Trades Round 10 trades

[Thuggee_Cult]

Are you trading out Martin instead of Cogs?

Yep, I’m hanging onto Cogs as I want to go ‘full premo’ first

I’ve also got Butters and Rowell to think of, I just want rookies off the field asap

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Wait wut is the issue with Ridley?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Wait wut is the issue with Ridley?

Covid

 

[pieman123]

Wait wut is the issue with Ridley?

Pea heart

 

[Goats]

Yep, I’m hanging onto Cogs as I want to go ‘full premo’ first

I’ve also got Butters and Rowell to think of, I just want rookies off the field asap

Considering the same after having Cogs in my sites all week. Not sure where I’ll land but I’m feeling more strongly that holding Cogs over Martin is the smart move - hard to set the emotion aside sometimes.

 

[Ingy]

Three things deciding my trades this week.

1- improving team balance for the byes
2- getting Clark
3- getting rid of cogs

Owens > Clark
Coniglio > Brodie

Owens is back on the bench for St Kilda so could play soon, but won't be playing in the all-important R12. Being a chance to play soon also makes him an unreliable captain/vice captain loop, so not much point keeping him.

Clark seems clearly the best of the rookies floating around at the moment and is too good to miss. Plays round 12. It's a shame he doesn't play round 13 as well, but still seems a must have.

Coniglio has been pretty terrible and yet he's in so many teams that not having him could make him the perfect anti-pod. Doesn't play in round 12 and has been crap so has to go.

Brodie may seem sideways but Cogs has 3 scores this year worse than Brodies worst, which is a passable 75, is averaging under 90 and scored 100+ only twice while Brodie is averaging over 100 and has scored 100+ five times. Cogs also misses round 12 while Brodie plays in both rounds 12 and 13. Brodie may end up being a top 8 forward while Cogs won't unless the new coach uses him very differently. It's frustrating paying almost twice as much for Brodie as those who started with him did but that shouldn't stop me taking the best current option.

Exactly how I feel about paying 600k for Witts - but I'm doing it

 

[TheRednWhite]

I've copped Weakfield being a spud long enough. I'm gonna treat myself this week and trade him out

Steele -> Brayshaw
Whitspud -> Zorko
Bowey -> Doch

change of plans, rd 12 is horrible for me...will pass on Doch and get Crisp (if not a late out). Pendles the back up choice

 

[Test Tickle]

Pea heart

small chol

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Trade assist might be onto something for once.....

 

[GamerKnight]

Hold on to dacios and martin. Or upgrade. That is the question this week

 

[Lord De Goey]

Pretty stumped on what to do this week. Trading Hewett out two weeks ago is looking like a mistake as well.

So far i was thinking these trades:
Steele -> Clark
Whitfield -> Hewett
NOD -> 650k for a defender and unfortunately cant get a mid

Do i just pay up and get Sicily?

I could field SDK and trade Martin over NOD allowing me to get any mid instead of sicily

 

[THECHIEFTON]

Trade assist might be onto something for once.....

View attachment 1404589

Mine told me to trade Cogs>Hamilton lol.

 

[Lord De Goey]

Pretty stumped on what to do this week. Trading Hewett out two weeks ago is looking like a mistake as well.

So far i was thinking these trades:
Steele -> Clark
Whitfield -> Hewett
NOD -> 650k for a defender and unfortunately cant get a mid

Do i just pay up and get Sicily?

I could field SDK and trade Martin over NOD allowing me to get any mid instead of sicily

Now i'm thinking i'll just do this for tonight. Steele to Clark and Whitfield to Hewett. It allows me to see what Durdin scores as E and same as SDK before i decide if i go down the sicily or premo mid route.

 

[King Max]

These are the 4 options I'm thinking about

View attachment 1404491
View attachment 1404492
View attachment 1404493
View attachment 1404494

Option 4. Get a warchest for during the byes or after them.

 

[Ollie1981]

Hi Legends,
What are your thoughts on the following trades? Advice Please

Option 1
Steele > Laird
Stephens > Clark

Option 2
Steele > Laird
MacDonald > Clark

Option 3
Steele > Laird
Stephens > Clark
Dixon > Khamis (Swing McCartin Forward)

Option 4
Steele > Laird
MacDonald > Clark
Dixon > Khamis (Swing McCartin Forward)

Or can you Legends see a better option??

 

[Scythe94]

Hi Legends,
What are your thoughts on the following trades? Advice Please

Option 1
Steele > Laird
Stephens > Clark

Option 2
Steele > Laird
MacDonald > Clark

Option 3
Steele > Laird
Stephens > Clark
Dixon > Khamis (Swing McCartin Forward)

Option 4
Steele > Laird
MacDonald > Clark
Dixon > Khamis (Swing McCartin Forward)

Or can you Legends see a better option??

View attachment 1404593

I personally wouldn't use a boost if you're not upgrading, especially for Khamis (can just wait for Cleary next week potentially).

In your situation, I'd go Dixon -> Clark, Steele -> Brayshaw (or similar), then you should have enough cash to make Stephens into a premo mid/forward like Parker/Libba. You'd maybe have enough cash to do Dusty/Trac instead too.

I know Brayshaw isn't an uber premo, but he's not far off. This way you get both of Hamilton/Rioli off your field.

FWIW, I replaced Steele with Trac, went SDK to Khamis and Rowell to Oliver. Only did Khamis as I went a week early on Clark.

 

[Spanish Sahara]

I personally wouldn't use a boost if you're not upgrading, especially for Khamis (can just wait for Cleary next week potentially).

In your situation, I'd go Dixon -> Clark, Steele -> Brayshaw (or similar), then you should have enough cash to make Stephens into a premo mid/forward like Parker/Libba.

I know Brayshaw isn't an uber premo, but he's not far off. This way you get both of Hamilton/Rioli off your field.

Yeah I like this option too.

 

[Rioli2Rioli]

Wait for Will Gould

Expected debut 2025

 

[Whiskers]

View attachment 1404602

Pretty stumped on what to do this week. Trading Hewett out two weeks ago is looking like a mistake as well.

So far i was thinking these trades:
Steele -> Clark
Whitfield -> Hewett
NOD -> 650k for a defender and unfortunately cant get a mid

Do i just pay up and get Sicily?

I could field SDK and trade Martin over NOD allowing me to get any mid instead of sicily

Yes pay up.

Does anyone think or know if Jesse Motlop will likely be a regular this season?

 

[ImissFrosty]

lads, bit of last minute help please.

team:




Considering: Bowey, Steele, Macdonald to Clark, Hewett, Heeney/Dawson

or Bowey, Steele, Durdin to Clark, Hewett, Libba.

or i can use Daicos instead of Durdin. Feel like i really need a loop with Cripps, Carroll and even TDK/Durdin needing loops.

idk this week is so tough

 

[kananooks]

i think trading out cogs for the podness of not having him and trading him to a sp like laird who is still kinda podish counts as a double pod and thats a double thumbs up from me.

either cogs or martin and at this stage by the time the byes come around cogs will be 50k less than martin

 

[kananooks]

lads, bit of last minute help please.

team:

View attachment 1404619


Considering: Bowey, Steele, Macdonald to Clark, Hewett, Heeney/Dawson

or Bowey, Steele, Durdin to Clark, Hewett, Libba.

or i can use Daicos instead of Durdin. Feel like i really need a loop with Cripps, Carroll and even TDK/Durdin needing loops.

idk this week is so tough

option 2.

hewett seems to be a must have. and libba is an amazing pod where most people are scared to add in another dogs player outside of bont or baz.

wouldn't be bringing in burnman this late in the season.

 

[CotchyPls]

13 trades left, 0 boost and i still haven't scored more than my rd1

 

[ImissFrosty]

option 2.

hewett seems to be a must have. and libba is an amazing pod where most people are scared to add in another dogs player outside of bont or baz.

wouldn't be bringing in burnman this late in the season.

yeah leaning towards that, need a loop and Durdin may only score 30 tonight and make another 20k or something. Libba a great pod and will average more than Parker with a lower BE so can get Parker later, can't with Libba.

 

[Ollie1981]

I personally wouldn't use a boost if you're not upgrading, especially for Khamis (can just wait for Cleary next week potentially).

In your situation, I'd go Dixon -> Clark, Steele -> Brayshaw (or similar), then you should have enough cash to make Stephens into a premo mid/forward like Parker/Libba. You'd maybe have enough cash to do Dusty/Trac instead too.

I know Brayshaw isn't an uber premo, but he's not far off. This way you get both of Hamilton/Rioli off your field.

FWIW, I replaced Steele with Trac, went SDK to Khamis and Rowell to Oliver. Only did Khamis as I went a week early on Clark.

Thank you for the advice.
I ended up going:
Steele -> Brayshaw
Dixon -> Parker
Macdonald -> Clark (only $1,900 in the shed)