Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion Round 14 Changes vs. Brisbane

  • Thread starter Thread starter YelloMit
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Their reasons were that DeBoer was older and more experienced. Pretty shit reasons if you ask me.
We're they? Perhaps reasonable for a club that has never played a GF ever. Our early misses would indicate that experience and composure would've helped.

It didn't. Does that mean our selectors suck? Nope, just means they got one wrong on the day.
 
I'm not putting the grand final loss on Suban, but I don't think he should be in the side at the moment. Honestly, we're going as well as we are this year because of one player. That doesn't win you grand finals. And if we keep playing these older guys, or ones that aren't pulling their weight, simply because we're not losing games, we're just going to make the same mistakes come the end of the season.
Oh gawd. Please don't say that we are only on top because of Fyfe.
 
We're they? Perhaps reasonable for a club that has never played a GF ever. Our early misses would indicate that experience and composure would've helped.

It didn't. Does that mean our selectors suck? Nope, just means they got one wrong on the day.
Yeah totally forgivable... on literally any other day ever!
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Cool. Tell the rest of the boys to take the week off. Why is that Fyfe can roam so free so often I wonder?
I'm not saying we'd be terrible without him. But we wouldn't be first. Our backline's spent most of the year injured, our forward line is barely operating, and sure we have an amazing midfield, even without Fyfe, but you can't carry "guys that cover ground" unless you have a dominant superstar to do their work as well.
 
I'm not saying we'd be terrible without him. But we wouldn't be first. Our backline's spent most of the year injured, our forward line is barely operating, and sure we have an amazing midfield, even without Fyfe, but you can't carry "guys that cover ground" unless you have a dominant superstar to do their work as well.
Sorry but you've drifted From your initial point. I agree with what you're currently saying. But you first said that you can't win with one superstar dragging along oldies. We aren't doing that. Our squad is providing a platform for our class. It currently isn't working perfectly but we are on the right track.
 
Not completly. You think they don't communicate?

Clutching at straws. Your argument is now that because we drafted Fyfe we should never question selection decisions over other players. Complete horseshit. Quit while you are behind.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Clutching at straws. Your argument is now that because we drafted Fyfe we should never question selection decisions over other players. Complete horse shit. Quit while you are behind.
WTF? When did I say you couldn't question selection decisions?! I'm saying we have competent leadership and we shouldn't speak of them as idiots. They get stuff wrong as they are human. Why abuse them on our own board?
 
So you're saying the reason none of our draftees have debuted is because they are all crap?

How did you get that???!

My comment was regarding St Kilda. Ross has debuted plenty in his time at Freo. The reason Weller and Blakely are still waiting (only half a season mind you) is because I don't see who you drop?? Keeping in mind Mzungu can't even crack in.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Don't mind the changes. I still think Duffield is in our best side, and importantly he can kick.

I still scratch my head why Mzungu can't get a game ahead of Suban, Sheridan or De Boer. It's really baffling.
I think Duffield in form is in our best 22, just don't think he is playing well at the moment.

Hopefully he turns it around on Sunday and plays a blinder.
 
Don't mind the changes. I still think Duffield is in our best side, and importantly he can kick.

I still scratch my head why Mzungu can't get a game ahead of Suban, Sheridan or De Boer. It's really baffling.
I'd prefer Gu over the Pig but we are probably missing something. Think Gu is massively overlooked upforward
 
I think Duffield in form is in our best 22, just don't think he is playing well at the moment.

Hopefully he turns it around on Sunday and plays a blinder.

My guess is Duffield is in to inject some experience and help McPharlin (with MJ and Dawson still out ) direct some traffic at the back.

Yeah, he does need to improve his form or he'll go straight out again.
 
Anyone know the average age of our side this weekend? Would have to be pushing the levels we had back in 2008
 
WTF? When did I say you couldn't question selection decisions?! I'm saying we have competent leadership and we shouldn't speak of them as idiots. They get stuff wrong as they are human. Why abuse them on our own board?

Nobody abused them or called them idiots. It was you who argued that anyone who disagrees with them (when really it was actually just your opinion) is an idiot.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom