ROUGH WEREWOLF

[MWPP]

What made my ears prick was MWPP telling the world she thought crowy was the doctor. Now a villager would keep that a secret.

He was pretty obvious with the soft claim before I asked him outright . If I saw it, some evil /neutral would’ve too.

I called him out in case I died overnight and Chippy was dead /silenced (that confirmation was before GUH flipped the way he did) . As I said to Chippy, if the amulet doesn’t go to good from here, crow will be killed tonight or Lynched tomorrow .

 

[BEaston]

This is the smartest thing I have read today. Yesterday MWPP says to Croweater - “I did something and you might have picked it … are you claiming doctor?” Then croweater posts a meme from MASH that mentions doctors and MWPP is all like “Ok then you are the doctor I will give you the amulet”
While I am thinking why on earth would the doctor out themselves basically at the start of the game?
Neither of these two players are that bad, which makes me think they might BE bad.

You guys might be onto something here.

Could be good targets for the vig.

 

[3KZ is Football]

Which is what you appear to be doing because you're not paying attention.

BTW - I am paying attention.

 

[akkaps]

Then that would leave two flogs to vote against Akkaps?

Trying to get in to the groove here and possibly doing it all wrong.

Who else has claimed flog

 

[MWPP]

This is the smartest thing I have read today. Yesterday MWPP says to Croweater - “I did something and you might have picked it … are you claiming doctor?” Then croweater posts a meme from MASH that mentions doctors and MWPP is all like “Ok then you are the doctor I will give you the amulet”
While I am thinking why on earth would the doctor out themselves basically at the start of the game?
Neither of these two players are that bad, which makes me think they might BE bad.

Anyway, I had a reason to believe it, based on my own previous play /honest mistake in other games. I said chip yesterday but in summary, the claim made sense to me in light of the way pie flipped and crowwy being amongst pie’s favourite targets and potentially being spooked by the miss/flip.

 

[MP_]

Who else has claimed flog

Chipmunk

 

[MC Bad Genius]

Not as much as that cover of the sounds of silence

That is not on.

MP_ please DERO

 

[MC Bad Genius]

He soft or hard claimed Doc, I don't recall seeing it but I won't have to read back.

I must've missed that as well, but that's not really a surprise.

 

[3KZ is Football]

Anyway, I had a reason to believe it, based on my own previous play /honest mistake in other games. I said chip yesterday but in summary, the claim made sense to me in light of the way pie flipped and crowwy being amongst pie’s favourite targets and potentially being spooked by the miss/flip.

Sorry but you are speaking “word salad” - I am just about ready to switch my vote to you.

 

[akkaps]

Chipmunk

But he’s already dead. Who else ?

 

[croweater 41]

So who can I trust sending the amulet to.

I'd voted akkaps but in light of a flog claim and then a JC masterclass of MWPP thinking and gameplay has me second guessing that.

I feel I saw a subtle flog claim from another player earlier today.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

He was pretty obvious with the soft claim before I asked him outright . If I saw it, some evil /neutral would’ve too.

I called him out in case I died overnight and Chippy was dead /silenced (that confirmation was before GUH flipped the way he did) . As I said to Chippy, if the amulet doesn’t go to good from here, crow will be killed tonight or Lynched tomorrow .

Obvious as in nobody else appeared to have picked up on it? Even if they may have, a villager would keep that quiet.

Remember my response to you yesterday about something not adding up?

Now passing the amulet to a person 'you' assumed was the doc just smells bad when there was an option to self-protect.

Then we have the fiasco this morning where crowy backtracked from his doctor claim and it doesn't look all that good for the both of you from my end.

I'm positive the amulet is with evil. If not you've both played it poorly.

 

[croweater 41]

But he’s already dead. Who else ?

Well 4 minus 1 = 3
You claiming = 1 more claim.

Leaving two unclaimed flogs. Although I did possibly see a soft claim

 

[MC Bad Genius]

He was pretty obvious with the soft claim before I asked him outright . If I saw it, some evil /neutral would’ve too.

I called him out in case I died overnight and Chippy was dead /silenced (that confirmation was before GUH flipped the way he did) . As I said to Chippy, if the amulet doesn’t go to good from here, crow will be killed tonight or Lynched tomorrow .

I've flicked back to some of those posts from this morning now. Do you believe his "I'm just a villager trying to take the heat of good roles" schtick? I'm not convinced.

 

[croweater 41]

I've flicked back to some of those posts from this morning now. Do you believe his "I'm just a villager trying to take the heat of good roles" schtick? I'm not convinced.

I've done it before.

I'll do it again.

As a villager you need to be willing to be sacrificied.

If I had of got an early notification of getting the amulet I in no way would have been as vocal about having it as I was.

 

[3KZ is Football]

I've flicked back to some of those posts from this morning now. Do you believe his "I'm just a villager trying to take the heat of good roles" schtick? I'm not convinced.

Honestly, I could be tempted to vote for croweater or MWPP

 

[MWPP]

Obvious as in nobody else appeared to have picked up on it? Even if they may have, a villager would keep that quiet.

Remember my response to you yesterday about something not adding up?

Now passing the amulet to a person 'you' assumed was the doc just smells bad when there was an option to self-protect.

Then we have the fiasco this morning where crowy backtracked from his doctor claim and it doesn't look all that good for the both of you from my end.

I'm positive the amulet is with evil. If not you've both played it poorly.

How could I know that self protect was an option given the consecutive nights limitation and pie’s mafia miss? I figured that by calling out the claim that there would be some accountability .

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

I must've missed that as well, but that's not really a surprise.

Everyone missed it because it was invented imo.

 

[MWPP]

I've flicked back to some of those posts from this morning now. Do you believe his "I'm just a villager trying to take the heat of good roles" schtick? I'm not convinced.

I don’t believe it but as he’s lynch immune, that’s a problem for tonight /tomorrow

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

How could I know that self protect was an option given the consecutive nights limitation and pie’s mafia miss? I figured that by calling out the claim that there would be some accountability .

The doc can self protect can he not?

If so, it was definitely an option.

 

[BEaston]

I don’t believe it but as he’s lynch immune, that’s a problem for tonight /tomorrow

We could vote for you. If the ruse was real, you're both equally evil.

If it was all a misunderstanding, worst case we lose a villager and crowy gives the amulet to good today.

Best case we lynch an evil head.

 

[MWPP]

The doc can self protect can he not?

If so, it was definitely an option.

Not in the scenario I was thinking of/that I have been in as a doc:
-self protecting n1 and thinking the miss was on the self protecting doc
(I’ve been right more often than probability in assuming that /claiming /living longer, but at least once I have also been wrong and caused an early death)

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Not in the scenario I was thinking of/that I have been in as a doc:
-self protecting n1 and thinking the miss was on the self protecting doc
(I’ve been right more often than probability in assuming that /claiming /living longer, but at least once I have also been wrong and caused an early death)

When I've been doc I always self-protect night 2.

 

[MC Bad Genius]

We could vote for you. If the ruse was real, you're both equally evil.

If it was all a misunderstanding, worst case we lose a villager and crowy gives the amulet to good today.

Best case we lynch an evil head.

Nah, worst case is we lynch someone who is "randomly" in second place. Or more likely, someone that evil has engineered as being in second place. That feels extra foolish. MWPP is right - it's definitely a tonight/tomorrow thing at the earliest.

 

[MWPP]

When I've been doc I always self-protect night 2.

Explains our different views on this. I always protect N1 unless it’s a game where we can only self protect once or not at all (no exception)