I read it was knee bruising. He needed a rest anyway.
Review Round 10: Collingwood 50-41 Sydney
- Thread starter PonsfordMagpie
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
jmac70
On the porch
The internet
- Banned
- #228
Been busy since the game finished, and I just read that Quaynor had his shin torn open.
Nasty injury, but my first thoughts were of a broken leg when i saw it live.
Otherwise hopefully Pendles is back for our next game.
Nasty injury, but my first thoughts were of a broken leg when i saw it live.
Otherwise hopefully Pendles is back for our next game.
Bucks said "that was well played"
Show some courtesy for other people before posting that, including young children who use this forum.
ppoiter
Premiership Player
- Feb 28, 2013
- 3,246
- 3,847
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Surely it's up to the match officials to check everyone's studs before the game? Please tell me the AFL doesn't ask players to self-police on important stuff like this
The Pies have the 2nd worse inside 50 to goal conversion rate (19.%) in the AFL only marginally better than Adelaide (18.5%). This is our poorest I50 conversation rate since data commenced in 1997. Even in our bottom of the ladder year in 1998 our I50 to goal rate was a healthy 25.6.
Tonight was a terrible night no matter from what angle one looks at it.
Daics – Building on an already consistent season to date. 25 possessions; 7 I50’s; 4 clearances; 501 metres gained, and the winning goal that was straight out of his father’s highlight reel. Also had 6 turnovers and at times a tendency to rush his kicks
Ruscoe – Should have kicked 4 goals tonight but maybe nerves got to him on debut. Looks a useful player and has some speed
Stevo – Buckley needs to put him back deep forward because he has provided nothing for us further up the ground. Looks disinterested and continues to play bruise free football. Had 8 kicks and not much else.
Maynard – Mr Consistency. My heart was in my mouth when he went down into the rooms clutching his shoulder. You won’t die wondering with him. Always gives 100%
Checkers – Another Jeckyl and Hyde performance. A licorice allsorts type of game
Adams – Had 29 disposals of which only 13 were effective (DE 45%). Got better once Treloar went off. Is becoming a regular goal kicker
IQ – was hardly sighted before he was stretchered off in the last quarter.
Noble – Played well but was let down at times by poor disposal. Had 5 turnovers. But provided drive from HB and wing.
Phillips – None of his attempted tackles stuck. No tackles for the game. His shot for goal 40m out on a 45 degree angle missed everything. Needs to have a break. Love to see Rantall get his chance.
Thomas – Devoid of all confidence. Was caught with the ball on several occasions, kicked into the man on the mark and with a leading forward coming towards him he kicked it over his head. Buckley needs to pull the trigger and give one of the youngsters a go. Nothing is working for JT at the moment. 13 disposals for 96 metres gained.
Grundy – He again appeared sluggish and struggled for any real impact around the ground. He 16 possessions for only 57 metres gained. 32 HO and 6 clearances.
Callum Brown – 14 possessions for 97 metres gained. Again had the chance to nail a shot running into goal from 35-40m only to fall short. However provided forward pressure that was lacking against the Dockers last week.
WHE – Two impact injuries within the first 10 minutes of the game and it was all over for him.
Elliott – Tackled well tonight. His disposal whilst in the midfield was average. Should stay forward.
Magden –.I thought he played well. 15 possessions at 88%. 4 tackles, 4 R50, and 9 intercepts
Treloar – Had 25 possessions in less than a ½ of football before succumbing to another hamstring injury. Unfortunately, his mountain of possessions failed to hurt the opposition (ala Scott West)
Roughie – Since Howe has been out Roughie appears unsettled and lost. However I prefer him in the side than out of it
Reid – First game for the year. Offered a contest on a night the opposition flooded our forward line.
Sidebottom – I wasn’t aware that he had as many possessions as he did. Set Adams up for a wonderful goal.
Crisp – Struggled with his disposal tonight
Moore – Didn’t have many possessions tonight but he didn’t waste one. the cornerstone of our defence
Sier – Got a bit of the ball but turned it over a far bit with poor decision making. Building into it
Tonight was a terrible night no matter from what angle one looks at it.
- We lost WHE with injury in the opening minutes
- We had over 20 I50’s before we got our first goal with the aid of a dinky free kick (otherwise how else were we going to get one
- The turnovers in the 1st half were embarrassing. Our midfielders regularly missing targets far and away
- Our over reliance on Handball again did a lot of players in by regularly handballing to teammates in a worse position
- We had 332 possessions to the Swans 241
- We had 150 handballs to the Swans 87
- The disconnect between the midfield and the forward line is deepening
- It appears every team have worked out our game plan except our coach
- The only thing missing for 2½ quarters was the Benny Hill music
- Our entries into F50 were either too shallow or too deep. It took until the 3rd quarter before the players lowered their eyes when kicking into F50
- Significant injuries to Treloar and IQ inflicted further pain
- Tonight we scored 6 goals from 50 - I50’s (12%). The Swans kicked the same amount of goals but from 17 less entries
- Tonight we took 2 contested marks to the Swans 13
Daics – Building on an already consistent season to date. 25 possessions; 7 I50’s; 4 clearances; 501 metres gained, and the winning goal that was straight out of his father’s highlight reel. Also had 6 turnovers and at times a tendency to rush his kicks
Ruscoe – Should have kicked 4 goals tonight but maybe nerves got to him on debut. Looks a useful player and has some speed
Stevo – Buckley needs to put him back deep forward because he has provided nothing for us further up the ground. Looks disinterested and continues to play bruise free football. Had 8 kicks and not much else.
Maynard – Mr Consistency. My heart was in my mouth when he went down into the rooms clutching his shoulder. You won’t die wondering with him. Always gives 100%
Checkers – Another Jeckyl and Hyde performance. A licorice allsorts type of game
Adams – Had 29 disposals of which only 13 were effective (DE 45%). Got better once Treloar went off. Is becoming a regular goal kicker
IQ – was hardly sighted before he was stretchered off in the last quarter.
Noble – Played well but was let down at times by poor disposal. Had 5 turnovers. But provided drive from HB and wing.
Phillips – None of his attempted tackles stuck. No tackles for the game. His shot for goal 40m out on a 45 degree angle missed everything. Needs to have a break. Love to see Rantall get his chance.
Thomas – Devoid of all confidence. Was caught with the ball on several occasions, kicked into the man on the mark and with a leading forward coming towards him he kicked it over his head. Buckley needs to pull the trigger and give one of the youngsters a go. Nothing is working for JT at the moment. 13 disposals for 96 metres gained.
Grundy – He again appeared sluggish and struggled for any real impact around the ground. He 16 possessions for only 57 metres gained. 32 HO and 6 clearances.
Callum Brown – 14 possessions for 97 metres gained. Again had the chance to nail a shot running into goal from 35-40m only to fall short. However provided forward pressure that was lacking against the Dockers last week.
WHE – Two impact injuries within the first 10 minutes of the game and it was all over for him.
Elliott – Tackled well tonight. His disposal whilst in the midfield was average. Should stay forward.
Magden –.I thought he played well. 15 possessions at 88%. 4 tackles, 4 R50, and 9 intercepts
Treloar – Had 25 possessions in less than a ½ of football before succumbing to another hamstring injury. Unfortunately, his mountain of possessions failed to hurt the opposition (ala Scott West)
Roughie – Since Howe has been out Roughie appears unsettled and lost. However I prefer him in the side than out of it
Reid – First game for the year. Offered a contest on a night the opposition flooded our forward line.
Sidebottom – I wasn’t aware that he had as many possessions as he did. Set Adams up for a wonderful goal.
Crisp – Struggled with his disposal tonight
Moore – Didn’t have many possessions tonight but he didn’t waste one. the cornerstone of our defence
Sier – Got a bit of the ball but turned it over a far bit with poor decision making. Building into it
Very typical Pies game frankly, only the quarters were out of order. If put in typical pies order it would be 3-1-2-4 namely the third quarter was the overwhelming, almost good quarter, 1-2 the lackluster can this team kick a goal quarters, and the 4th being the hold on for life quarter as always.
A very peculiar game in that it possessed all the things we hate about the 2020 pies: horrid handballs, overuse, lackluster kicking accuracy, but also saw (for the first time in recent memory) a team come out of half-time with a spark, seeming tactical/style changes, and something resembling a desire to win a game of football, which crescendoed into a Goal of the Year contender for Daicos.
In true Collingwood form also some big injuries to further torpedo our list. Interesting to see how the selection group balances yet another fresh crop of outs.
A very peculiar game in that it possessed all the things we hate about the 2020 pies: horrid handballs, overuse, lackluster kicking accuracy, but also saw (for the first time in recent memory) a team come out of half-time with a spark, seeming tactical/style changes, and something resembling a desire to win a game of football, which crescendoed into a Goal of the Year contender for Daicos.
In true Collingwood form also some big injuries to further torpedo our list. Interesting to see how the selection group balances yet another fresh crop of outs.
I'll probably get piled into because for some unknown reason, dozens of posters have some weird agenda against him, but Jack Madgen has been playing some very fine footy in the last two weeks. Doesn't do much wrong, and is a perfectly fine back-up for Howe. He gels in well with his defensive teammates and rarely panics under pressure, isn't afraid to get a little physical and he has laid some good tackles too.
At 27 years (yea that's actually his age, thought he was 25 tops), I won't pretend he has a great deal of upside but what he is and how much he'd be getting paid (very little), he's a good player to have.
At 27 years (yea that's actually his age, thought he was 25 tops), I won't pretend he has a great deal of upside but what he is and how much he'd be getting paid (very little), he's a good player to have.
60 Yards Out
Club Legend
- Dec 7, 2016
- 2,994
- 5,744
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Not sure plastic has that glint.
Agree, hes very unfashionable in the way he goes about it but is a good reliable steady depth option. Hes got a bit of toe, too.
- Sep 3, 2019
- 17,241
- 49,912
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
The rupture last year or the frostbite early this year
There were some bad plays, like handballs to teammates under pressure, but over all we were pretty good. Could be helped we were tackling their kids hard but we looked considerably more aggressive.
Clean up the forward 50 entries (add Cox) and our problems look miniscule.
- Mar 29, 2019
- 9,034
- 13,665
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I could only happen to us
Swans kicked two lucky goals from outside 50 from bombs.
We didnt get any easy or lucky goals at our end.... except arguably a very generous 50 metre penalty to Noble.
These things will turn around but we need to tidy up disposal and decision making, especially in the forward half.
- Mar 29, 2019
- 9,034
- 13,665
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I think he is pointing out the difference in luck. Lynch breaks his hand, plays the next week. De Goey injures the ligaments in his hand, out for the season.
Better off breaking a bone.
jmac70
On the porch
Probably. Im not too fussed about this season now. If we can keep getting games into young players that will be a positive. Our chances of even making finals now are low.
- Apr 18, 2015
- 21,055
- 25,576
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- PAOK of SALONIKA LIVERPOOL
Yeah you know exactly what happened baby.. Daiiiiiicccoooooooooos! In da kyber mate..
From a stats perspective (only) we did. We had 90 more possessions; 63 more HBs, 34 to 24 in clearances; 28 to 15 in stoppages, and 50 to 33 in I50's. I agree with you, we butchered our ball movement, we were slow going forward where we missed our targets completely or kicked it to the wrong contest, handballed to a teammate in a worse position etc. It was terrible to watch. Bucks has to focus on the positives because there are so many negatives with our poor form and mounting injuries
- Banned
- #246
Sydney were horrendous we were slighlty better ( luckier) What the hell has happened to our footskills? If I hear one more person tell me we should have won by more if we kicked straight I will spew up. We don't kick straight because we can't bloody kick.
left at home
Hall of Famer
Got the win, thank goodness, but l wish we could kick straight, instead of those bloody behinds.
Daicos, just like his old man moment, brilliant
Daicos, just like his old man moment, brilliant
Wouldn’t mind seeing him in the middle.
Such clean hands and evasive.
Might shark a few of Grundys taps and put it lace out to the forwards
- Aug 31, 2014
- 14,579
- 25,889
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I just remembered JT & Mihocek kicking into the man on the mark about 60 out from goal.
Anyone else feel like they lost 2 years of their lives watching that?? Basic stuff.
Anyone else feel like they lost 2 years of their lives watching that?? Basic stuff.
- Banned
- #250
When you pick players that can't kick hoping they will then suddenly kick straight is a waste of time.
- Status
