Round 1 Ladder - Penalties and Explanations

doggiesin08

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 17, 2007
Posts
5,473
Likes
140
Location
australia
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
Bushrangers
Thread starter #1
Code:
Team			P	W	L	D	F	A	%	P
[B]Fighting Furies		1	1	0	0	90	69	130	4
East Side Hawks		1	1	0	0	119	93	128	4
Mod Squad		1	1	0	0	92	73	126	4
West Coast Wonders	1	1	0	0	87	77	113	4
Geelong Gumbies		1	0	1	0	77	87	89	0*[/B]
Baghdad Bombers		1	0	1	0	73	92	79	0
Mount Buller Demons	1	0	1	0	93	119	78	0*
Southern Dragons	1	0	1	0	69	90	77	0
* 1st warning given

It has been decided that each team shall receive a 1st warning for either of the following offences:
- failure to notify team signings in the Squad Submission Thread before naming the player(s) in selected team.
- failure to notify league admin of changes to selected team (ins and outs).
# If after the 1st warning, another offence occurs, there will be a 1 premiership point penalty for each occurrence.
# The warning will not apply to late submissions which will incur an immediate 3 premiership point penalty.

The Mount Buller Demons failed to notify team signings in the Squad Submission Thread before naming the player(s) in selected team.
The Geelong Gumbies failed to notify league admin of changes to selected team (ins and outs).



Unfortunately, due to my lack of experience in administrating the league, I have found the league in a situation where stats from pre-season matches are included when saving stat tallies. I thought merely setting the configuration for the league would remove those stats from future lists, however, it seems what I needed to do was have 2 seperate leagues for pre-season and normal season. The stats will have to worked out manually and so it may take a bit longer than expected each round to get them up (they may also be less extensive)


KICKS
Code:
Postmanpav	Wonders		18
Hawks1523	Hawks		17
Bigpapagman	Furies		16
Wiskers32	Shagons		16
Sterephonic	Mod Squad	15
SA Hawkette	Shagons		15
Sausageroll	Bombers		14
Bomberlegend	Demons		14
Fatty Lumpkin	Gumbies		14
RangaInTeal	Gumbies		14
PHX		Furies		14
Gilbert Hodge	Hawks		13
PerthSwans	Gumbies		13
Ninty		Gumbies		13
Cheetah		Shagons		13
Ljp86		Shagons		13
Fred		Mod Squad	12
TigerGlory	Demons		12
Lion4Life	Wonders		12
Snag Breac	Wonders		12
Cormick		Shagons		12
15Petterd15	Shagons		12
Jabso		Mod Squad	11
Larrikin	Mod Squad	11
Doggiesin08	Bombers		11
HANDBALLS
Code:
Cormick		Shagons		15
Gilbert Hodge	Hawks		13
Snag Breac	Wonders		13
Diablo14	Gumbies		13
PHX		Furies		13
Ljp86		Shagons		13
Efl_represent	Bombers		12
PerthSwans	Gumbies		12
Fatty Lumpkin	Gumbies		12
KainoKaino	Furies		12
Cleishy		Furies		12
Tristo		Bombers		11
Tarkyn24	Hawks		11
Headless	Demons		11
Micky Ashman	Gumbies		11
Magpie Matty	Gumbies		11
Carn Tigez	Furies		11
Sterephonic	Mod Squad	10
Sausageroll	Bombers		10
Big Man		Hawks		10
XXX Kings	Hawks		10
Kerrby		Wonders		10
ssfc0203	Wonders		10
BF4		Gumbies		10
Portentous	Gumbies		10
MARKS
Code:
Hawks1523	Hawks		10
Cheetah		Shagons		9
Chezwick	Shagons		9
Snag Breac	Wonders		8
Gilbert Hodge	Hawks		7
Quinzate1	Hawks		7
Keyser Soze	Hawks		7
Micky Ashman	Gumbies		7
Beaver's Army	Furies		7
Fred		Mod Squad	6
Doggiesin08	Bombers		6
Headless	Demons		6
Lion4Life	Wonders		6
Peterss		Gumbies		6
G.F.C.		Gumbies		6
Magpie Matty	Gumbies		6
Cormick		Shagons		6
Ljp86		Shagons		6
Keato3		Shagons		6
Kahuna		Shagons		6
TACKLES
Code:
Cleishy		Furies		8
Wiskers32	Shagons		8
Larrikin	ModSquad	7
Bomberlegend	Demons		7
Portentous	Gumbies		7
Sausageroll	Bombers		6
Tarkyn24	Hawks		6
Rick18		Wonders		6
SA Hawkette	Shagons		6
EBIAC		Demons		5
Made4September	Demons		5
Mop		Wonders		5
Equus		Furies		5
15Petterd15	Shagons		5
Stereophonic	ModSquad	4
Tristo		Bombers		4
TigerGlory	Demons		4
RangaInTeal	Gumbies		4
PHX		Furies		4
Wizzbang123	Shagons		4
Ljp86		Shagons		4
HITOUTS
Code:
Postmanpav	Wonders		14
15Petterd15	Shagons		12
Efl_represent	Bombers		11
Made4September	Hawks		11
Equus		Furies		11
Larrikin	Mod Squad	10
Boncer34	Hawks		8
Stakerz		Hawks		7
RangaInTeal	Gumbies		7
GOALS
Code:
Croweater41	Wonders		5
Quinzate1	Hawks		4
Okeydoke7	Demons		4
MrEagles	Mod Squad	3
HawkPatrol	Bombers		3
Sausageroll	Bombers		3
YOTC		Hawks		3
Cara_coughar	Demons		3
Tugga		Furies		3
Pie 4 Life	Shagons		3
Jabso		Mod Squad	2
Cousin Jed	Mod Squad	2
Larrikin	Mod Squad	2
Borgsta		Mod Squad	2
Lovett Lover 13	Bombers		2
Wally		Hawks		2
Zarko		Hawks		2
TigerGlory	Demons		2
Shallow		Wonders		2
Postmanpav	Wonders		2
One_eyedtiger	Furies		2
Emperor		Furies		2
HBK619		Furies		2
PHX		Furies		2
Keato3		Shagons		2
15Petterd15	Shagons		2
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Fred

Premium Platinum
Joined
Nov 17, 2000
Posts
36,601
Likes
4,467
Location
Echuca
AFL Club
St Kilda
Other Teams
The Roys FFC
#2
Re: Round 1 Ladder - Penalties and Explinations

That seems arse-about to me. I'd have thought that naming ineligible players was more serious than a late team submission.
3 points for being late is a hell of a penalty.
 

doggiesin08

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 17, 2007
Posts
5,473
Likes
140
Location
australia
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
Bushrangers
Thread starter #5
Re: Round 1 Ladder - Penalties and Explinations

That seems arse-about to me. I'd have thought that naming ineligible players was more serious than a late team submission.
3 points for being late is a hell of a penalty.
The idea for being 3 rather than 1 is to punish a team more severely who continually make late submissions. With the punishment only being 1 point, the would be little difference between 1 late submission and 2 late submissions (baring the influence of draws of course).
 

Tarkyn_24

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Dec 23, 2006
Posts
28,336
Likes
23,244
AFL Club
Collingwood
#7
Re: Round 1 Ladder - Penalties and Explinations

+ Doggies, did you start a new season after finishing the pre-season?

That should've wiped the competition stats clean, but kept the stats as far as games played etc.

You also need to file the previous season (in this case, the pre season) in a serparate file.
 

doggiesin08

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 17, 2007
Posts
5,473
Likes
140
Location
australia
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
Bushrangers
Thread starter #8
Re: Round 1 Ladder - Penalties and Explinations

+ Doggies, did you start a new season after finishing the pre-season?

That should've wiped the competition stats clean, but kept the stats as far as games played etc.

You also need to file the previous season (in this case, the pre season) in a serparate file.
not sure, stuffed up somewhere though. alright though, got the excel going nice:D Stats will be up shortly.
 

peterss

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 22, 2004
Posts
10,089
Likes
613
Location
Safety Bay WA
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Brentford FC, Geelong Gumbies,
#9
Re: Round 1 Ladder - Penalties and Explinations

Wasnt aware of the Gumbies first warning penalty.....Who was not named in the squad submission thread before naming the side?
 

doggiesin08

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 17, 2007
Posts
5,473
Likes
140
Location
australia
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
Bushrangers
Thread starter #10
Re: Round 1 Ladder - Penalties and Explinations

Wasnt aware of the Gumbies first warning penalty.....Who was not named in the squad submission thread before naming the side?
is stated pretty clearly:
The Geelong Gumbies failed to notify league admin of changes to selected team (ins and outs).
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Ljp86

West Coast Eagles - 2018 AFL Premiers!!
Joined
Apr 5, 2005
Posts
15,009
Likes
12,829
Location
Jennifer Hawkins' bed
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Indoor Sports WA
#12
Re: Round 1 Ladder - Penalties and Explinations

Hmm, bottom spot. Only the first round though and we've shown we can play good footy.

Should be rising up the ladder anytime soon.
 

peterss

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 22, 2004
Posts
10,089
Likes
613
Location
Safety Bay WA
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Brentford FC, Geelong Gumbies,
#14
Re: Round 1 Ladder - Penalties and Explinations

Hi kerrby :)

Was just wondering and wanting clarification thats all...and its clear now.

You stil suck ;)
 

PHX

Quarterback Style
Joined
Jan 15, 2006
Posts
33,009
Likes
6,694
Location
Oz
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Orlando Magic, Baltimore Ravens
#15
Re: Round 1 Ladder - Penalties and Explinations

Despite rules being set in two threads, they're suddenly flexible? The Furies would naturally expect a similar concession if we breach a rule in the future going by today's precedent. ;)
 

Ljp86

West Coast Eagles - 2018 AFL Premiers!!
Joined
Apr 5, 2005
Posts
15,009
Likes
12,829
Location
Jennifer Hawkins' bed
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Indoor Sports WA
#16
Re: Round 1 Ladder - Penalties and Explinations

Penalties are the wrong way around. 3 points for a late submission is very harsh whereas the penalty for playing an unregistered player is way too low, playing an unregistered player could be likened to cheating.

The warning for a late submission is fair enough but I don't think one should be given for the other offence. All captains should be aware of the rules by now.
 

doggiesin08

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 17, 2007
Posts
5,473
Likes
140
Location
australia
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
Bushrangers
Thread starter #18
Re: Round 1 Ladder - Penalties and Explinations

Despite rules being set in two threads, they're suddenly flexible? The Furies would naturally expect a similar concession if we breach a rule in the future going by today's precedent. ;)
depends if it complies with the warnings set. If you can think of any possible rule breaches not yet covered, the rules thread is a place to list them so they can be sorted, hopefully before an event like this rises (one of the key problems with this situation was that no penalty had been set for the breach made by the Demons, and I felt it would be unfair to punish the Gumbies in terms of premiership points for their offence given it was round 1 and there was possibly some uncertainty as to whether changes to team from pre-season needed to be listed).
 

PHX

Quarterback Style
Joined
Jan 15, 2006
Posts
33,009
Likes
6,694
Location
Oz
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Orlando Magic, Baltimore Ravens
#21
Re: Round 1 Ladder - Penalties and Explinations

Fair enough with it all, the time has passed, the Demons have learned their lesson. :thumbsu:


You would also get your first warning PHX.
*woosh* Right over my head, lc.
 

Rick18

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Oct 30, 2007
Posts
5,972
Likes
1,718
Location
Vermont
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
San Antonio Spurs
#24
was a bit unsure, but it was top 5 two seasons ago with 8 teams. No issue was raised over off season so thought i'd leave it the same.
Yeah that's fair enough. Assuming it's too late to change it to a top 4 this season, it should be changed back at the end of the season I reckon.
 
Top Bottom