Round 15 team

[shake_and_bake]

some1 told me james kelly didnt train today and that he might be a chance to be out? can anyone confirm this?

 

[The Casey Cat]

At the risk of opening up the 'horses for courses' can of worms again - and as much as I love Harry - we don't need 3 tall KPP backmen against Freo.

He'll get his turn - and we need him fresh for the run home and the finals.

We don't need 3? Without him we don't really even have two. Harley has been taking smaller to medium sized players these days. I would not be all the confident of him on Tarrant (years ago he was our man for that job as Tarrant murdered Scarlett). As for Rooke on Pav I can't see that happening unless Pavlich goes on the ball. Scarlett will have to take him. I would not have minded Taylor coming in to play on Tarrant but I guess Milburn will have to do the job.

 

[Duskfire]

We don't need 3? Without him we don't really even have two. Harley has been taking smaller to medium sized players these days. I would not be all the confident of him on Tarrant (years ago he was our man for that job as Tarrant murdered Scarlett). As for Rooke on Pav I can't see that happening unless Pavlich goes on the ball. Scarlett will have to take him. I would not have minded Taylor coming in to play on Tarrant but I guess Milburn will have to do the job.

Exactly. Scarlett and Taylor are our only true tall defenders, by that being they excel at playing on tall opponents (that and Egan but well, he isnt avaliable.) Harley and Milburn both seem suited to medium sized defenders. If Freo load up their forward line with talls we will struggle to contain them. With the North game, we smashed them all over the ground except for the forward line who just kicked goals out of nothing. Granted Scarlett was out, but the point remains the same.

Not to mention Scarlett was getting rested last week due to his hamstring injury. what if he needs the same again this week and cant play out the entire game? Just seems logical for taylor to play.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Source: GFC.com

No change to the squad.

B: Tom Harley Matthew Scarlett Andrew Mackie
HB: Darren Milburn Max Rooke Corey Enright
C: James Kelly Cameron Ling Jimmy Bartel
HF: Steve Johnson Cam Mooney David Wojcinski
F: Paul Chapman Tom Lonergan Mathew Stokes
R: Brad Ottens Joel Corey Gary Ablett
Int: Josh Hunt Mark Blake Joel Selwood Travis Varcoe
Eme: Brent Prismall Harry Taylor David Johnson

In my 30 years of being a cat i think that is the best team i could possibly hope for. Obviously egan ......and harry has been impressive but really .....who can you remove from that back half for them?.

They have all been going great guns and i wouldnt change a thing . If thats the grand final team that runs out god help whoever we are playing. I just look at those names and through every line its just ....gun, gun, gun, gun, hard at the ball animal, gun, gun , gun hahaha man its good to be a cat. As big as a priz fan i am there is just no way i can get him in there. Im half hoping we trade him just so he can get a decent run.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Oh cmon!.

There is five guys ahead of aker id be worried about!!.

He's just an old w***er doing handstands