already on the rise when he took over thanks to previous coaches.
Hahahaha really Freo were risers before Ross Lyon took over at the end of 2011?

As stated by another Freo poster. The 2011 dockers got belted by 90 points vs the demons at the MCG under coach Dean Bailey.

This was the exact same demons coach under Dean Bailey that 2 months later lost to Geelong by 186 points
 

Freomaniac

Brownlow Medallist
May 3, 2007
29,808
17,081
Parts Unknown
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Man City, Valencia, Lazio, Panthers
Of course West Coast were further behind, that's not the discussion. None of Hawthorn's threepeat wins were ever in doubt. Trying to paint 2013 as some kind of nailbiter is absolutely revisionism.
Going by your theory, eagles in 2022 were close to the flag too lol
 
Sep 22, 2013
25,378
45,998
Buzz City
AFL Club
St Kilda
Other Teams
Suns, Hornets, Sharks, Stars
Hahahaha really Freo were risers before Ross Lyon took over at the end of 2011?

As stated by another Freo poster. The 2011 dockers got belted by 90 points vs the demons at the MCG under coach Dean Bailey.

This was the exact same demons coach under Dean Bailey that 2 months later lost to Geelong by 186 points
To be fair you beat Hawks in 2010 elimination final so not too bad
 

Jables

Club Legend
Jun 16, 2008
2,661
3,604
Melbourne
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
NY Giants, Hornets, Bulls
To be fair you beat Hawks in 2010 elimination final so not too bad
Yeah we were actually at the same point on the ladder at the time, apparently their fans didn't like Harvey in 2011 but the players were pretty surprised when he was sacked, IMO it's revisionism to say Fremantle weren't expected to rise up the ladder.
 

Freomaniac

Brownlow Medallist
May 3, 2007
29,808
17,081
Parts Unknown
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Man City, Valencia, Lazio, Panthers
To be fair you beat Hawks in 2010 elimination final so not too bad
Well at least your mob made finals in 2011.

But as I said, demons beat the injury riddled dockers by 90 points.

This was the same demons side that lost by 186 a few weeks later to the cats in Geelong.

I would not of liked that 2011 injury riddled side having a game vs the cats in Geelong late in 2011, who later on won the flag.

Would of been a 276 point loss to the dockers or even by more than 300 points!
 

Freomaniac

Brownlow Medallist
May 3, 2007
29,808
17,081
Parts Unknown
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Man City, Valencia, Lazio, Panthers
Yeah we were actually at the same point on the ladder at the time, apparently their fans didn't like Harvey in 2011 but the players were pretty surprised when he was sacked, IMO it's revisionism to say Fremantle weren't expected to rise up the ladder.
And just like the hawks were underdogs in ever grand final from 1983-89 and 2012-15
 

#gosaintas

Premiership Player
Nov 11, 2013
4,351
8,793
AFL Club
St Kilda
Maybe "Chemical Ali?" In all seriousness, he's conned them into giving him a four-year deal worth a fortune, puzzling when you consider they have Harvey and Hayes back at the club. St Kilda has a list that pales in comparison to what he had at the start of his coaching tenure in 2007. Who is going to win this team any games? They did stuff all at the trade table and are light years behind the top teams who all did extremely well and it's very doubtful the Saints will win 5 or 6 games for the entire year in 2023? They should consider themselves lucky the Roos, Eagles and Hawks are so bad... If they finish any higher than 12th he's achieved a miracle!
Good chance for the 8