Autopsy Round 13, 2021: St.Kilda v Adelaide

Remove this Banner Ad

EWarren2017

Debutant
Jun 15, 2021
89
107
AFL Club
St Kilda
Is cricket ok? Footy is a very safe sport. Look at all the girls who play it now. The only real danger for girls that started late is they haven’t learn to protect themselves as good as guys. My daughter played school footy. She was useless but I did not give the danger or lack of a second thought. More dangerous going to a nightspot and popping pills and unfortunately most will do it and as a parent you can’t stop it. I know which one I’d rather they do.
lol
what on earth is this post?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

bird_man

Brownlow Medallist
Jan 14, 2012
27,507
60,441
The River Murray
AFL Club
St Kilda
No way to know that now is there. I think he actually didnt even see O'Meara until the last minute and was going to take a chest mark so he wouldnt have his arms out. Is attempting a chest mark not contesting the ball?

Plowman shouldnt have been suspended and certainly if he was then Mackay should have been also.

Plowman got to the ball, Mackay didnt.

The other bolded bit is interesting... Whether reaosnably or unreasonably, two sentences later "unless: it was reasonable for the player to contest the ball.

Long story short if Plowman "bumped" at the point he did i dont see how you can argue Mackay didnt "bump"

Dont suspend them, suspend them but dont try to claim this system works, just go back to assessing each incident on its own.
Yeah I've gotta disagree with you there.

Plowman still had a few metres to gain on O'Meara before he realised he was no chance of taking a chest mark. He then chose to brave himself rather than try and contest the footy.

Screenshot_20210618-173348_YouTube.jpg


Mckay was still reaching for the footy and was much closer to Clark at the time he chose to brace.

Screenshot_20210614-134628_Google.jpg


Plowman was definitely stiff as it was a split second decision but had the chance to contest the footy rather than just cannon into him.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Diehard Saint

Brownlow Medallist
Jan 17, 2016
12,222
41,169
Melbourne
AFL Club
St Kilda
Every club has a player with a broken jaw and nerve damage?

Ok
Unfortunately, even if MacKay had been found guilty, it wouldn’t have changed the outcome for Hunter.

But it appears to me he’s talking about us being hard done by with rule changes about GF draws, goal post cameras etc etc. all after we were disadvantaged.
 

Remboy

All Australian
Apr 24, 2014
714
2,352
AFL Club
St Kilda
They mentioned something yesterday about if Marshall gets through a big session on Saturday, he should be right to play against Richmond.

But not sure if it's just him training or the entire side.
Thanks. I was thinking about going but don’t want to make the trip and not see anything.
 

Remove this Banner Ad