Round 17 Trades

[Machineman]

I kept 2 trades for injuries, thinking maybe one was enough...now Simpkin, J Martin and Worpel (I know, don't ask, he was my POD from the start) all looking iffy!!! Grrrrr, rookies playing R17 already!

 

[Suma Magic]

I’ve got 1 trade and no cash. Just realised I can trade Draper to Petrevski-Seton and re-open my mid-def link.

 

[Andrew Birch]

I’ve got 1 trade and no cash. Just realised I can trade Draper to Petrevski-Seton and re-open my mid-def link.

Statistically you're just as likely to get 2x40's from Petrapski as you are 2x100's

 

[DT_35]

Got Simpkin and Doch.
think Simpkin will play but at least North play early in the round. I have Rivers D7 so not the worst outcome RE: Doch but o may choose to trade anyway.
4 trades left. The plan was Grundy > Gawn and a downgrade somewhere

 

[Suma Magic]

Statistically you're just as likely to get 2x40's from Petrapski as you are 2x100's

If only Carlton were playing early in rounds 17 and 18.

I think he remains an option for a scenario where heaps of injuries pop up next day or two and the objective is just warm bodies.

 

[Gene Simmons]

Docherty injury cloud really stuffs me up... Especially since my D7/D8 cover is Watson & Gould and to top it off I’ve got McPherson at D6..

my plan was to upgrade McPherson to Daniel... But now I’m thinking, should I just trade Doch to Ryan?

 

[rocker_oz33]

I wish they would rule DOC out now ...I prob get Duggan.
Low on cash so if I wait only Rich and Srimshaw the other options really Or Burnman B.Smith crows variety.
Gerrard.

 

[Gene Simmons]

I wish they would rule DOC out now ...I prob get Duggan.
Low on cash so if I wait only Rich and Srimshaw the other options really Or Burnman B.Smith crows variety.
Gerrard.

frustrating because he isn’t even listed on their injury list as a test...

 

[Gethsemene]

I have:
Whitfield
Petracca
Greenwood
B.Smith
and Simpkin up forward (Coleman and Riccardi on the bench)

Assuming Simpkin plays, who do we think is the best Fwd in the comp for the final two games? Can afford anyone as Draper (xerri swing to R6) + Wicks/McInerney (-102k rookie) + 70k to spend (final 2 trades)

Alternatively, best Fwd under 400k and I keep a trade for emergencies

 

[rocker_oz33]

Dawson might a option.

Duggan b2b tons kind of keen..

frustrating because he isn’t even listed on their injury list as a test...

If a late out alot less options to choose from.

And not on injury report..

 

[SC fish]

Probably Starcevich to Greaves and Draper to Gawn

 

[Mikevk123]

I have jack Marin, Simpkin, Willams and Docherty Lol.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I have:
Whitfield
Petracca
Greenwood
B.Smith
and Simpkin up forward (Coleman and Riccardi on the bench)

Assuming Simpkin plays, who do we think is the best Fwd in the comp for the final two games? Can afford anyone as Draper (xerri swing to R6) + Wicks/McInerney (-102k rookie) + 70k to spend (final 2 trades)

Alternatively, best Fwd under 400k and I keep a trade for emergencies

Blake Arces might a option.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I have jack Marin, Simpkin, Willams and Docherty Lol.

That's rough.

 

[Mikevk123]

That's rough.

Very much so. Which ones should I keep and trade? What do you reckon

 

[Seymour Skinner]

Got Zwill, Docherty, Jack Martin and Riccardi.

Praying that Zwill plays this week so I can use my last 2 trades and not cop a donut...

 

[rocker_oz33]

Very much so. Which ones should I keep and trade? What do you reckon

What sucks the most if they are not ruled out early...blues play Sunday not much to get for Martin and DOC.

If you get rimmed hard and loose Doc and Zillions do you have a emg for one of them ?
If you lose Martin aswell..

 

[Shermy]

Doch to Helmet

cya trade threads

 

[Chaisa]

2 trades left. Have all of Williams, Docherty and Simpkin though....and they all have very aggravating injury clouds.

If all 3 are fit then Wicks -> Greaves (via Rivers DPP) and Rankine -> Ridley (via Dawson DPP). If say Docherty and Simpkin is out I'm tossing up between Ryan and Wingard and Ridley and Walters. Kind of like the other option better but have no idea whether Walters will actually play midfield.

Urgh.

 

[Chaisa]

Though apparently Carlton still expect Docherty to play?

 

[rocker_oz33]

Though apparently Carlton still expect Docherty to play?

Doc not on any injury reports..grade one Strain is like 3 weeks .
Mills missed 2 from he's calf....but who knows everyone is different.

 

[Gene Simmons]

Though apparently Carlton still expect Docherty to play?

Doch has scored over 100 only twice (124, 126) since Round 4 so Doch under an injury cloud doesn’t fill me with confidence... That is why I’m seriously thinking of going Doch -> Ryan...

 

[DrummoSolo]

Knocked out of any league I care about, so time to just rage trade.

Weller > Maynard with the peace of mind of knowing that I'll never pick him again.
Riccardi > Coleman

Final week will be Schroeberg > Brayshaw and Draper > Best Available.

 

[Mikevk123]

What sucks the most if they are not ruled out early...blues play Sunday not much to get for Martin and DOC.

If you get rimmed hard and loose Doc and Zillions do you have a emg for one of them ?
If you lose Martin aswell..

Yep got Greaves and Rivers. Thinking either doch/Willams to Haynes and Martin to Walters.

 

[Chaisa]

Doch has only scored over 100 twice (124, 126) since Round 4 so Doch under an injury cloud doesn’t fill me with confidence... That is why I’m seriously thinking of going Doch -> Ryan...

Yeah I see that - but alas I don't have a lot of cash/cap space and with other injuries we need what we can get!