Round 1.5 Discussion

toxic · Mar 26, 2014

Champion_Data said:
Without having numbers directly in front of me, I'm pretty sure Cotchin was the benefactor of a large "state of game" weighting. As I'm sure you are all aware, all points are weighted based on the margin at the time of the event and how long there is left in the game. Having a strong contribution late in a tight game receives a high weighting. We're aware of the criticism against this and Cotchin's game is one example that constantly gets raised. We're monitoring it this year with a view to reducing the maximum possible weight assigned in close matches but the weighting will never be removed completely. Performing well when the game is up for grabs is what players build reputations on, not by going missing or alternatively, by getting cheap touches once the game is out of reach of one team.

WOW

Champion Data follow Big Footy!

5 GB USB · Mar 26, 2014

Champion_Data said:
Without having numbers directly in front of me, I'm pretty sure Cotchin was the benefactor of a large "state of game" weighting. As I'm sure you are all aware, all points are weighted based on the margin at the time of the event and how long there is left in the game. Having a strong contribution late in a tight game receives a high weighting. We're aware of the criticism against this and Cotchin's game is one example that constantly gets raised. We're monitoring it this year with a view to reducing the maximum possible weight assigned in close matches but the weighting will never be removed completely. Performing well when the game is up for grabs is what players build reputations on, not by going missing or alternatively, by getting cheap touches once the game is out of reach of one team.

LOL, not laughing at you Champion Data just the fact your posting here. By any chance do you need a storage device preferably 5 GB to keep hold of some of your stats, im very happy to help. :drunk:

Jars458 · Mar 26, 2014

toxic said:
WOW

Champion Data follow Big Footy!

They must have seen your Avatars.

Mad Sainter · Mar 26, 2014

EyeloveRichmond said:
Good one. Cotch is one of the elite midfielders in the comp. Get an idea.

If Cotchin was in the elite, would he not be selected in more teams? He is a very good player, but he doesn't influence games the way an ELITE players like Ablett, Pendenury, Selwood etcetera. Soz brah but Cotch be haxin!!

toxic · Mar 26, 2014

Mad Sainter said:
If Cotchin was in the elite, would he not be selected in more teams? He is a very good player, but he doesn't influence games the way an ELITE players like Ablett, Pendenury, Selwood etcetera. Soz brah but Cotch be haxin!!

Cotchin is selected in more sides than Watson, SJ, Jelwood, Kieran Jack, Cox, NicNat, NRoo, Wingard, Delidio, Swan

so not sure SC selection criteria is the best measure of an elite midfielder

Mad Sainter · Mar 26, 2014

toxic said:
Cotchin is selected in more sides than Watson, SJ, Jelwood, Kieran Jack, Cox, NicNat, NRoo, Wingard, Delidio, Swan

so not sure SC selection criteria is the best measure of an elite midfielder

point taken

toxic · Mar 26, 2014

Mad Sainter said:
If Cotchin was in the elite, would he not be selected in more teams? He is a very good player, but he doesn't influence games the way an ELITE players like Ablett, Pendenury, Selwood etcetera. Soz brah but Cotch be haxin!!

toxic said:
Cotchin is selected in more sides than Watson, SJ, Jelwood, Kieran Jack, Cox, NicNat, NRoo, Wingard, Delidio, Swan

so not sure SC selection criteria is the best measure of an elite midfielder

Mad Sainter said:
point taken

Probably proves how many CRAP supercoach coaches there are!

TheOz · Mar 26, 2014

toxic said:
Probably proves how many CRAP supercoach coaches there are!

Last year's winner has Cotchin.

copthat · Mar 26, 2014

TheOz said:
Last year's winner has Cotchin.

Where is he ranked? Wouldn't mind having a squiz.

Mantastic · Mar 26, 2014

I have Cotchin. Same price as Libba. I have no concerns whatsoever about my choice.

toxic · Mar 26, 2014

TheOz said:
Last year's winner has Cotchin.

copthat said:
Where is he ranked? Wouldn't mind having a squiz.

read somewhere he was ranked 20,000 but i could be wrong....

Jiska · Mar 26, 2014

toxic said:
Cotchin is selected in more sides than Watson, SJ, Jelwood, Kieran Jack, Cox, NicNat, NRoo, Wingard, Delidio, Swan

so not sure SC selection criteria is the best measure of an elite midfielder

That's because he's cheap for his potential output

GT619 · Mar 26, 2014

But I selected Watson

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk

TheOz · Mar 26, 2014

toxic said:
read somewhere he was ranked 20,000 but i could be wrong....

Sounds like what he was ranked after round 1 last season.

toxic · Mar 26, 2014

TheOz said:
Sounds like what he was ranked after round 1 last season.

Thats where im ranked, stratergy working then..... fml

TheOz · Mar 26, 2014

toxic said:
Thats where im ranked, stratergy working then..... fml

Bloke who won it in 2012 was ranked 50,000th or so after round 1.

toxic · Mar 26, 2014

TheOz said:
Bloke who won it in 2012 was ranked 50,000th or so after round 1.

Stop it, im getting a chubby!

Judd_Magic · Mar 26, 2014

TheOz said:
Bloke who won it in 2012 was ranked 50,000th or so after round 1.

Sudden my 18,000 odd overall ranking doesn't seem to bad.

Dunstan and Langdon on the ground this week and Rohan back on the bench should help bolster my score this week.

I expect to go up at least 8,000 places. :rainbow:

TheOz · Mar 26, 2014

Judd_Magic said:
Sudden my 18,000 odd overall ranking doesn't seem to bad.

Dunstan and Langdon on the ground this week and Rohan back on the bench should help bolster my score this week.

I expect to go up at least 8,000 places.

Im around 12,000th, ranked too high to win it it looks like it!

KardiniaPark · Mar 26, 2014

toxic said:
read somewhere he was ranked 20,000 but i could be wrong....

IM BEATING HIM!!!!!!

GT619 · Mar 26, 2014

I'm ranked 32 I'm not complaining

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk

KardiniaPark · Mar 26, 2014

gezimnexhipi said:
I'm ranked 32 I'm not complaining

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk

IM NOT BEATING HIM

The_Steadier · Mar 26, 2014

TheOz said:
scpaige is crap, her starting team was a disaster.

maybe you guys are being too harsh for some reason, I haven't seen that site before now, but her team is pretty close to mine and I knocked out 2300 rd 1?

Judd_Magic · Mar 26, 2014

The_Steadier said:
maybe you guys are being too harsh for some reason, I haven't seen that site before now, but her team is pretty close to mine and I knocked out 2300 rd 1?

I honestly don't mind SC Paige as in watching her weekly sc video reviews.

She's a bit of a dyke, is a female Dane Swan wannabe with all her tattoos and goes for the pies but no-ones perfect!

At least she has all her teeth still!

Amazing Bombers · Mar 26, 2014

Judd_Magic said:
I honestly don't mind SC Paige as in watching her weekly sc video reviews.

She's a bit of a dyke, is a female Dane Swan wannabe with all her tattoos and goes for the pies but no-ones perfect!

At least she has all her teeth still!

I like the page mostly for the end of quarter supercoach scores but some of the video stuff is good as well.

Log In or Create New Account

Round 1.5 Discussion

TheBrownDog

Club Legend

Premium Platinum

All Australian

TheBrownDog

All Australian

TheBrownDog

Brownlow Medallist

Fullee Love

Premiership Player

TheBrownDog

Moderator

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

TheBrownDog

Brownlow Medallist

TheBrownDog

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

WINX!

Norm Smith Medallist

WINX!

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Similar threads