ROUGH WEREWOLF

[DERO]

 

[Barrybran]

You don't have to worry about anyone thinking here, DERO

 

[Dingster]

Barrybran the exquisite thinker. I like that guy

 

[DERO]

DEADLINE

 

[DERO]

Barrybran godfather lynched by the village. It is night.

 

[por_please_ya]

Barrybran godfather lynched by the village. It is night.

Wow what a get! Nicely played Baz, didn't really think you were evil until the numbers dwindled.

 

[jmoo wan]

Wow what a get! Nicely played Baz, didn't really think you were evil until the numbers dwindled.

bit too late to try to distance yourself from him now

 

[BEaston]

So nobody has found any info on the apprentice hey? I'm going to go out on a limb and say they're in an evil faction, and possibly recruited from a role that would hide the apprentice seer result. There were two of those. One just died.

Wolves you wouldn't want to be getting played by your alpha this whole game would you?

If I die to the SK or the SK controlled wolf kill tonight, I must be getting close with this train of thought as well as my vote on jmoo today - at which point he suddenly appeared.

 

[BEaston]

Mafia might have already been onto this theory with barrybran's vote - could have been a breadcrumb.

 

[Frederico_WA]

Posting this coz it may help village when im gone. This covers up to 1pm AWST yesterday.

Notable comments / observations
(as of 1pm AWST)

N1 - Mafia missed kill (likely Gralin N1 revenge as a 'welcome' gift - but was immune)

D1 - Cadsky - "Nice win for the town knocking off the goon"

D1 - Dingster - "MWPP is the Veg"

D1 - Dingster - "GUH are you evil?"

D1 - Gralin - "I missed the SK could have apprentice. That’s all the village needs one of our own being turned"

D1 - Gralin - says he's not in a PM

D1 - MWPP - chatting to MP about theory re: Gralin being picked as apprentice

D1 - Gralin - playing dumb re: not being thorough to read to OP when he obviously did last 2 games quite a lot

D1 - Baz - meme nod re: history of killing MWPPs. "I don't have a gun in this one"

D2 - Cadsky - "Bad miss by the vig"

D2 - MWPP - "I've been defending you but this post doesn’t add up" (to Cadsky)

D2 - JC - Says to Beaston he thinks he has a role. Showed a red flag.

D2 - Baz - "why does Gralin keep mentioning the SK?"

D2 - Cadsky - "MWPP seems switched on so ill follow her and vote akkaps"

D2 - JC - "MWPP evil, Baz sus, Bluelegs has friends, Porps 50/50, Beaston cagey evil"

D2 - 3kz - Huge stoke the flames post for MWPP/crow being evil (replying to JC theory)

D2 - Beaston - reply to 3kz flames "You guys might be onto something here"

D2 - Cadsky - asks Porps again was she intimidated when she'd said yes multiple times (and other ppl)

D2 - Cadsky - really insightful and detailed reply about roles and why MWPP vote makes sense. Conflicts his previous dumb question to porps that he is not watching carefully.

D2 - Cadsky - pulls the old "why are you so worried about lynch if youre village" to MWPP

D2 - Crow - says Cadsky is the stinkiest on the MWPP wagon

D2 - Porp - randonly interjects that she remembers Crow post about germ lock from D1 and having medicine implying he is the Doc

D2 - Porp - post keeping focus on MWPP maybe still being evil

D2 - Gralin - quickly agreed with Fred post re: MWPP/Crow evil ploy to draw out the doc

D2 - Cadsky - has done a vote count and is very active

D2 - 3kz - random post about mafia missing 2 kills. Insinuates they hit alpha and wolf holding amulet. "I wonder if that is how it played out"

D2 - Beaston - Says he'd like to believe MWPP but doesn’t belive a good player (crowy) would out himself on D1 as doc

D2 - Porp - Another theory post re: amulet, crowy, the doc not protecting and chip dying. Old news.

D2 - Porp - really seems anti-MWPP today

D2 - Gralin - going after MWPP quite directly in a few posts

D2 - 3kz - another huge post about MWPP being evil in some hugely elaborate theory

D2 - Gralin - talks about the evil seers, finishes with "or am I missing something" (note: he don't miss!)

D2 - Dingster - agree with Crowy post saying MWPP is not the play

D2 - Cadsky - jumps off MWPP vote despite saying "stay the course" for voting MWPP. Changed to Bluey. Says he is confident it wont backfire.

D2 - Dingster - changes his mind and votes MWPP anyway. (Lazy evil wagon jumper?)

D2 - 3kz - tells MWPP she dies! Also says he is posting more due to operation and on pain killers

D2 - MWPP - tells Dingster he is evil, pretending to make an honest mistake to remain lynching an uncontested seer

D2 - MWPP - calls out Beaston due to leaping onto her early but is staying away now

D2 - MWPP - 'stinky 7' are Gralin, Beaston, Akkaps, Greenery, Baz, 3kz, Ding

D2 - 3kz - betting odds post saying MWPP is evil / wolf

N3 - Dingster - "Dunno why the village would be pushing mod kills" re: MWPP asking about mod kills

N3 - JT - "I have concluded jmoo is a villager. Or at least not a threat we need to worry about if not."

D3 - Cadsky - "well that’s a *** horrible night for the town"

D3 - Gralin - "Well im an idiot I was sure MWPP was evil and suckered everyone"

D3 - Porp - suprprise at Crowy not doc and JC not head evil

D3 - Gralin - agreeing with Porp and also that he doesn’t understand the MWPP/crow play

D3 - Cadsky - says he is suss on jmoo as he's lurking big time. Also Baz for lurking.

D3 - Cadsky - states obvious that 9 evil and 5 good remain. Lots of lurkers.

D3 - Gralin throws sus on Baz, not same faction. Points out Baz late switch to kill MWPP when it looked in doubt.

D3 - Gralin - says we cant wait for flog actions. Need to hit the right target today.

D3 - Gralin very active

D3 - 3kz - doubles down on MWPP/crow criticism. (Move on, they're dead mate!)

D3 - Beaston - "Holy sh** what a bad night for us". Concedes MWPP was telling truth but is hard to read. Thrown by crowy claim and Chip dying unnecessary. (Is he appealing to my earlier post that chip died unnecessarily?). Says we need to look at lurkers.

D3 - Beaston - nominates Greenery, jmoo and dogs are lurkers to look at in response to Gralin question. (vibes they're working in tandem in this)

D3 - Baz - Dingster is most suss for him. 3 out of Ding/Dogs/Kurve/JT/MCBG are evil.

D3 - Porp - agrees on Ding vote. Names Kurve votes previously failed to gete traction. "I wouldn’t be surprised if a first gamer was put into the action"

D3 - JT - "Im not opposed to a Ding vote"

D3 - Dingster - Says he genuinely thought MWPP was squirming. Doesn't mind the Beaston shout.

D3 - Baz - JT has him stumped. Says JT usually play disinterested villager role but he has role this time. (contradictory post)

D3 - JT - replies to Beaston saying he was bigger lurker first 2 days and only appeared after JT called him out

D3 - Gralin - sides with JT about Beaston lurking

 

[Frederico_WA]

And here was my true suss list with reasons (from yesterday 1pm).

***

1) Gralin is very active, but has insinuated he has missed things and is an idiot etc. Straight out lie. He has proven he is thorough and observant. This is an easy WW version to play.

2) Cadsky is stinky. Voting pattern is following others. His posts follow a pattern of "oh no, good died overnight" and jumping on whatever theory get posted. Made a very detailed post going after MWPP, despite 1hr earlier saying she seemed switched (duh) on and followed her vote. Crow also said he was the stinkiest on the wagon. I agree with GUH comment that Cadsky D1 comment stunk.

3) 3kz is super active (says he is home with bad back) but he is throwing out theories left and right. Went hard for MWPP/Crow and supported every other theory against them.

4) Porps. She went hard on MWPP and is another one that is throwing out lots of theories without adding much. Her random post about Crowy soft Doc claim reeked, and then she refocussed the wagon to MWPP.

5) Beaston. Playing the village card ... using lots of "us" and "we" etc. Named in MWPP stinky seven. JC13 said he is cagey evil. JT has it out for him.

6) Baz. Openly 'helping' good by instructing flogs yesterday and today. But can't forget he was the late vote onto MWPP to lynch her before Bluey saved her.

 

[Frederico_WA]

Regarding the last flog, there is a particular thing done by a particular dead flog that they can post in chat to verify themself (should they decide to claim once im dead)

 

[DERO]

DEADLINE

 

[DERO]

Kurve , villager killed by mafia

por_please_ya , apprentice killed by wolves

BEaston , roleblocker killed by SK

 

[por_please_ya]

Haha damn. Didn't quite make it
Dead pm please

 

[Frederico_WA]

 

[jmoo wan]

i would’ve bet my left nut that dogs was in cahoots with Beaston but based on his death, i suspect he’s the SK

dogs thanks DERO

 

[Frederico_WA]

Dingster thanks DERO

Chance of baz voting for Dingster to (1) distance himself or (2) point out Alpha wolf?

Dingster

 

[dogs105]

JMoo is the serial killer based on BigJoeD_'s theory that people keep mentioning their role in their posts.

 

[JT_the_Man]

Ah BEaston. So obvious, I just had to keep trying.

Dingster is next

 

[jmoo wan]

what made you guys think to kill porps?

 

[Frederico_WA]

what made you guys think to kill porps?

Chip spotted a tell early on and put her on our radar.

 

[Greenery]

dingster DERO

 

[Frederico_WA]

7 players left ... Roles left
Village: Flog (2), Villager (1)
Wolves: (3) Alpha/Beta/Cub
SK: (1)

There is a chance that por_please_ya was a wolf, so may only be 2x wolves left (and 2 villagers).

Vote count
Dingster: Fred, JT
Dogs: jmoo
Jmoo: dogs

Still to vote:
MC Bad Genius
Greenery
Dingster

Pretty sure Greenery didn't vote yesterday and is a modkill chance today. Nobody tag him ... it's 50/50 shot of evil dead.

 

[Frederico_WA]

Oops .... Hi, Greenery