Round 10 trades

[Andrew Birch]

Who to trade out of Starcevich v Budarick -> Stewart ?

I would assume you have a bunch of M/Fs in your forward line that you can conveniently swing with Buda, so I would say trade out Starce

 

[Red Syrah]

You have 3 forwards in your midfield and 4 in your forward line who are all arguably keepers. You have just 4 pure mid keepers. Looking at that I'd definitely suggest going with option 2

Thanks. I kept on going for value picks and ended up with a bunch of fwds! And of course wingard and Butler (leading fwds at the time) have been s**t since I brought them in... And simpkin and smith pretty bad too....

 

[SC fish]

Righto 2 trades left 100k in piggy bank.

Unsure which rookie to grab.ANYone got some input.

Would like sturt back soon.

View attachment 927228

Draper

 

[Red Syrah]

Ouch.

Noble pulled out a bluemoon..

And bc of lock outs I couldnt wait to find out if he was in - I would have kept him if I'd known. Pretty much sums up this season!

 

[rocker_oz33]

Draper

Won't give the cash to get Stewart.

Only if a DPP ruck.

 

[SC fish]

Won't give the cash to get Stewart.

Only if a DPP ruck.

Ah yeah thought your R3 had DPP so you could trade OUT Sturt or Rankine for Draper

 

[rocker_oz33]

Ah yeah thought your R3 had DPP so you could trade OUT Sturt or Rankine for Draper

I wish .
That would be gold.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Aarts, Rankine or Simpson: Which to trade out?
Fell $900 short of my preferred tradeout, would have to go one of them.

On paper Rankine's BE says trade him out, but he's also the most likely to give a high looped score at stages.

Simpson if dropped tonight.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Simpson if dropped tonight.

At Least one change Chook out after he got knocked out.
Selwood probably comes in.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Am I crazy looking at Ballenden over Skinner?

 

[Ollie1981]

Suggestions Please

I don't know weather to just hold Simpkin and hope he comes good. Devon Smith is the other one that's doing nothing.
My Thoughts
Option1
Rankine > Skinner
Simpkin > Duncan
Conroy > Draper leaved $82,400

Option 2
Rankine > Skinner
Devon > T Stewart (Via Simpkin to forward and Stark to Mid)
Conroy > Draper

Or if you can come up with a better trade.

 

[UltimateStrategist]

Buda Rankine and Brander to Draper Skinner and Duncan OR

Rankine Simpson and Brander to Draper Skinner and Duncan if Simpson gets dropped

 

[Changa10]

Brander, Hill and Rankine for Duncan and two rookies.

Hmmm, can do the below. Thoughts?

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hmmm, can do the below. Thoughts?

View attachment 927306

Do you SC on a Commodore 64 .

 

[Changa10]

Do you SC on a Commodore 64 .

Nah, excel. Don't want to 'accidentally' lock in trades when playing around.....

 

[Sherman41]

All this talk about Gawn etc reminds me of the pre season talk and reasons not to get him.

Bloke is a super premo averaging 145.

All hail king Max. Set and forget.

 

[vast]

Am I crazy looking at Ballenden over Skinner?

Its almost impossible to know. I just hope close in named so I dont have to pick one of them.

 

[Walshy_The_Goat]

Thinking of doing something crazy and grabbing Witherden as long term DEF coverage for some much needed depth in DEF, and a potential stepping stone to Haynes/Lloyd down the track.

Having to play Starc and Williamson week after week is hurting me massively. And Witherden provides coverage across the first 3 byes and longer term D7 coverage once I nab Haynes/Lloyd as my final defensive upgrade (if I don't use him as a stepping stone). Allows me to use Williamson as DEF depth if needed across the byes when guys could be rested also.

Thinking of going:

Taylor > Witherden (Brander to FWDs, Budarick on field FWDs)
Rankine > Skinner
Green > Stewart (Starc into MIDs bench, can loop in his score if need be after tonight with Cripps)

Means I have to play Budarick and Skinner up forward.

Thoughts?

FROM THIS:



TO THIS:

 

[Ingy]

All this talk about Gawn etc reminds me of the pre season talk and reasons not to get him.

Bloke is a super premo averaging 145.

All hail king Max. Set and forget.

And then he underperformed Round 1 and then the whole thing got shut down and he had two months to heal.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Its almost impossible to know. I just hope close in named so I dont have to pick one of them.

If no bye I might look at what's up Watson.

 

[vast]

If no bye I might look at what's up Watson.

If Hamill cant beat his breakeven again this week. I might trade him to Rookie Jesus next week.

 

[vanders]

Hmmm, can do the below. Thoughts?

View attachment 927306

If you can get Watson in DEF hes a better option than Close or Bell imo. Same price as Bell too. Has the bye this week but has better JS than the other two.

 

[rocker_oz33]

If you can get Watson in DEF hes a better option than Close or Bell imo. Same price as Bell too. Has the bye this week but has better JS than the other two.

Watson came for Hill.
Hill likely to return after the bye.

Wookies JS no such thing

 

[freddy mercury]

Looks like every campaigner is grabbing Stewart.


I'm one of ya.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Looks like every campaigner is grabbing Stewart.


I'm one of ya.

Toot toot.