Preview Round 10, 2019: St.Kilda v Carlton - Marvel Stadium, Sunday 26th May, 3:20PM AEST

Who Wins?

  • Saints

    Votes: 75 91.5%
  • Blues

    Votes: 7 8.5%

  • Total voters
    82
Status
Not open for further replies.

George

Moderator
Aug 17, 2015
14,155
44,953
Victoria
AFL Club
St Kilda
Other Teams
Philadelphia Eagles Liverpool

______________________________________________________________


Preview
St.Kilda v Carlton






St.Kilda drop to 4-5 on the season after their fourth successive defeat, this time by 41 points to Collingwood on the MCG. After hanging with the Magpies for three quarters the Saints fell away in the last.

Carlton were insipid from the outset, trailing by 40 points at quarter time before the Giants piled on another 13 goals in the remaining three quarters to run away 93 point winners. Carlton's 8th loss for the season sees them enter Round 10 on the bottom of the AFL ladder.


Let’s have a look at possible best 22s:

St.Kilda Best 22
B:
Daniel McKenzie, Nathan Brown, Shane Savage
HB: Callum Wilkie, Josh Battle, Jonathon Marsh
C: Ed Phillips, Sebastian Ross, Jack Newnes
HF: Jack Billings, Josh Bruce, Dean Kent
F: Robbie Young, Tim Membrey, Jade Gresham
Foll: Rowan Marshall, Jack Steele, Jack Sinclair
I/C: Luke Dunstan, Blake Acres, Ben Paton, Matthew Parker

Carlton Best 22
B:
Dale Thomas, Jacob Weitering, Caleb Marchbank
HB: Nic Newman, Mitch McGovern, Jack Silvagni
C: Sam Petrevski-Seton, Patrick Cripps, Ed Curnow
HF: Zac Fisher, Levi Casboult, Darcy Lang
F: Michael Gibbons, Harry McKay, Harrison Macreadie
Foll: Matthew Kreuzer, Sam Walsh, Paddy Dow
I/C: Lochie O'Brien, Liam Stocker, Charlie Curnow, Will Setterfield



Medical Room




The Saints' Ed Phillips passed a concussion test and eventually returned to the field after copping a high hit from Magpie Travis Varcoe late in the first quarter.

As for Carlton, Marc Murphy was sent to hospital to get his rubs checked after he was crunched by Shane Mumford in the first term, and the former skipper was a big loss for the Blues.



Preview




St.Kilda's tough fixture concluded on Saturday afternoon at the MCG against Collingwood in what was Josh Bruce's 100th game, Shane Savage's 150th game, and livewire young forward Robbie Young's AFL debut. The Saints were in the game for the best part of three quarters before Collingwood went into another gear in the final term to put the result beyond doubt. Good news for Saints fans however is now the fixture plays into their hands well, with the majority of the Saints remaining games against teams below them on the ladder.

In what was a tough loss on Saturday, it was forward Tim Membrey who stood up for St.Kilda - kicking 4 goals, including 9 score involvements, 11 disposals and 6 marks to be voted best on ground for the afternoon.


Other notable performances included Jack Billings (29 disposals, 8 marks), Shane Savage (25 disposals, 1 goal), Luke Dunstan (30 disposals, 5 tackles) and midfield tagger Jack Steele (25 disposals, 4 marks & 7 tackles).

And a nod to Robbie Young who electrified the crowd with two goals on debut.


Carlton have been commended for their fighting spirit this year, but ultimately falling short on most occasions with losses to Richmond, Port Adelaide, Sydney, Gold Coast, Hawthorn, North Melbourne, Collingwood and now GWS. Their sole victory for the year against the Bulldogs at Marvel Stadium. Unfortunately Carlton are again staring down the barrel of another bottom four season, and a stark reality of the difference in quality came on Sunday afternoon as the Giants demolished the hapless Blues to the tune of 93 points.

In what was the worst loss of Carlton's year, they must take some positives from the loss. Harry McKay was solid up forward, kicking 3 goals to go along with 13 disposals and 6 marks, and Nic Newman was the leading disposal getter on the ground for the Blues, finishing with 29 touches and voted best on ground.



Potential changes



St.Kilda's Hunter Clark looks set to come straight back into the side following his 31 disposal (and 1 goal) game in the VFL against Essendon on Sunday.

Other notable inclusions could be Nick Coffield (22 disposals, 6 marks), Nick Hind (22 disposals, 3 tackles), and Ben Long (15 disposals, 4 tackles).



Key Match-Ups



Patrick Cripps
The Carlton captain had a very quiet night in the Blues loss to the Giants, however great players don't stay down for long, and if the Saints (and primarily Jack Steele) can get a hold of the two time John Nicholls' medalist in the middle, they'll put themselves in a great position to win the game.

Harry McKay
McKay kicked three goals on Sunday against the Giants - almost half of Carlton's entire goal tally. With St.Kilda's makeshift back six giving up 17 goals to Collingwood on Saturday afternoon, stopping McKay will be front of mind.



Tip




Thankfully the toughest stretch of games for St.Kilda's season is over, and now the draw really opens up with winnable games littering the back half of the year. It starts this weekend for the Saints, with the Blues coming off a 93 point drubbing and their ex captain in Marc Murphy out with injury. After matching it for three quarters with last years Grand Finalists and a premiership fancy in Collingwood, I think the Saints are ready to get back onto the winners list and do it convincingly.



Saints by 58 points.

Thoughts?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Plugger35

The umpires are always right!
Sep 27, 2008
94,126
92,493
AFL Club
St Kilda
Other Teams
Chelsea, Black Caps, Subiaco
In - Bailey Rice

Let him rub it in Carlton's faces with a BOG against them.

Richo would never be that daring though, he'll bring in someone safe like Justin Peckett.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Mikka84

Premiership Player
Feb 9, 2009
3,212
10,662
AFL Club
St Kilda
The St Kilda in me thinks this is very losable. But surely not..

We’re simply not kicking scores or having any impact in the middle to be confident at present. I do worry about their forwards, in Mackay and Curnow. And we have to stop Cripps. Somehow.

Depending on tomorrow, I want Clark and Hind in. Pace the key to this game. Break them open.
 

OES

Nigel Staplecock
Jul 26, 2006
30,169
21,466
AFL Club
St Kilda
The St Kilda in me thinks this is very losable. But surely not..

We’re simply not kicking scores or having any impact in the middle to be confident at present. I do worry about their forwards, in Mackay and Curnow. And we have to stop Cripps. Somehow.

Depending on tomorrow, I want Clark and Hind in. Pace the key to this game. Break them open.
Yes yes yes. Pace is super important. We need every speedster we can get.
 

OES

Nigel Staplecock
Jul 26, 2006
30,169
21,466
AFL Club
St Kilda
Agreed. We must win this game. But this is a massive danger game. If we are not at our best we are vulnerable.

I am pretty confident they won’t go into this game thinking all they have to is turn up to win but I’m a little nervous about them possibly taking them lightly.


But here’s the absolute crux.

Kick straight. I’ve had enough of 10.10, 9.12 and 10.14. The last four weeks we have scored 10.8, 10.10, 10.10 and 10.11

I want to see something more like the 15.5 against Melbourne. Tired of inaccuracy. It feels like no matter what we do nothing improves.
 

saintkildaman

Norm Smith Medallist
Jun 1, 2010
9,584
5,945
Canberra
AFL Club
St Kilda
We haven’t lost a game when Acres has had 28+ touches. Play him in the guts or send him to Sandringham, unsure what his role is at the moment but it’s a complete waste of talent and a spot in the 22.

Newnes and Kent should also be on the chopping block, not good enough for players of their experience. Hind is well due to debut this game.
 

Hayes4PM

Norm Smith Medallist
Sep 7, 2013
9,554
17,107
AFL Club
St Kilda
Must win, I'd consider dropping Newnes and Acres but to be fair Acres is just being plonked anywhere like a utility, pretty sure the coaches think he's Jeremy McGovern. I'd look at White/Hind/Clark as an in for Newnes. Honestly, Clark is a cut above VFL, I'm just not sure his tank is up to AFL standards yet, but **** it, he played well last week and if he plays well again tomorrow, then bring him in for Newnes.
 

pebblesofsand

Premiership Player
Oct 18, 2011
4,391
10,303
AFL Club
St Kilda
Other Teams
Ocean Grove Collendina Cobras
In Carlisle, Roberton, Geary, Steven, Hannebery and Lonie.

Out - Brown, Paton, Phillips, Sinclair, Marsh and Kent.


Geary Battle McKenzie
Roberton Carlisle Savage
Hannebery Steele Billings
Young Bruce Parker
Lonie Membrey Gresham

Marshall Ross Steven

Int Wilkie, Dunstan, Newnes, Acres
 

Ekomaira

Norm Smith Medallist
Oct 6, 2012
5,367
8,438
AFL Club
St Kilda
In Carlisle, Roberton, Geary, Steven, Hannebery and Lonie.

Out - Brown, Paton, Phillips, Sinclair, Marsh and Kent.


Geary Battle McKenzie
Roberton Carlisle Savage
Hannebery Steele Billings
Young Bruce Parker
Lonie Membrey Gresham

Marshall Ross Steven

Int Wilkie, Dunstan, Newnes, Acres
Spiderman's younger brother Young Bruce Parker
 

Diehard Saint

Norm Smith Medallist
Jan 17, 2016
6,851
21,153
Melbourne
AFL Club
St Kilda
In Carlisle, Roberton, Geary, Steven, Hannebery and Lonie.

Out - Brown, Paton, Phillips, Sinclair, Marsh and Kent.


Geary Battle McKenzie
Roberton Carlisle Savage
Hannebery Steele Billings
Young Bruce Parker
Lonie Membrey Gresham

Marshall Ross Steven

Int Wilkie, Dunstan, Newnes, Acres
Doubt Robbo will be back, sadly.
Webster?
 

Plugger35

The umpires are always right!
Sep 27, 2008
94,126
92,493
AFL Club
St Kilda
Other Teams
Chelsea, Black Caps, Subiaco
Why would you drop Brown? He was one of our best players.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom