- Jul 21, 2008
- 12,118
- 10,583
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Bombers,Jazz,49'ers,Rafa
I'll be looking at a double downgrade. Most likely Pickett -> Lloyd and Balic -> Greenwood
Round 10 Trades
- Thread starter SELFCONFESDAFLNERD
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
toxic
Premium Gold
Rookie watch.... Willie Rioli had limited game time for East Perth Reserves in his return from a bad hamstring injury yesterday... had 16 touches, 6 marks and 4 goals. Should be in the Eagles team in no time!!
Crafty Pig
Team Captain
Otten> Ablett via Hibberd is a lock. Will wait and see if there's a second trade worth doing.
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
In the offchance I can afford SPS to Lloyd/Greenwood and Hayward to Wingard, then that. Otherwise it'll have to be Barrett to Wingard, which would at least give me some leftover cash for next week.
PepeSilvia
Norm Smith Medallist
Who knows.
Shaw, Greene, Fyfe and Crouch (to a lesser extent) are my only disappointing non-rookies at the moment, but I can't really see myself trading any of them this week.
Rooks are:
Newman: Keeper.
Stewart - 57 on Friday night means he should have a little more money to make.
Hibberd - Eminently tradeable, but DPP link has been helpful.
Barrett - More money to make.
Myers - Obviously not.
SPP - Nearly cooked in terms of cash generation, but will be useful coverage across the bye rounds.
Bowes - Sitting with a BE of 21, so maybe a couple more games of cash generation. Also could be useful across the byes, but his job security clearly isn't as good as SPP's.
Balic - A bit torn on Balic at this stage. 'Out indefinitely' obviously a worry, but the (very unfortunate) given scenario means he might not actually be gone for that long. With a BE of 2 and cash generation being crucial at this stage, maybe it's worth holding him?
D. Cameron - No point trading.
McInnes - Obviously not.
Parsons - With his BE to drop considerably, he still has money to make.
In conclusion, I have absolutely no idea. Maybe nothing this week?
Shaw, Greene, Fyfe and Crouch (to a lesser extent) are my only disappointing non-rookies at the moment, but I can't really see myself trading any of them this week.
Rooks are:
Newman: Keeper.
Stewart - 57 on Friday night means he should have a little more money to make.
Hibberd - Eminently tradeable, but DPP link has been helpful.
Barrett - More money to make.
Myers - Obviously not.
SPP - Nearly cooked in terms of cash generation, but will be useful coverage across the bye rounds.
Bowes - Sitting with a BE of 21, so maybe a couple more games of cash generation. Also could be useful across the byes, but his job security clearly isn't as good as SPP's.
Balic - A bit torn on Balic at this stage. 'Out indefinitely' obviously a worry, but the (very unfortunate) given scenario means he might not actually be gone for that long. With a BE of 2 and cash generation being crucial at this stage, maybe it's worth holding him?
D. Cameron - No point trading.
McInnes - Obviously not.
Parsons - With his BE to drop considerably, he still has money to make.
In conclusion, I have absolutely no idea. Maybe nothing this week?
Last edited:
Bobby Sands
Premiership Player
- Sep 12, 2013
- 3,253
- 8,349
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Too early to trade Zac Jones?
Ripe for trade? Keeper?
Thoughts..?
Ripe for trade? Keeper?
Thoughts..?
- Sep 6, 2015
- 28,197
- 23,338
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Pelicans, Perf Wildcats
He's cooked, upgrade time.
At this stage I'll go Hampton -> Perryman and Otten -> Pittard or Harbrow
there aren't too many defs better than him that are averaging 100+
Port & Gold Coast have had their bye making Pittard and Harbrow more attractive but i'm not convinced that's much of an upgrade
he's probably a hold for me because it would make more sense to upgrade McGrath first
Cripps Kru
Team Captain
- May 8, 2017
- 305
- 514
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Banned
- #11
Could be a D6-7 keeper, but I'm upgrading him to a Mid Premo this week before he leaks any more cash and because I've got too many Rd11 bye players already.
Cripps Kru
Team Captain
- May 8, 2017
- 305
- 514
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Banned
- #12
Balic > Greenwood
Zak Jones > Tom Mitchell
Completes my starting midfield
T Mitchell, Rocky*, Z Merrett, M Murphy, GAJ, Danger, Oliver, Pendles (SPP, Myers, Fisher)
Zak Jones > Tom Mitchell
Completes my starting midfield
T Mitchell, Rocky*, Z Merrett, M Murphy, GAJ, Danger, Oliver, Pendles (SPP, Myers, Fisher)
Last edited:
Probably be pulling the trigger for GAJ after r10, so this week is all about banking some rookie cash to get there. If Rocky comes back during the bye that should my midfield done and dusted (not taking any injuries into account obviously). It's hard because GAJ has shoulders like crepe paper, but he's so quality and has a big ceiling
I can honestly right now see Newman as my D6 well into the season, guys scoring like a hero
I'm probably going to bank Ottens cash and leave WHE on the forward line for another week.
Options I'm sort of/maybe considering:
Heeny: Wouldn't mind seen his price drop first, don't have enough faith in him just yet
Hanners: Strung together 4 (counting this round) 100+ scores and has been improving every round. Probably my closest alternative to GAJ (seeing as he's 80k cheaper)
Mitch Duncan: For his price, this guy has had one average game this year. Now we know he has a pretty high ceiling after this round. I have trust issues, like I had with Yeo, but I think he's hard to go past. Not a bad price for his output either.
Zorko: Solid, but with Rocky back in a few weeks and hopefully once against pigging out his output might be down like a few rounds ago. Still an ok price, and an easy BE
Pendles: Too up and down for me atm but has gone large twice in 4 rounds (140+). Good price, and only 11% ownership. Mebs
Jobe Watson: Honestly way too up and down, and rested too much during the year but he's pretty interesting. Really cheap for his last 3 weeks output, had 6 games @ 100+. At 465K he's probably close to the best value for money if he can stay on the park of all the experienced mids atm. Yeahhhh nah
Brodie Grundy: I thought he'd have well and truly bottomed out by now and planned to bring him in this week, but he keeps getting it done. He'll be my Sandi replacement at some stage...when ever that is
In short, * knows really. I'll Relton on Friday anyway.....
I can honestly right now see Newman as my D6 well into the season, guys scoring like a hero
I'm probably going to bank Ottens cash and leave WHE on the forward line for another week.
Options I'm sort of/maybe considering:
Heeny: Wouldn't mind seen his price drop first, don't have enough faith in him just yet
Hanners: Strung together 4 (counting this round) 100+ scores and has been improving every round. Probably my closest alternative to GAJ (seeing as he's 80k cheaper)
Mitch Duncan: For his price, this guy has had one average game this year. Now we know he has a pretty high ceiling after this round. I have trust issues, like I had with Yeo, but I think he's hard to go past. Not a bad price for his output either.
Zorko: Solid, but with Rocky back in a few weeks and hopefully once against pigging out his output might be down like a few rounds ago. Still an ok price, and an easy BE
Pendles: Too up and down for me atm but has gone large twice in 4 rounds (140+). Good price, and only 11% ownership. Mebs
Jobe Watson: Honestly way too up and down, and rested too much during the year but he's pretty interesting. Really cheap for his last 3 weeks output, had 6 games @ 100+. At 465K he's probably close to the best value for money if he can stay on the park of all the experienced mids atm. Yeahhhh nah
Brodie Grundy: I thought he'd have well and truly bottomed out by now and planned to bring him in this week, but he keeps getting it done. He'll be my Sandi replacement at some stage...when ever that is
In short, * knows really. I'll Relton on Friday anyway.....
- Sep 24, 2010
- 7,310
- 8,057
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Phili Eagles + Sixers
Might have to look at dumping some of my non playing rookies in preparation for the bye rounds. I've got Smith still who don't be back and then Balic who we don't know when he will return.
Scharenberg will probably come in if named.
Scharenberg will probably come in if named.
Think just the one trade for me this week.
Balic -----> Greenwood.
Still don't have enough cash with that trade to do anything else, none of my rookies have maxed out enough.
Need to dish off non playing rooks for bye round prep. Pickett will probs go next week too.
Balic -----> Greenwood.
Still don't have enough cash with that trade to do anything else, none of my rookies have maxed out enough.
Need to dish off non playing rooks for bye round prep. Pickett will probs go next week too.
- Jun 27, 2013
- 46,992
- 43,989
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspur, SSC Napoli, ESH
If McInnes is named then I'm getting him in
Otherwise dunno what to do, depends on team selection and breakevens
Might even hold the fort, a lot of good scores this week
The easy, preferred option is Williamson to McInnes and Sandi to Grundy as I have 4 R11 defenders, so getting in a R12er in McInnes helps bye planning.
Williamson may have a lowish breakeven this week though which I'll need to weigh up, but he really should've went on with it tonight, he regularly scores 45-50 til half time and only gets a score between 67-73, really should've scored an 80 by now.
I'm sick of these 77-90 scores from Sandi too, he just doesn't have it in him to ton up anymore, Grundy does.
Bolton and Greenwood are likely ins next week, probably go 2 down 1 up.
Otherwise dunno what to do, depends on team selection and breakevens
Might even hold the fort, a lot of good scores this week
The easy, preferred option is Williamson to McInnes and Sandi to Grundy as I have 4 R11 defenders, so getting in a R12er in McInnes helps bye planning.
Williamson may have a lowish breakeven this week though which I'll need to weigh up, but he really should've went on with it tonight, he regularly scores 45-50 til half time and only gets a score between 67-73, really should've scored an 80 by now.
I'm sick of these 77-90 scores from Sandi too, he just doesn't have it in him to ton up anymore, Grundy does.
Bolton and Greenwood are likely ins next week, probably go 2 down 1 up.
Maybe Barrett >>> Greenwood. But he might have more cash to make so maybe Balic>>>Greenwood. Anything to get parsons off my field.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
I didn't see the free game did Walters play midfield? If he stays there he's very underpriced and a POD. Obvious risk I know.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
- Sep 6, 2015
- 28,197
- 23,338
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Pelicans, Perf Wildcats
If McInnes is named then I'm getting him in
Otherwise dunno what to do, depends on team selection and breakevens
Might even hold the fort, a lot of good scores this week
What about O'Connor? Basement priced to just sit at D8
- Jun 27, 2013
- 46,992
- 43,989
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspur, SSC Napoli, ESH
Yeah forgot about him
Maybe, dunno how his JS is though, scored better this week but wouldn't want to field him, only R11 and 13
Would free more cash up but, but would look at upgrading Stewart on his bye if I did it
- Sep 24, 2010
- 7,310
- 8,057
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Phili Eagles + Sixers
Just looking at the upgrades I have left to do. I'm not that far off with 17 trades left.
2 in defence and I already have 2 good stepping stones in McGrath and Newman. Newman could potentially be a keeper as well.
Then one in my midfield which I will use Barrett and possibly Myers eventually.
So forgetting about Newman right now. I will be hoping to go something along the lines of:
One downgrade then Mcgrath->Lloyd
2 downgrades then Barrett->Zerrett
That leaves me with 12 trades. If everything is going ok then I could then look at luxury trades like Fyfe->Rocky or bringing in another forward to move Nank to R3/F7.
Hopefully have a finished team by the time the byes are finished.
2 in defence and I already have 2 good stepping stones in McGrath and Newman. Newman could potentially be a keeper as well.
Then one in my midfield which I will use Barrett and possibly Myers eventually.
So forgetting about Newman right now. I will be hoping to go something along the lines of:
One downgrade then Mcgrath->Lloyd
2 downgrades then Barrett->Zerrett
That leaves me with 12 trades. If everything is going ok then I could then look at luxury trades like Fyfe->Rocky or bringing in another forward to move Nank to R3/F7.
Hopefully have a finished team by the time the byes are finished.
- Sep 5, 2013
- 6,476
- 10,961
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Western Bulldogs
Is McInnes JS any better though? Plenty of WCE talls on their way back....
- Mar 20, 2007
- 28,248
- 24,763
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Might get rid of the Crows duo Hampton and Otten
Was keen to upgrade one of Barrett or SPP, but Barrett still has cash generation in him (15k this week, and another 15k next supposedly) and SPP could be useful during bye rounds
Might come down to Tuohy or Pittard
Was keen to upgrade one of Barrett or SPP, but Barrett still has cash generation in him (15k this week, and another 15k next supposedly) and SPP could be useful during bye rounds
Might come down to Tuohy or Pittard
Falchoon
Brownlow Medallist
- Feb 15, 2002
- 29,546
- 10,714
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Bluestar Airlines, Anacott Steel
At this stage I don't have enough starters for round 11. Balic/Pickett/Hannan/Eddy/Spencer/Hibberd (handy DPP) and Marchbank all under the gun.
$614 on hand, so I can shop at the premium end, looking for a plus 2 premium deal.
1st trade is Probs Balic to Aaron Hall -$331k
Hannan's decent score this week only got +$8k, so no point in waiting, he can go for Wingard -$220k
That means the next week with the 3 trade rule I can finally bank Spencer in to Strandica for +$127k with Marchbank in to Pittard -$120k and Greenwood in for Pickett.
Then hopefully the next week Otten for GC Lynch??
$614 on hand, so I can shop at the premium end, looking for a plus 2 premium deal.
1st trade is Probs Balic to Aaron Hall -$331k
Hannan's decent score this week only got +$8k, so no point in waiting, he can go for Wingard -$220k
That means the next week with the 3 trade rule I can finally bank Spencer in to Strandica for +$127k with Marchbank in to Pittard -$120k and Greenwood in for Pickett.
Then hopefully the next week Otten for GC Lynch??
Agent93
NinetyThree
- Sep 10, 2010
- 28,939
- 42,097
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Toronto Maple Leafs
Think I'm doing a single, Jones or Marchbank to Pittard. Haven't checked yet but I don't think I have any rookies that have topped out and already have Lloyd. Don't think there are any other must haves.
- Status
