Round 13 Trades

[AngryRanga]

Tippa Brown DBJ before Trac or Kerridge imho

So Macpherson to Stewart and Nutnut to Gawn this week, AMT (or Brown) to Phillips and DBJ to Laird next? Wouldn't be able to make a 2nd upgrade without the Dunkley to Trengove move. That leaves Petracca and Kerridge on field in F6 and M8.

I'm not a fan of Rose at all, I'm only willing to pay 150k for Trengove because I'm certain about his JS.

 

[Pedsy]

$1,120,000 to spend on 2 forward premos to replace Tippett and Dahl.

Already have Wells and Dusty.

I'm thinking 2 of Zorko/Gunston/Merrett, or alternatively I could grab one of those 3 and then wait a week to get Deledio.

Can't go too wrong with Zorko and Merrett imo

 

[Obese Arachnid]

You guys are doing ok if you're getting rid of Dmac, I'm keeping him as my mid loopy for the year.

 

[gutsroy]

Don't want to distract from people's pre-lockout dilemmas, just a syllogism I've been mulling (between convincing myself that Stef will outperform Gawny at a bargain basement price because I need him to)

Toby Greene likes feasting on carcasses.
GWS' upcoming fixture is carcass-heavy
Therefore Toby Greene will feast on many carcasses on the run home.

Bit like a Steve Motlop style one for F7/M9.

Would he be worth a punt? Or madness to even consider?

 

[pincrusher]

Don't want to distract from people's pre-lockout dilemmas, just a syllogism I've been mulling (between convincing myself that Stef will outperform Gawny at a bargain basement price because I need him to)

Toby Greene likes feasting on carcasses.
GWS' upcoming fixture is carcass-heavy
Therefore Toby Greene will feast on many carcasses on the run home.

Bit like a Steve Motlop style one for F7/M9.

Would he be worth a punt? Or madness to even consider?

Depends if you are happy to ride the roller coaster. If you are considering him you would want to have loophole options. He's only had two scores between 70 and 100 all year. 5 scores over 100 but 4 scores under 70. Amazingly inconsistent.

 

[Edmund hunt]

I am stuffed as i only have 6 trades left.

 

[Mex13]

Should I trade Hewett or Davis to Jansen, trading Hewett will mean that I cop a zero this week while trading Davis I will have a full team this week. Even though Davis will keep mooing and Hewett will lose money this week. And Jansen Or Stewart?? Already getting in Trengove

 

[Hear Me Crow]

Trades are thin, with only 12 left after this round and a number of upgrades to make in the coming weeks.
So I will be trading IN only one of Trengove or Jansen for BKen.

Which one has the best JS? Trengove or Jansen?

 

[Hear Me Crow]

Should I trade Hewett or Davis to Jansen, trading Hewett will mean that I cop a zero this week while trading Davis I will have a full team this week. Even though Davis will keep mooing and Hewett will lose money this week.

Avoid the zero.
As long as it doesn't prevent you from fielding 18 next week.

 

[Ingy]

Trades are thin, with only 12 left after this round and a number of upgrades to make in the coming weeks.
So I will be trading IN only one of Trengove or Jansen for BKen.

Which one has the best JS? Trengove or Jansen?

I'm pretty sure Trengove's JS is rock-solid.

We are talking top draft pick, ex-captain, chronically injured gun who isn't currently injured. Can't see them making him play twos much at all

 

[gutsroy]

Depends if you are happy to ride the roller coaster. If you are considering him you would want to have loophole options. He's only had two scores between 70 and 100 all year. 5 scores over 100 but 4 scores under 70. Amazingly inconsistent.

Yeah, the enticing part is that GWS' fixture is quite friendly from here on in and he scores well in wins.

 

[pulpdriver]

Alcohol abuse is a bitch.

Sobriety just as bad.

So I've heard.

 

[heatedwire]

I'm more than happy to take the punt on SP Stef as Nic Nat replacement. If needed can do a luxury upgrade towards the end of the season.

 

[toxic]

Should I trade Hewett or Davis to Jansen, trading Hewett will mean that I cop a zero this week while trading Davis I will have a full team this week. Even though Davis will keep mooing and Hewett will lose money this week. And Jansen Or Stewart?? Already getting in Trengove

I was sure Hewett wasnt even selected so not sure how this whole scenario plays out

Avoid the zero.
As long as it doesn't prevent you from fielding 18 next week.

Hewett = a zero anyways and avoiding the zero is really only relevant if aiming for overall.
If aiming for league victory then assess you v your opponent this week and decide from there

 

[srobbo]

Don't want to distract from people's pre-lockout dilemmas, just a syllogism I've been mulling (between convincing myself that Stef will outperform Gawny at a bargain basement price because I need him to)

Toby Greene likes feasting on carcasses.
GWS' upcoming fixture is carcass-heavy
Therefore Toby Greene will feast on many carcasses on the run home.

Bit like a Steve Motlop style one for F7/M9.

Would he be worth a punt? Or madness to even consider?

Not at all. I've bought in Steph this week & will be all over Greene in my final fwd upgrades for the reasons you mentioned.

 

[gutsroy]

I am stuffed as i only have 6 trades left.

But then you might want to hold off on moving Hopper on, no?

 

[Mex13]

I was sure Hewett wasnt even selected so not sure how this whole scenario plays out


Hewett = a zero anyways and avoiding the zero is really only relevant if aiming for overall.
If aiming for league victory then assess you v your opponent this week and decide from there

Hewett is playing

 

[toxic]

Hewett is playing

my bad

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

I'm pretty sure Trengove's JS is rock-solid.

We are talking top draft pick, ex-captain, chronically injured gun who isn't currently injured. Can't see them making him play twos much at all

Agreed , the Dees aren't the most skilful team and they need his ball use

 

[MVallence90]

OK guys current line-up with $427k in the bank and 15 trades left after 2 this week (NicNat/Gawn, Smith/Trengove)

Still have plenty of upgrades to do, would it be worth say culling Hewett or Davis this week for say Jansen to free up more cash or move one on for Phillips next week to create a DPP link. Also have my eye on upgrading Tippa & DBJ next week, Tiger combo of Lids/Rance probably the favoured move or anything else I should consider? Cheers

 

[Mex13]

Stewart or Jansen?

 

[Dez!]

Dahlhaus out of the forward line.

554,300 to spend on a forward, suggestions?

 

[Ingy]

Stewart or Jansen?

Refer to pages 43-44 of this thread

 

[GRUFFY]

Stewart or Jansen?

You know what to do
Stewart, just do it

 

[Tang]

Thoughts on McGovern to rose?

Copping a donut at this stage