Round 12 Discussion

[doona]

So what appears to be par this week? Judging on the scores shown so far I would think you would want 2000 to hold ground.

2K is easily par this week. At the top end of the rankings though, It could potentially be higher like 2050+

 

[Bandicoot]

I need Treloar and Scharenberg to total less than 197. Pretty much line ball at this stage.

 

[melanChronic]

Treloar being robbed of tackles whilst Pendlebury gets handed them for touching someone.

 

[happy_eagle]

Had hoped that Adams score would have kicked into the best 18 by now (>48) but not to be.
Grundy going along nicely

 

[PepeSilvia]

1971 with the rest of Grundy and Pendlebury to come. Another 100 or so points in the second half and that's looking like a pretty reasonable score.

 

[Bandicoot]

Treloar being robbed of tackles whilst Pendlebury gets handed them for touching someone.

I noticed on Friday the huge tackle by wingard was ignored because the player tackled eventually got a handball away.
It's chook lotto trying to figure out what CD consider as a tackle.

 

[happy_eagle]

I noticed on Friday the huge tackle by wingard was ignored because the player tackled eventually got a handball away.
It's chook lotto trying to figure out what CD consider as a tackle.

I wonder if you are prohibited from participating in any form of Fantasy if you work at CD collecting stats

 

[Danger_zone]

thank eff for Grundy! Might be able to salvage a cash league win!

 

[doona]

I noticed on Friday the huge tackle by wingard was ignored because the player tackled eventually got a handball away.
It's chook lotto trying to figure out what CD consider as a tackle.

If someone gets a disposal out of a tackle, I would not count it. It is not an effective tackle.

However, if you tackle someone to the ground, they can't get the disposal out but it pops out through others hands etc... I would count that.

I actually think that what you posted is not a chook lotto as you described it, but logical.

 

[CJApples87]

If someone gets a disposal out of a tackle, I would not count it. It is not an effective tackle.

However, if you tackle someone to the ground, they can't get the disposal out but it pops out through others hands etc... I would count that.

I actually think that what you posted is not a chook lotto as you described it, but logical.

It needs to be an effective disposal for it not to count. But that just means if a teammate of the playing being tackled touches it first after the disposal then the tackle doesn't count.

As you say, it's actually logical the way they consider tackles.

 

[go you pups]

I noticed on Friday the huge tackle by wingard was ignored because the player tackled eventually got a handball away.
It's chook lotto trying to figure out what CD consider as a tackle.

If someone gets a disposal out of a tackle, I would not count it. It is not an effective tackle.

However, if you tackle someone to the ground, they can't get the disposal out but it pops out through others hands etc... I would count that.

I actually think that what you posted is not a chook lotto as you described it, but logical.

Grundy laid a tackle following up from a centre stoppage that quarter and was given the +4 but the Melbourne player still got his handball away while falling to ground with Grundy.

I think it depends how long the tackle was applied for if they count it or not.

I wonder if you are prohibited from participating in any form of Fantasy if you work at CD collecting stats

I think they can play, but they might be exempt from winning cash/prizes like what Warnie, Roy and Calvin are in AFLF as they are AFL employees now.

CD employees definitely can not bet on AFL games, I asked someone in the know there a couple of years ago.

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

2023 with a quarter to come from Grundy, Treloar, Oliver & Adams

 

[doona]

I think it depends how long the tackle was applied for if they count it or not.

Like CJApples87 said, it could be if it is counted as an effective disposal. But I think there would be logic around it, not just a chook lotto

 

[melanChronic]

If someone gets a disposal out of a tackle, I would not count it. It is not an effective tackle.

However, if you tackle someone to the ground, they can't get the disposal out but it pops out through others hands etc... I would count that.

I actually think that what you posted is not a chook lotto as you described it, but logical.

Nah there's so many grey areas. Like

- Pendlebury jumps in 4th man on, did he actually play any role in keeping the ball in? He got +4.
- Desperate handball comes out of tackle and goes out of bounds, was that an effective disposal? Treloar gets nothing.
- WHE merely holding a guy who gets a 40m kick away, doesn't hit a Melbourne player so he gets +4.

 

[BoltonsBlues]

2231 atm

 

[doona]

Pendlebury jumps in 4th man on, did he actually play any role in keeping the ball in? He got +4.

I watch a lot of rugby league and I would say yes. it is not gray.

Desperate handball comes out of tackle and goes out of bounds, was that an effective disposal? Treloar gets nothing.

Ask champion data, they have what they classify as an effective disposal. A disposal is effective/ineffective regardless of if a tackle is being made. so this is an absolute non-issue. Rather than what is a tackle, you are starting a completely unrelated topic of what is an effective disposal.

 

[Agent93]

Far out, early in the 4th and Taytay still isn't on the field for me (Sloane's 62 is my 5th worse atm). That'll be worth a few dollars in a couple of weeks to the few folks who don't have him yet.

 

[Agent93]

5x 140+ scores int my team this week... nuts. Even with 18 players this will be my 3rd best round score of the year.

 

[CrozaN]

1976....meh

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

2151. Hopefully move up slightly from 49th

 

[go you pups]

2151. Hopefully move up slightly from 49th

I reckon you'll be top 35

 

[CJApples87]

1973 and I thought I had a good round. Wow at some of the other scores.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Atavistic]

2151. Hopefully move up slightly from 49th

Nice team name.

 

[doona]

2048, slightly disappointed but I went well last week, and next week should be my best bye round considering the players in the teams above me. A good first 2 weeks of the byes.

 

[go you pups]

Brodie Grundy you legend making my score somewhat respectable

I'll miss you next week