ROUGH WEREWOLF

[Jhye Clark 13]

Nup I'm staying where is atm..

Something still doesn't add up..

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Yep

N1


N2


N1 I seered GUH and it came back as intimidator. I didn't know I was the real one, I didn't want to derail the day in case someone else had better intel. But I probed/fished for GUH (and as I said before, he slipped up, which jye picked up on but the wagon didn't otherwise gather much momentum),, my one vote for the entire day was on GUH , immediately after he voted for me, and it stayed there, for good reason. Post lynch I knew he was the true seer but figured that if evil had actioned me N1 they would attribute it to the amulet and leave me alone another night

N2 I seered a flog . If I seered evil I would've claimed . I intended to wait until I had more intel before claiming, but my hand was forced

One question. If you seered GUH as intimidator how could someone have better Intel?

 

[MWPP]

Nup I'm staying where is atm..

Something still doesn't add up..

The flogs can clear me, and by akkaps getting the amulet, he will live to tell the tale
The fact that you don't see the logic in this is suspicious to be honest

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

The flogs can clear me, and by akkaps getting the amulet, he will live to tell the tale
The fact that you don't see the logic in this is suspicious to be honest

How can the flogs clear you?

 

[MWPP]

One question. If you seered GUH as intimidator how could someone have better Intel?

eg The flogs have 2 actions, and unlike me, they wouldn't get a fake seer result . Chippy did say when he claimed that he had nothing currently but would be back later. I wondered if he crumbed that they had seered evil and not 50/50 like I was.

My plan was to claim late in the day but the amulet gave the wagon momentum and it wasn't needed

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

eg The flogs have 2 actions, and unlike me, they wouldn't get a fake seer result . Chippy did say when he claimed that he had nothing currently but would be back later. I wondered if he crumbed that they had seered evil and not 50/50 like I was.

My plan was to claim late in the day but the amulet gave the wagon momentum and it wasn't needed

 

[MWPP]

How can the flogs clear you?

This is how

Flogs – four players who know each other’s role and share a PM, get one seer and one kill that can be taken at night

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Yea but you said the flogs can clear you by getting the amulet. The problem is you don't have it.

 

[MWPP]

I fell asleep before clarifying:

FLOG CLAIM

I’m a flog. por_please_ya is not a flog and I suspect is being intimidated based on her response to me at the start of the phase.

We have no steer for today’s vote but I’ll be around before deadline.

It would also be great if we could have the amulet.

And Jhye Clark 13 , this post about "no steer" is what prompted my amulet claim
I would've followed up with a result claim later in the day if it was needed but he was the comfortable lynch thanks to his vote on me/my amulet claim, and therefore, it wasn't needed

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

This is how

No, it still doesn't prove you're the seer.

 

[3KZ is Football]

I agree. Given everything that MWPP has said, there were much simpler plays that would have presented themselves. If you were seer, be quiet and gather info. If you have the amulet, be quiet and pass it on to someone good - like Chipmunk. If you were good, why all the super obvious palaver with Croweater? Mafia missed kills are interesting too. You would think that they might have thrown a few shots at MWPP. A good player playing poorly or Evil bring too clever by half. I think MWPP is worth a look.

 

[MWPP]

You can seer me tonight if you wish, however, I am not the vote today

I said this Jhye Clark 13 , a while ago

 

[Frederico_WA]

Claiming seer has thrown me too.

Even if you got out of lynch MWPP , how do you make itthrough the night? You'd need to be unprotected for akkaps to seer you.

Any representative of evil factions want to claim and promise not to kill her?

 

[MWPP]

And given they get a true not a fake result, it would clear me

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

And Jhye Clark 13 , this post about "no steer" is what prompted my amulet claim
I would've followed up with a result claim later in the day if it was needed but he was the comfortable lynch thanks to his vote on me/my amulet claim, and therefore, it wasn't needed

It's funny because IMS used to give the amulet to the seer every game he ran and nobody took any notice. I'm still not buying this though.

 

[MP_]

A good player in crowy

 

[MWPP]

Claiming seer has thrown me too.

Even if you got out of lynch MWPP , how do you make itthrough the night? You'd need to be unprotected for akkaps to seer you.

Any representative of evil factions want to claim and promise not to kill her?

Eventually, the amulet breaks, and I'll be open
Plus the doc didn't protect chip yesterday so I'm not going to rely on them to protect me today

It's better to let evil kill me by night since they can't coordinate, than lynch me

 

[Frederico_WA]

The flogs can clear me, and by akkaps getting the amulet, he will live to tell the tale
The fact that you don't see the logic in this is suspicious to be honest

But youre outed seer. You die tonight ... and waste the flogs only seer.

 

[MWPP]

But youre outed seer. You die tonight ... and waste the flogs only seer.

Then the flogs don't seer me, I did say to akkaps "if you like"
When I've been in this position as good, my approach has been to focus on somebody else

Especially when there's a lack of a counterclaimant

Put simply, I am not the play today

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Who did you seer as flog MWPP? I think it's worth the risk given their options.

I want to see if akkaps can counter.

 

[MWPP]

It's funny because IMS used to give the amulet to the seer every game he ran and nobody took any notice. I'm still not buying this though.

Did you notice that the wagon only gained momentum after my vote? Go back and check if you like...
Did you also notice that GUH only responded after Ding tagged him, I commented on his last game (which seemed like a sore spot) and he made that slipup you picked on+ went on to vote for me a while later?

 

[MWPP]

Who did you seer as flog MWPP? I think it's worth the risk given their options.

I want to see if akkaps can counter.

I'll only reveal this if akkaps wants me to, otherwise, it's only putting a target on their backs after what happened to Chip

 

[croweater 41]

I'll only reveal this if akkaps wants me to, otherwise, it's only putting a target on their backs after what happened to Chip

Gives me another place to hide the amulet though

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

I'll only reveal this if akkaps wants me to, otherwise, it's only putting a target on their backs after what happened to Chip

They've got a kill and a seer. Two roles left. They'll use them regardless.

 

[MP_]

Gives me another place to hide the amulet though

Why did you say mwpp was not the play?