But you don’t know what was said. What if the person who spoke to someone who I don’t believe to be Caro was told everything that finnis said today? Yep upset they wanted to go but left with our blessing. No story there but what if Caro was only told the first part or chose only to say the first part. Then there is a story. My point is there is no leak if the full story is told because it’s actually no story.
Gotta say I agree.
I think if a bunch of managers sat around having a discussion about the hows, why’s and when’s of Seb leaving happened it would be absolutely no different to any standard resourcing meeting.
Fair enough. I think once the decision was made the club were always going to tell them they had the blessing. They can't make them stay.
Or tell the truth. As you say we won’t know. I will go with the club because if it as bad as Caro made out she would have a bigger go at club. He Main go was at the players for some weird reason.
It’s not unreasonable. I’m pretty sure he’s not heading home for a holiday.
Or as said told the truth. I don’t even bel red I’ve she heard from the saints. A third party is my guess. As I said why didn’t she have a real go at the club if completely true. She was more than happy to have a go at the players. Story has more holes in it than my jocks.
Was she right. Seems she was only partly right and if you add the end of the story there is no story. I will say it again. The bigger story should have been Stkilda but she makes Ross the bigger story. Maybe she wasn’t sure of all the info regarding Stkilda. The Stkilda story would have been so much bigger had it finished with them being disappointed they left. She brushes over that and basically attacks Ross.
I think that is fair enough, AFL players didnt sign up for hubs and having a mate working at a footy club last year was not the holiday for them that many seem to think. We all made a little bit of fun about the "heroic" sacrifice the players made last yeat but for many it would have been very trying and if there is some residual concern from players about that this year i cant blame them.
Plugger - the issue here isn’t Ross and Membrey leaving and the club okaying it.
Membery pushed out. Are we all of a sudden going to be top 4. For some reason you have been against him this year. He has been bloody good. Certainly not the reason for a crap year. And I thought you said Ross has also had a good year. You don’t have to have all stars in a side even to win a flag. Both those players are good enough to play in very good sides especially if you have set role for them.
I suspect that Ross will be Nathan Jones esque by the time were challenging for a flag. Older, fringe best 22 etc.
Firstly we haven’t got a clue to club spoke her. Could be a third party but secondly if they did and told the whole story then it isn’t a worry the club spoke to her. With the whole story it isn’t a story. I think you would be shocked how many club people speak to journalists
Not doubting that at all but that’s timing not ability. Mcqualter and eddy played in 2 grand finals. I think those other 2 have them covered. Just need to find a role for certain players.
It is their right though. Yes you are old fashioned. And if you are talking when they signed up well then they didn’t sign up to hubs. She deserves everything she is getting as long as people aren’t personal. Her views are terrible. Just come out and say they shouldn’t have gone home. You making enough excuses for her to suggest that’s what you think. Fine if that’s the case. It’s just not the way things should be done in 2021.
