Round 10 Trades

[Hoges64]

After the first game has kicked off, can I make trades and then reverse them so it reverts back to the team I had after said first kick-off?

 

[Vineyy]

Miller > Fwd Premo (via Krak DPP)
Rocky > Fwd Premo (via Bonts DPP)

~860k

Pavlich & McGovern?

Zorko & Buddy?

I like the Zorko call. Reckon he's a chance to improve on scoring with Hanley back?
He's 100k cheaper than at the start of the year.

 

[TheOz]

After the first game has kicked off, can I make trades and then reverse them so it reverts back to the team I had after said first kick-off?

No.

 

[Hoges64]

No.

Cool, thanks!

 

[karaoke]

I like the Zorko call. Reckon he's a chance to improve on scoring with Hanley back?
He's 100k cheaper than at the start of the year.

Yep

 

[stevebbb]

help me please, going crazy
15 trades, 105k bank

1. Krak to Dumont/Glenn
Clark to Wines (via McGov to fwd, Saad to def)

2. Krak to Dumont/Glenn
Clark to Shaw (via McGov to fwd)

3. Clark to Steele
Krak to Wines

4. No trades

***keeping Rocky for now

Sorry to do an Asho but I'm desperate for some opinions
Thanks

 

[joop]

He has questionable JS this round. If people are like me, and are using Oxley as our D6, then its too risky not to trade him out, rather than not trade and cop a zero.

That, and you'll have to trade him out prior to Rnd 12 anyway. So, why bear the risk for a player you're going to ditch in two rounds anyway.

Fair enough. I'll be straight swapping him to Smith after adelaides bye which happens to be collingwoods bye.
Trades are too valuable this year.

 

[Hairy Lager]

wish id started with duggan now good js and starting to show some confidence id expect him to average pretty well if they don't keep him tagging. but have a feeling they wont as his skills look too good to waste tagging, I guess we'll see. If he scores 80+ this week I wouldn't be surprised but if he doesn't then my theory must be flawed

Some flog on this board talked me out of him, bloody campaigners the lot of them.
I need to back my gut next year.

 

[Super Hans]

Went
Rockliff > Dawson
Krak > Dahl

 

[StoneX]

Haven't traded yet... Can't decide between these:

1. Krak -> Amon & Clark -> Buddy
2. Oxley -> Hamling & Clark -> Dahlhaus

 

[Vineyy]

Haven't traded yet... Can't decide between these:

1. Krak -> Amon & Clark -> Buddy
2. Oxley -> Hamling & Clark -> Dahlhaus

Just be weary that Hamling and Dahlhaus have the bye next week.

 

[StoneX]

Just be weary that Hamling and Dahlhaus have the bye next week.

Thanks Vineyy. With all the injuries lately, that would screw me next round with only 15 or 16 on field. I'll stick with number 1.

 

[ike2112]

Any reason that noone has considered gunston as F5/F6?
He's averaging 99. His low of 70 was the first round and if you take that out all of his scores have been between 95 and ~130.

Also he's pretty cheap at ~500k

I'm bringing him in as my F6 along with wallis for krak to cover donuts

One of my favourite non-Saints, have had him in fantasy games last two seasons. And he is frustrating; he'll drop a 50 then a 70 and then you're stuck with someone around $360k with limited sideways trade options. I know his record this year shows consistency, but I've just been burned too many times now.

 

[ike2112]

It's hard to give constructive advice without seeing a screenshot of your entire team (pre-trades) including bank money.

I'd posted them the page prior, which led to this discussion.

Ended up deciding I didn't feel comfortable chasing a player with only 1 game played so ruled out being able to get to Gray with Boston etc.
However figured out that Krak's value isn't going to change so shouldn't panic about getting him out, just focus on who will likely drop, get 22 on the field and then consider end team.
So went Hurn/Rocky to Buddy/Wallis on the basis that Hurn was gonna lose $25k, Rocky could be out for as much as 6 weeks, whilst both those I bought in will rise in $ and I can at some point change Buddy into Gray.

 

[Satan]

talia dogs to corr
rocky to dangerfield

 

[alfyyy3]

Would appreciate some advice guys .. trading Miller out for C.Ward/Jelwood or finish off my forward line and bring in L.Franklin ..

surely Selwood cant keep churning out poor scores..

 

[Hoges64]

Decided, gonna keep Rocky and trade Bonts.

So have gone Bonts to McLovin (and will swing into DEF when I can) and Touk Miller via Krak's DPP for......


Wait for it.......




West Coasts Callum Sinclair.

Also gives me ruck cover for the foreseeable future. *fingers crossed*

 

[GAsnr]

Would appreciate some advice guys .. trading Miller out for C.Ward/Jelwood or finish off my forward line and bring in L.Franklin ..

surely Selwood cant keep churning out poor scores..

Selwood still has a B/E of 126, so even if he goes big you're not going to lose much on waiting for him. If I were you I'd wait until he pulls together 2 weeks of decent scores before bringing him in.

Ward similar scenario, but been more consistent than the above^.

I'd take Franklin. Was 2nd picked in my fwd line after Gray this year. B/E of 83, so will only increase in value for a while now. And plays GC.

Edit: I have Selwood and he's pissing me off something chronic, so that could be clouding my judgement a bit...

 

[xisor]

Rockliff > Wallis
Clark > Buddy

 

[Baker_for_PM]

With the cash i will get from trading out Krakouer, Is it better to fix up my backline by bringing in someone like Bob for Oxley/Lumumba or do a sideways trade of the Bont to save myself a donut. I am going for overall score rather then league wins and am presently in the top 300 with 18 trades left.
.

 

[Juddy88]

Been flat out and haven't had time to look at SC this week. Work tomorrow too, so I'm in need of advice!

Newnes, Gov, Yeo, Hibberd, Saad, Oxley (Kmac, Lever)

Fyfe, Pendles, Treloar, Beams, Rocky, Parker, CEY, Cripps (Dmack, Heeney, Krak)

Mummy, Goldy

Gray, Martin, Swan, Goddard, Tarrant, Lonie (Salem, Clark)

Was set on Oxley/Krak ---> Rookie and Salem/Oxley ---> Prem
Currently have 13 rd 12 starters :/

Now not so sure. Started with rocky, traded him out, then in LAST week. Can't hold on to him really, so what are my options I'm terms of rookies? I know there's Hamling, and that north mid rookie. Anymore? Any forward/mid rookies?

Thinking Krak ---> Rookie
Rocky -->> Hodge/Lewis

Any thoughts? Cheers

 

[rocker_oz33]

Been flat out and haven't had time to look at SC this week. Work tomorrow too, so I'm in need of advice!

Newnes, Gov, Yeo, Hibberd, Saad, Oxley (Kmac, Lever)

Fyfe, Pendles, Treloar, Beams, Rocky, Parker, CEY, Cripps (Dmack, Heeney, Krak)

Mummy, Goldy

Gray, Martin, Swan, Goddard, Tarrant, Lonie (Salem, Clark)

Was set on Oxley/Krak ---> Rookie and Salem/Oxley ---> Prem
Currently have 13 rd 12 starters :/

Now not so sure. Started with rocky, traded him out, then in LAST week. Can't hold on to him really, so what are my options I'm terms of rookies? I know there's Hamling, and that north mid rookie. Anymore? Any forward/mid rookies?

Thinking Krak ---> Rookie
Rocky -->> Hodge/Lewis

Any thoughts? Cheers

Lewis has a shoulder issue unsure if he'll play prob best to wait on lateouts if you can.

There bugger all rookies.
Amon port 141k played 3.
Boston suns 129k played 1.
Dawson brissy 117 on the bubble.
Dumont north dude 150k played 3.
Hamling dogs 123k played 1.
Glenn suns not named on the bubble tho.

 

[ike2112]

Lewis has a shoulder issue unsure if he'll play prob best to wait on lateouts if you can.

There bugger all rookies.
Amon port 141k played 3.
Boston suns 129k played 1.
Dawson brissy 117 on the bubble.
Dumont north dude 150k played 3.
Hamling dogs 123k played 1.
Glenn suns not named on the bubble tho.

I'm keeping an eye on Menadue too - one Tiger injury and he might suddenly jump to scoring 70s, he seems handy.

 

[Juddy88]

Rocky has stuffed me. Shows you can't even barely plan one week in advance for trades. Was going to hold off on upgrading to him too, for another week, but thought I'd lose to much ground if he gunned it and I had a rookie (Miller) in his place.

Basically next 3 weeks I'll need to spend getting rd 12 rookies and injured players out.

Might have to take the risk on Amon I guess. Held Salem and Heeney this long might as well keep them. Hopefully Salem is back for rd 12...

 

[toxic]

Sorry to do an Asho but I'm desperate for some opinions
Thanks

Clark to Wallis via krakhore
Rockliff to Wines. If cash allows..

Do the numbers as trades cannot be reversed

Ps...good strong side