Trades Round 15 Trades

[BLERN]

I'll have one of these convos on field post trades, which is best?

Rocky/Treloar and Marchbank

Fyfe and Newman

Steven and Birchall

Marchbank has maxed for mine. Newman basically the same but with better weekly avg.

I wouldnt be trading either in if you haven't had them. Newman is decent but has earnt his money. Little to gain there.

Still for me #1 is in front even though i dont like any of them

 

[browncow]

At this point I've gone a bit of a cash grab as I literally have $1,000 in the bank after double upgrade last week.

Gone Scooter to Gray making $70,000 and will ride his low B/E for a few weeks hoping he can keep up some decent form.
Then I'm finally moving Sloane on. Can't take his headaches scores anymore so I'm taking a punt on Bontempelli to storm home like last year and he seems quite a nice price at $567,000.

Cue a Sloane 150.

 

[JADED]

Marchbank should return to passable scoring with Lamb out if you need to hold him.

 

[yogibbear]

I'm bringing in Mitch Hibberd 150k D/M.

Rest of the rooks are too suspect and low fantasy scoring relevancy. Hibberd's Job security is probably average to crap, but I'll take it. Better than the others with a chance of actually averaging >50ppg. Hopefully Partington is a late in anyway over Butler or for Cripps, dominates and then secures his spot as best 22 that HE DESERVED TO BE NAMED THIS WEEK YOU SHITTERS. Hopefully Simmo wanted him and rest of MC disagreed or some rubbish and Simmo quietly tells Cripps he has to fake an injury on the day for Parto to walk in as late change. Can't believe Butler, Redden, Masten are all somehow "ahead" of debuting someone that has been knocking it out of the park in the WAFL. ****s sake. If Lecras and Priddis come back next week and Parto still doesn't play.......................

 

[DrZaius]

Who has better JS?

Mountford/Karpany/Witherden ?

Looking for a rook to bring in as M8 for a week or two as I set up my fwd line.

Witherden DPP is looking very juicy but really not sure what his role is.

 

[John Wayne II]

Wtf is up with Eagles selections? Also Pridda with "general soreness"

 

[John Wayne II]

Who has better JS?

Mountford/Karpany/Witherden ?

Looking for a rook to bring in as M8 for a week or two as I set up my fwd line.

Witherden DPP is looking very juicy but really not sure what his role is.

Really don't know about Mountford or Karpany, Witherden for me.

 

[John Wayne II]

Selwood + Barrett -> Gray + Macrae

Didn't want Gray but it's all I can afford.

 

[desTROY]

Wanting a ruck overhaul. stuck with Goldy... and Nank atm. Going to get rid of nank this week, any thoughts on who to go to, Gawn before he's quite at his low point, Martin with Archie or spend the extra and go Kruezer or Grundy.
Beams to Treloar most likely my second trade.

 

[JADED]

Selwood + Barrett -> Gray + Macrae

Didn't want Gray but it's all I can afford.

I feel for you man. Look, if you ever need someone to console you over the coming weeks, this board is here for you mate.

 

[JADED]

Wanting a ruck overhaul. stuck with Goldy... and Nank atm. Going to get rid of nank this week, any thoughts on who to go to, Gawn before he's quite at his low point, Martin with Archie or spend the extra and go Kruezer or Grundy.
Beams to Treloar most likely my second trade.

Nank to Gawn. Nothing wrong with pulling THAT trade a week early as they'll both lose money this week so no real loss/gain.
Your in gets cheaper but your out loses money (Nankervis with a high-ish break even)
I'll jump at same trade next week unless Gawn scores very poorly (unlikely) but if he does it may buy me another week.

I've had Kreuzer since Gawn got injured, that was a score.

 

[John Wayne II]

I feel for you man. Look, if you ever need someone to console you over the coming weeks, this board is here for you mate.

I know it's coming, can't do anything about it. Smh

 

[John Wayne II]

Selwood + Barrett + Cash = 1063000

1) Macrae + Gray + 63k
2) Ablett + Cox + 181k
3) Macrae + Cox + 317k
4) other

Help plz. Option one I field Marchbank, SPP, Greenwood. Any other option I field that and Ainsworth.

 

[forlols]

locking stengle in for 3 goals just a freak who knows where they are

 

[Corby_4]

Marchbank should return to passable scoring with Lamb out if you need to hold him.

This is reassuring.
Need a decent score for just this week.

 

[Eskimo_Fennel]

Selwood + Barrett + Cash = 1063000

1) Macrae + Gray + 63k
2) Ablett + Cox + 181k
3) Macrae + Cox + 317k
4) other

Help plz. Option one I field Marchbank, SPP, Greenwood. Any other option I field that and Ainsworth.

With option 4, it can be a lil' hard to recommend choices without knowing who is in your team. If you don't have a Lloyd/Newnes, you could flick Marchbank instead of Barrett to one (assuming you have around 150k cash if my math isn't completely shot), then use some DPP and turn Scooter into a premo FWD (menegola, yeo, one of the dogs (Macrae as you suggest), heeney, etc.)

Like I said though, without knowing your squad it's difficult to suggest things as helpful as we possibly could. Having said that, of the options above, I would go number one. I know plenty aren't keen on Roberto Gray, but he has a low BE and should be ok this weekend. Even if just for a few weeks, though hopefully the year.

 

[Possum Vomit]

With option 4, it can be a lil' hard to recommend choices without knowing who is in your team. If you don't have a Lloyd/Newnes, you could flick Marchbank instead of Barrett to one (assuming you have around 150k cash if my math isn't completely shot), then use some DPP and turn Scooter into a premo FWD (menegola, yeo, one of the dogs (Macrae as you suggest), heeney, etc.)

Like I said though, without knowing your squad it's difficult to suggest things as helpful as we possibly could. Having said that, of the options above, I would go number one. I know plenty aren't keen on Roberto Gray, but he has a low BE and should be ok this weekend. Even if just for a few weeks, though hopefully the year.

I'm going Gray this week as I need a forward under $488k. I looked at Wallis but I've already got the other two dogs so I'm going Gray - not entirely comfortable but like you said he has a low BE so if he's shit we can just ride it out for a few weeks. Leaves me with only Greenwood F6 and Mountford M8 and $61k for next week.

 

[Corby_4]

Barrett > Macrae
Williamson > Hibberd (rook)
287k left over.

EDIT: Back to Williamson > Brennan Cox
Hibberd's dpp doesn't help me get Jelwood in 2 weeks as planned.
+255k

 

[Cotchy9]

Rocky or Treloar? Not worried about BE's

 

[John Wayne II]

With option 4, it can be a lil' hard to recommend choices without knowing who is in your team. If you don't have a Lloyd/Newnes, you could flick Marchbank instead of Barrett to one (assuming you have around 150k cash if my math isn't completely shot), then use some DPP and turn Scooter into a premo FWD (menegola, yeo, one of the dogs (Macrae as you suggest), heeney, etc.)

Like I said though, without knowing your squad it's difficult to suggest things as helpful as we possibly could. Having said that, of the options above, I would go number one. I know plenty aren't keen on Roberto Gray, but he has a low BE and should be ok this weekend. Even if just for a few weeks, though hopefully the year.

Cheers for the reply, yeah I've got every one of those guys you suggested if that helps haha.

Def:
Adams/Laird/Newnes/Hibberd/Newman/Marchbank - Ryan/Williamson
Mid:
Titch/Zerrett/Danger/Rocky/Lloyd/Treloar/Scooter/SPP - Cousins/Mountford
Ruck:
Grundy/Martin - Rookies
Fwd:
Yeo/Menegola/Dahlhaus/Barrett/Greenwood/Heeney - Ainsworth/JKH

 

[Butterz]

Downgrade to Hibberd and have some spare cash for next week or spend the extra on Withderden and leave no cash for next week?

 

[John Wayne II]

Rocky or Treloar? Not worried about BE's

Treloar

 

[John Wayne II]

Downgrade to Hibberd and have some spare cash for next week or spend the extra on Withderden and leave no cash for next week?

By all accounts Hibberds been good in the 2s so he could get an extended run, Witherden would have better JS though.

 

[John Wayne II]

Do I just pull the trigger on Doch while I have the cash?

 

[BLERN]

Downgrade to Hibberd and have some spare cash for next week or spend the extra on Withderden and leave no cash for next week?

Well last time hibberd played he barely found the ball and got dropped. Only coming in due to injuries and suspensions.

Witherden actually got the ball and used it quite well.

Witherden does feel like the better option. But who really knows how this week will play out.