Prediction Round 1, 2025: Starting 23

[wce1990]

My take on the 22 for next season. Maybe I'm under rating Owies and over rating some of our existing players but it doesn't seem like he has a spot.

At the very least at least we have added some hard workers and created some competition for spots. I think (hope) this, along with a fresh perspective from the new head coach will be the biggest driver for improvement as everyone should be starting off a clean slate. Depending on the pre season we could potentially see a Cripps or Ryan starting in the WAFL if they are unable to buy into the new gameplan while an Owies or Dewar have been performing.

B: Hough - H.Edwards - Duggan
HB: Ginbey - McGovern - Maric
C: Hunt - Graham - Hutchinson
HF: Baker - O.Allen - Kelly
F: Ryan - Waterman - Cripps

R: Flynn - Reid - Yeo

Int: J.Williams - Hewett - Cole - Long

Emg: Owies

 

[Westend]

My take on the 22 for next season. Maybe I'm under rating Owies and over rating some of our existing players but it doesn't seem like he has a spot.

At the very least at least we have added some hard workers and created some competition for spots. I think (hope) this, along with a fresh perspective from the new head coach will be the biggest driver for improvement as everyone should be starting off a clean slate. Depending on the pre season we could potentially see a Cripps or Ryan starting in the WAFL if they are unable to buy into the new gameplan while an Owies or Dewar have been performing.

B: Hough - H.Edwards - Duggan
HB: Ginbey - McGovern - Maric
C: Hunt - Graham - Hutchinson
HF: Baker - O.Allen - Kelly
F: Ryan - Waterman - Cripps

R: Flynn - Reid - Yeo

Int: J.Williams - Hewett - Cole - Long

Emg: Owies

Owies was part of the pick 3 debacle ...I fully expect him and demand that he plays every game and kicks 30 plus goals next season...

and baker down back for me

 

[WCE_phil]

I'll have a crack assuming everyone is fit and good to go with a bit of a change up on structure and positioning.

FB Hough Edwards Maric
HB Baker McGovern Ryan
C Duggan Yeo Kelly
HF Dewar Allen Hewett
FF Owies Waterman Cripps
R Flynn Reid Graham
I J.Williams Ginbey Hutchinson Hunt
S Petch

 

[sharps24]

Assuming we don't get reamed by the AFL in the fixture, we should play all of Richmond, North, Adelaide, Saints, Melbourne twice so you'd pencil those in as wins at home. Thats 5, should beat Richmond twice. 6. If we get Suns at home I'd back us in there. 7. Usually we are good for one derby win regardless of how either team are travelling. 8. Some chance to knock off a top 8 team that's travelled to Optus, some chance to have a stirring away win. Figure that is around 10 wins. Could be less, if we overachieve could be 11/12. Might be enough in an even comp.

 

[DorothyG]

Assuming we don't get reamed by the AFL in the fixture, we should play all of Richmond, North, Adelaide, Saints, Melbourne twice so you'd pencil those in as wins at home. Thats 5, should beat Richmond twice. 6. If we get Suns at home I'd back us in there. 7. Usually we are good for one derby win regardless of how either team are travelling. 8. Some chance to knock off a top 8 team that's travelled to Optus, some chance to have a stirring away win. Figure that is around 10 wins. Could be less, if we overachieve could be 11/12. Might be enough in an even comp.

Agree, we showed signs last year that we aren't as bad as lots seem to think, definitely not the worst in the comp.

Problem was the fitness levels to maintain/run out games and probably more damming, the lack of interest/intent is some matches.

Fix those and we are probably 8-12 win season.

 

[Elite Pete]

2025
Delist - L Edwards
Add Carroll as DFA
(Try and trade back in to the draft)

Draft
12*- Xavier Lindsay
27*- Harrison Oliver
71*- Champion
Rookie- State League Ruck
SSP- ?

B- Hough - Edwards - Cole
HB- Baker - Gov - Maric
C- Hunt - Kelly - Duggan
HF- Ryan - Allen - Hewett (fwd/mid)
F- Owies - Waterman - J Williams
R- Flynn - Reid - Yeo
Bench - Ginbey (Back) - Graham (4th mid) - Hutchinson (Utility ) Cripps (Fwd) - Lindsay* (back/wing)

Bold = Could be still on the list in 5 years 16/23.

EMG- Long* - B Williams - Carroll

Beagles
F- Champion - A Reid - Rawlinson
HF- Long - B Williams - Petruccelle
C- Chesser - Jack Carroll - Dewar
HB- Brockman - Barnett - Johnston
B- Oliver* - Jamieson - Bazzo
R- Mature Age Ruck- Sheed - Hall
Bench - Livingstone - Rotham* - SSP

36/44 could still be on the list in 5 years time

 

[Gazeah78]

2025
Delist - L Edwards
Add Carroll as DFA
(Try and trade back in to the draft)

Draft
12*- Xavier Lindsay
27*- Harrison Oliver
71*- Champion
Rookie- State League Ruck
SSP- ?

B- Hough - Edwards - Cole
HB- Baker - Gov - Maric
C- Hunt - Kelly - Duggan
HF- Ryan - Allen - Hewett (fwd/mid)
F- Owies - Waterman - J Williams
R- Flynn - Reid - Yeo
Bench - Ginbey (Back) - Graham (4th mid) - Hutchinson (Utility ) Cripps (Fwd) - Lindsay* (back/wing)

Bold = Could be still on the list in 5 years 16/23.

EMG- Long* - B Williams - Carroll

Beagles
F- Champion - A Reid - Rawlinson
HF- Long - B Williams - Petruccelle
C- Chesser - Jack Carroll - Dewar
HB- Brockman - Barnett - Johnston
B- Oliver* - Jamieson - Bazzo
R- Mature Age Ruck- Sheed - Hall
Bench - Livingstone - Rotham* - SSP

36/44 could still be on the list in 5 years time

If Hewett comes on like we all hope and J Will keeps improving that forward line looks mint.
Especially if you think about Reid rolling through there at times and giving Hewett some time on ball.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Elite Pete]

If Hewett comes on like we all hope and J Will keeps improving that forward line looks mint.
Especially if you think about Reid rolling through there at times and giving Hewett some time on ball.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Yeah. Decent depth with the forwards too. I don’t know much about Owies to be honest but you’d think a nice role player we need.

Would love Baker up there too but I think we need him down back atm. See how Maric, Ginbey and maybe Lindsay look by round 6 and adjust if they are taking then game ons

Walley in the pipe line too and what Charlie Banfield did in the futures game as well.

 

[THE A5]

Haven’t looked too far into round 1 but J.williams needs to be a mainstay and backed in next year. Kid looked great last season once he settled into the aide. He’ll be of the right age next season for a break out year. With No Darling he’ll become a more of a focal point up forward. What hurst him and any fwd/ruck for us is Billiams/flynn aren’t really the types of rucks that can shoulder majority of the workload in the ruck

 

[jdisc]

In Simmo's Honor:

FB: Rotham HEdwards Jamieson
HB: Cole McGovern HReid
C: Duggan Sheed LEdwards
HF: Brockman OAllen Petch
FF: JWilliams Waterman BWilliams
Fol: Barnett Yeo Kelly
Int: Chesser Livingstone Bazzo Cripps
Sub: Maric

 

[Bender_]

In Simmo's Honor:

FB: Rotham HEdwards Jamieson
HB: Cole McGovern HReid
C: Duggan Sheed LEdwards
HF: Brockman OAllen Petch
FF: JWilliams Waterman BWilliams
Fol: Barnett Yeo Kelly
Int: Chesser Livingstone Bazzo Cripps
Sub: Maric

Pride and Honour aren't the same.

 

[garlic munchers]

Heres my crack at it.

B: Bazzo, H.Edwards, Hough
HB: Baker, McGovern, Duggan
C: Hunt, Reid, Maric
HF: Ryan, Allen, Graham
FF: Cripps, Waterman, Long
R: Flynn, Kelly, Yeo

IC: J.Will, Dewar, Ginbey, Cole
Sub: Hutch


I think Hewett would need a solid month in the WAFL, otherwise he'd be in there.

Agree Edwards at Full Back, as any further up the ground he would be turned inside out like a used pair of jocks.

Imagine him trying to go with a Cameron, Hipwood, Treacy or a Ugle Hagen type.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Agree Edwards at Full Back, as any further up the ground he would be turned inside out like a used pair of jocks.

Imagine him trying to go with a Cameron, Hipwood, Treacy or a Ugle Hagen type.

Harry played well on Cameron during the second half in the last round of the season tbf.

 

[KERRPOW]

We also cant lose sight of the rebuild.

Id flipping spew if we see graham, owies & cripps in the forward line...while long and dewar are rotting in our crappy beagles side.

 

[garlic munchers]

Harry played well on Cameron during the second half in the last round of the season tbf.

Hope Harry continues to improve, but the last 2 quarters of a dead rubber before finals with Cameron kicking 2 goals, isn’t a benchmark to think he can hold down CHB.

He’s clearly best 22 with no Barrass, but must stay close to goal (think McKay at the Bombers).

 

[jdisc]

Harry Edwards has played 37 games, far less than the amount it takes for a key defender to normally find their footing at AFL level

 

[Astro7]

This is Eagle Nation's starting 23. Hutchinson would be in my 23, on the bench at least?

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

I'll have a crack assuming everyone is fit and good to go with a bit of a change up on structure and positioning.

FB Hough Edwards Maric
HB Baker McGovern Ryan
C Duggan Yeo Kelly
HF Dewar Allen Hewett
FF Owies Waterman Cripps
R Flynn Reid Graham
I J.Williams Ginbey Hutchinson Hunt
S Petch

Why are people liking a team that has no Noah Long in it.

One of the first picked

 

[Forward Press]

This is Eagle Nation's starting 23. Hutchinson would be in my 23, on the bench at least?

View attachment 2148570

Given Long and Hewett's injury statuses (statii?), Hutch is already in the best 23.

 

[garlic munchers]

Harry Edwards has played 37 games, far less than the amount it takes for a key defender to normally find their footing at AFL level

Harry is 25 in 2025.

Accept that having McGovern and Barrass may have held him back, but if he was any great shakes some other club would have gone after him (i.e. a 20 yr old Busslingler).

You don't think his agent wouldn't have shopped him around with no takers and if he hasn't, then he would be negligent for the exact reason you state, 37 games/24 yrs old.

 

[Altum Volantes]

Fox Footy have dropped theirs:

B: T.Cole, H.Edwards, B.Hough

HB: J.Hunt, J.McGovern, L.Baker

C: L.Duggan, E.Yeo, R.Ginbey

HF: J.Graham, J.Waterman, L.Ryan

F: M.Owies, O.Allen, J.Cripps

FOLL: B.Williams, T.Kelly, H.Reid

I/C: J.Williams, J.Hutchinson, E.Hewett, J.Petruccelle, C.Chesser

Not too far off I don’t think - Ginbey probably heads back as the 3rd tall.

No Noah Long but he’s a wait and see I think on where he fits - talent but yet to nail a position.

They noted choosing Williams over Flynn - I would agree with this initially but it’s gotta be up for grabs in the Pre-season.

So yeah.

Our depth is horrifying.

 

[Cuzz09]

The good thing is this is the 3rd year after that initial "hard" pre season where we got all the injuries because we weren't used to it so those who were there should be able to be even fitter.

I felt like last year, despite still being poor, we ran out games better than previously so hopefully the fitness will go up another level which can translate to better skills, decision making etc



Sent from my SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[GlennTwenty]

Why are people liking a team that has no Noah Long in it.

One of the first picked

Wow, hats off to you, you finally posted something I actually agree with. I never thought this day would come.

 

[jdisc]

Harry is 25 in 2025.

Accept that having McGovern and Barrass may have held him back, but if he was any great shakes some other club would have gone after him (i.e. a 20 yr old Busslingler).

You don't think his agent wouldn't have shopped him around with no takers and if he hasn't, then he would be negligent for the exact reason you state, 37 games/24 yrs old.

I mean there were rumours other clubs were looking at him before we signed him for 3 years

 

[flyinghi64]

One good thing going into next year there will be some stiff competition for spots all round the ground.
Keep injuries to a minimum, obviously not something you can know, and those that make the best 23 will need to play to keep their spots.
Credits in the bank will be all but a memory you would think with a fresh new HC.

FB - Hough Edwards Cole
HB - Ginbey Gov Baker
M - Maric Yeo Hunt
HF - Ryan Allen JWilliam
FF - Owies Loosh Cripps
R - Flynn Reid Kelly

B - Graham Hutch Duggan Bwilliams Dewar
E - Chesser Petch Brockman

Could swap Bwilliams for one of the Emergencies depending if we want 2 rucks.

Couldn't include players we haven't drafted yet or those that haven't played for nearly a year in Long, Sheed and Hewett, need to see them get through a pre-season first.

Those knocking on the door if you don't perform, Hall, Johnston, Reid, Bazzo, Jamieson and who knows who else will take a big step this year.

If we can field that team, or close to, and have everyone fit and firing there is every chance we can be very competitive.
Good mix of youth and experience in all lines.