Round 18 Trades

[toxic]

I traded him out after his last reappearance.. I would wait at least one game to see what he plays like again, but by then you may aswell have gone with another player for this week.. Then again, he could destroy it with a great draw coming up. Big risk though!

Hes a risk. He also got a lot of his points as no1 ruck, which nicholls now owns. I'd be waiting a week

 

[leng jai]

If I didn't have a bagel last week I would have kept Buddy. Dayum. Hopefully he continues the poor form...

 

[yellowandblack21]

Must win league game this week, so making my last mid upgrade.
O'Meara -> Gablett (yes, I know, should have had him from the start, no need to rub it in )
Titichell -> Carter

4 trades left

 

[[ToTTi]]

Need bf's expert help, as I've got a huge fortnight coming up in my league where I am playing the top two teams, and need two wins to guarantee finals action!

Trades: 9
Cash: $657,600

Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Hanley, Terlich, Staker, Vlastuin (Goodes, Thurlow)

Mids: Ablett, Swan, Kennedy, Priddis, O’Meara, Dwyer, T.Mitchell, Viney (Dangerfield, Colquhoun)

Rucks: Cox, Nicholls (Currie, McBean)

Forwards: Martin, Kennedy, Zorko, Franklin, S.Johnson, Macaffer (Bartel, Natanui)

Option 1:
- Viney to Pendles
- Dangerfield to Cotchin / Selwood

I can use Colquhoun (he named on a HBF) to cover the defense hole and relegate T Mitch or Dwyer to the bench

Option 2:
- Viney to Pendles
- Hanley to H Shaw / Ibbotson

Will the difference between Shaw and Colquhoun’s score be greater than the difference of say between Cotch and T Mitch as with option A?

Option 3:
- Viney to Pendles
- Dwyer to Cotchin / Selwood

Means I hang onto Dangerfield and need to play Colquhoun. Also means I lose the DPP link between forward line and midfield. But it does bolster the
Mids..

Help is greatly appreciated.

 

[karaoke]

Need bf's expert help, as I've got a huge fortnight coming up in my league where I am playing the top two teams, and need two wins to guarantee finals action!

Trades: 9
Cash: $657,600

Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Hanley, Terlich, Staker, Vlastuin (Goodes, Thurlow)

Mids: Ablett, Swan, Kennedy, Priddis, O’Meara, Dwyer, T.Mitchell, Viney (Dangerfield, Colquhoun)

Rucks: Cox, Nicholls (Currie, McBean)

Forwards: Martin, Kennedy, Zorko, Franklin, S.Johnson, Macaffer (Bartel, Natanui)

Option 1:
- Viney to Pendles
- Dangerfield to Cotchin / Selwood

I can use Colquhoun (he named on a HBF) to cover the defense hole and relegate T Mitch or Dwyer to the bench

Option 2:
- Viney to Pendles
- Hanley to H Shaw / Ibbotson

Will the difference between Shaw and Colquhoun’s score be greater than the difference of say between Cotch and T Mitch as with option A?

Option 3:
- Viney to Pendles
- Dwyer to Cotchin / Selwood

Means I hang onto Dangerfield and need to play Colquhoun. Also means I lose the DPP link between forward line and midfield. But it does bolster the
Mids..

Help is greatly appreciated.

Goodes > Shaw (Hanley to bench)
Viney > Pendles

then next week;

Thurlow > XRichards
McCaffer > Enright (Staker DPP)

ATM, keep Danger to see what next week brings, if he comes back > trade Dwyer, if not > keep Dwyer (m/f bench) and trade Danger to best mid premo,

Terlich, Vlastuin, JOM, Titch, Nicholls, NicNat(??) would have to be viewed as potential 'luxury' upgrades later if you have luck & no LTI's - you'll find many still playing these or having as bench cover still & into finals,

IMO & FWIW,

 

[toxic]

Need bf's expert help, as I've got a huge fortnight coming up in my league where I am playing the top two teams, and need two wins to guarantee finals action!

Trades: 9
Cash: $657,600

Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Hanley, Terlich, Staker, Vlastuin (Goodes, Thurlow)

Mids: Ablett, Swan, Kennedy, Priddis, O’Meara, Dwyer, T.Mitchell, Viney (Dangerfield, Colquhoun)

Rucks: Cox, Nicholls (Currie, McBean)

Forwards: Martin, Kennedy, Zorko, Franklin, S.Johnson, Macaffer (Bartel, Natanui)

Option 1:
- Viney to Pendles
- Dangerfield to Cotchin / Selwood

I can use Colquhoun (he named on a HBF) to cover the defense hole and relegate T Mitch or Dwyer to the bench

Option 2:
- Viney to Pendles
- Hanley to H Shaw / Ibbotson

Will the difference between Shaw and Colquhoun’s score be greater than the difference of say between Cotch and T Mitch as with option A?

Option 3:
- Viney to Pendles
- Dwyer to Cotchin / Selwood

Means I hang onto Dangerfield and need to play Colquhoun. Also means I lose the DPP link between forward line and midfield. But it does bolster the
Mids..

Help is greatly appreciated.

If immediate points is your main aim I'd go Goodes to Beams (moving the coke kid back to def) and NicNat to Walker
week after Macaffer to XRichards (so Staker can be swapped)
then Dwyer or Omeara to best possible premium mid you want (pick based on draw versus opponent if you are aiming for a week win)

 

[Spider Eater]

Need bf's expert help, as I've got a huge fortnight coming up in my league where I am playing the top two teams, and need two wins to guarantee finals action!

Trades: 9
Cash: $657,600
Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Hanley, Terlich, Staker, Vlastuin (Goodes, Thurlow)
Mids: Ablett, Swan, Kennedy, Priddis, O’Meara, Dwyer, T.Mitchell, Viney (Dangerfield, Colquhoun)
Rucks: Cox, Nicholls (Currie, McBean)
Forwards: Martin, Kennedy, Zorko, Franklin, S.Johnson, Macaffer (Bartel, Natanui)

Help is greatly appreciated.

I'd back Brent Harvey to have a big scoring game this week... he's someone to consider for Nic Nat but not sure if he's the best long term choice with Norths tough fixture.

 

[nofx]

I don't think I'm going to trade anything this week with my remaining 3 trades:

I'm 3k short of trading in Rowe and Tom Mitchell for Pendles and I'm not going to give up my only mid cover (Hrovat) to get him yet. Maybe next week.

That one remaining trade though...to JJK Gunston away or not now that Mitchell and Buddy are back?

 

[karaoke]

Ok gents, what do you think?

4 trades & 406k in bank,

I am thinking of only 1 trade this week, as I would like to have 3 when it comes to SC finals;

Goodes > SJ (via Staker DPP)

Gingy, toxic, Judd_Magic, any others - comments & thoughts appreciated, especially different viewpoints I may not have already considered,

TIA

 

[Tigey]

Finally decided on my trades this week leaving me 7 to go and 150K

D: Goddard, Shaw, Enright, Hartlett, Gibbs, Staker, (Clisby, Webster)
M: Ablett, Swan, Pendlebury, Barlow, Cotchin, Selwood, Ball, Mitchell (S.Thompson, B.Crouch)
R: Maric, Kruzer, Currie, Mcbean
F: Franklin, Cox, Lewis, Martin, SJ, Lee (Bartel, Daniher)

Now, over the next coming weeks I will look to drop Crouch to Atkins then upgrade Thompson to a Premo leaving Mitchell on the bench, then will upgrade Clisby to a premo leaving Staker as cover


Will four trades be enough for finals?

 

[Embleberry]

The deal is 4 trades remaining and $47k coin. I can rely on my bench for cover this week, without making any trades however, I think it's best to ditch Goodes now plus it's a must win game this week, so don't want to gamble on Clisby's score.
Probably look to bring in Enright but that leaves me very very very light on coin :S I've been considering shifting Staker to def, however, that makes my forward emergencies very weak - particularly with Neade there lol
Any thoughts? Why, oh why does SC always turn to shit!! haha

 

[Embleberry]

View attachment 24663

Ok gents, what do you think?

4 trades & 406k in bank,

I am thinking of only 1 trade this week, as I would like to have 3 when it comes to SC finals;

Goodes > SJ (via Staker DPP)

Gingy, toxic, Judd_Magic, any others - comments & thoughts appreciated, especially different viewpoints I may not have already considered,

TIA

I think that works quite well for you actually. Staker can hold D6 until Birch comes back which should be soon (you just have to hope he doesn't spud bad!) By that time it could be your opportunity to side ways Staker too so now you have a prem-like D6/7. Your Forward line cover would be quite strong. You've got a nice team there. A couple more weeks Jobe is back and you can sideways/up TMitch or upgrade one of Bennedy/Saunders with 1 trade left. Looking good

Finally decided on my trades this week leaving me 7 to go and 150K

D: Goddard, Shaw, Enright, Hartlett, Gibbs, Staker, (Clisby, Webster)
M: Ablett, Swan, Pendlebury, Barlow, Cotchin, Selwood, Ball, Mitchell (S.Thompson, B.Crouch)
R: Maric, Kruzer, Currie, Mcbean
F: Franklin, Cox, Lewis, Martin, SJ, Lee (Bartel, Daniher)

Now, over the next coming weeks I will look to drop Crouch to Atkins then upgrade Thompson to a Premo leaving Mitchell on the bench, then will upgrade Clisby to a premo leaving Staker as cover


Will four trades be enough for finals?

4 trades will be plenty IMO. I like your trade ideas, however, I'd look to sideways/up Ball as well. Come finals you want your start mids to all be capable of going bang with the huge scores, if not a reliable 100. Ball on the other hand won't provide you that in SC.

 

[Krujan]

View attachment 24665

The deal is 4 trades remaining and $47k coin. I can rely on my bench for cover this week, without making any trades however, I think it's best to ditch Goodes now plus it's a must win game this week, so don't want to gamble on Clisby's score.
Probably look to bring in Enright but that leaves me very very very light on coin :S I've been considering shifting Staker to def, however, that makes my forward emergencies very weak - particularly with Neade there lol
Any thoughts? Why, oh why does SC always turn to shit!! haha

Very similar Def & Fwd situation as my team.

Goodes > Enright FTW!(I'm also doing this trade only Hanley > Enright) Enright has a very good record against St Kilda and @ the Cattery this week I'm hopeful for a 120+ score

Leave Staker in your forwards. Can loophole Buddy/Staker with Neade doughnut this week.

I'd actually make Nicholls ruck emergency this week. If he spuds up, move Cox to the rucks via Nicnat to the forwards and take Buddy's emergency score if he fires up.

 

[Spider Eater]

View attachment 24663

Ok gents, what do you think?

4 trades & 406k in bank,

I am thinking of only 1 trade this week, as I would like to have 3 when it comes to SC finals;

Goodes > SJ (via Staker DPP)

Gingy, toxic, Judd_Magic, any others - comments & thoughts appreciated, especially different viewpoints I may not have already considered,

TIA

That's a good trade... will still leave you with 250k and 2 trades aswell as Watson, Birchall and Bartell to come back in then you can do what ever you want with Nic nat and maybe upgrade Mitchell in the end.

 

[karaoke]

View attachment 24665

The deal is 4 trades remaining and $47k coin. I can rely on my bench for cover this week, without making any trades however, I think it's best to ditch Goodes now plus it's a must win game this week, so don't want to gamble on Clisby's score.
Probably look to bring in Enright but that leaves me very very very light on coin :S I've been considering shifting Staker to def, however, that makes my forward emergencies very weak - particularly with Neade there lol
Any thoughts? Why, oh why does SC always turn to shit!! haha

Embles,

Not saying it's right option, but you could go Goodes > XRichards (swap with Staker) & raise some $$ with 3 trades to go, (toxic special )

this week play Vlas & Staker as D5 & D6, Buddy at F6, no real Emerg cover though,

Put 'E' on Clisby (Sat game), if he goes well 85+, you could always put Hanley (Sun game) on field for Vlas (Sun game) for emerg loophole,

You would now have some coin to upgrade Clisby, Viney & Neade eventually (provided NicNat, Cox & Danger aren't put out to pasture early!),

Just some thoughts.....

 

[karaoke]

Very similar Def & Fwd situation as my team.

Goodes > Enright FTW!(I'm also doing this trade only Hanley > Enright) Enright has a very good record against St Kilda and @ the Cattery this week I'm hopeful for a 120+ score

Leave Staker in your forwards. Can loophole Buddy/Staker with Neade doughnut this week.

I'd actually make Nicholls ruck emergency this week. If he spuds up, move Cox to the rucks via Nicnat to the forwards and take Buddy's emergency score if he fires up.

 

[Embleberry]

Very similar Def & Fwd situation as my team.

Goodes > Enright FTW!(I'm also doing this trade only Hanley > Enright) Enright has a very good record against St Kilda and @ the Cattery this week I'm hopeful for a 120+ score

Leave Staker in your forwards. Can loophole Buddy/Staker with Neade doughnut this week.

I'd actually make Nicholls ruck emergency this week. If he spuds up, move Cox to the rucks via Nicnat to the forwards and take Buddy's emergency score if he fires up.

Oh yeah I never actually thought of doing those emergency loopholes! A little busy this weekend, but every point will count. Cheers

Embles,

Not saying it's right option, but you could go Goodes > XRichards (swap with Staker) & raise some $$ with 3 trades to go, (toxic special )

this week play Vlas & Staker as D5 & D6, Buddy at F6, no real Emerg cover though,

Put 'E' on Clisby (Sat game), if he goes well 85+, you could always put Hanley (Sun game) on field for Vlas (Sun game) for emerg loophole,

You would now have some coin to upgrade Clisby, Viney & Neade eventually (provided NicNat, Cox & Danger aren't put out to pasture early!),

Just some thoughts.....

Yeah I was thinking that too. The extra cash will come in ultra handy, particularly since I still have a couple more rookies to upgrade. I intend to hold Jobe + Danger, but hopefully Nic Nat is rested for a couple of weeks and is back firing for finals!
It's the riskier option, but has it's merits and the payoff would be quite nice!

 

[jmac009]

Gents any ideas for trades this week?

Goddard, Hanley, Gibbs, Goodes, Ibbotson, Hartlett (Clisby, Richards)
Ablett, Pendles, Swan, Selwood, Kennedy, Barlow, Priddis, Mitchell (Crouch, Viney)
Maric, Naitinui (Nicholls, Rowe)
Bartel, Cox, Martin, Rocklif, Franklin, Harvey (Staker, Speight)

5 Trades, $122,200 left

Thanks

 

[footyfan08]

Backs - Goddard, Hartlett, Duffield, Gibbs, Hanley, Goodes (Docherty, Staker)
Mids - Ablett, Swan, Pendlebury, Cotchin, Kennedy, Selwood, S.Mitchell, Griffen (T.Mitchell, Martin)
Rucks - McEvoy, Cox (Nicholls, Naismith)
Fwds - Johnson, Walker, Martin, Franklin, Rockliff, J.Kennedy (B.Kennedy, Rowe)

4 trades, $45,000

Should have a league win, regardless, but wondering what to do about B.Goodes?

Thinking 1 trade this week and go Goodes>Heppell/Hibberd

I haven't had a chance to look at BE's, but wondering what peoples thoughts are.... or is there another option I'm missing?!


Cheers

 

[leng jai]

Gents any ideas for trades this week?

Goddard, Hanley, Gibbs, Goodes, Ibbotson, Hartlett (Clisby, Richards)
Ablett, Pendles, Swan, Selwood, Kennedy, Barlow, Priddis, Mitchell (Crouch, Viney)
Maric, Naitinui (Nicholls, Rowe)
Bartel, Cox, Martin, Rocklif, Franklin, Harvey (Staker, Speight)

5 Trades, $122,200 left

Thanks

I'd be looking at trading Nicnat next week if he's out again but other than that your team looks pretty decent. Goodes to Shaw is a no brainer though.

 

[karaoke]

Gents any ideas for trades this week?

Goddard, Hanley, Gibbs, Goodes, Ibbotson, Hartlett (Clisby, Richards)
Ablett, Pendles, Swan, Selwood, Kennedy, Barlow, Priddis, Mitchell (Crouch, Viney)
Maric, Naitinui (Nicholls, Rowe)
Bartel, Cox, Martin, Rocklif, Franklin, Harvey (Staker, Speight)

5 Trades, $122,200 left

Thanks

Goodes > Enright
play Clisby as D6 for this week, move Staker back next week (via XRichards DPP - I presume?)
Nicholls to play for NicNat

next week - Crouch > Cyril (DPP) or MMurphy ($$)

3 trades left (not a lot of $$) for LTI's,

 

[karaoke]

Backs - Goddard, Hartlett, Duffield, Gibbs, Hanley, Goodes (Docherty, Staker)
Mids - Ablett, Swan, Pendlebury, Cotchin, Kennedy, Selwood, S.Mitchell, Griffen (T.Mitchell, Martin)
Rucks - McEvoy, Cox (Nicholls, Naismith)
Fwds - Johnson, Walker, Martin, Franklin, Rockliff, J.Kennedy (B.Kennedy, Rowe)

4 trades, $45,000

Should have a league win, regardless, but wondering what to do about B.Goodes?

Thinking 1 trade this week and go Goodes>Heppell/Hibberd

I haven't had a chance to look at BE's, but wondering what peoples thoughts are.... or is there another option I'm missing?!


Cheers

Goodes > Enright/Ibbotson/McKenzie

 

[rocker_oz33]

Gents any ideas for trades this week?

Goddard, Hanley, Gibbs, Goodes, Ibbotson, Hartlett (Clisby, Richards)
Ablett, Pendles, Swan, Selwood, Kennedy, Barlow, Priddis, Mitchell (Crouch, Viney)
Maric, Naitinui (Nicholls, Rowe)
Bartel, Cox, Martin, Rocklif, Franklin, Harvey (Staker, Speight)

5 Trades, $122,200 left

Thanks

Goodes to enright/heppell.Tmitch crouch and viney moo for another week or 2 upgrade downgrde to another mid gun as finals start.

 

[Goats]

View attachment 24663

Ok gents, what do you think?

4 trades & 406k in bank,

I am thinking of only 1 trade this week, as I would like to have 3 when it comes to SC finals;

Goodes > SJ (via Staker DPP)

Gingy, toxic, Judd_Magic, any others - comments & thoughts appreciated, especially different viewpoints I may not have already considered,

TIA

I think that's the best possible trade you could do if you only want to use one trade.

 

[jmac009]

Goodes to enright/heppell.Tmitch crouch and viney moo for another week or 2 upgrade downgrde to another mid gun as finals start.

Goodes > Enright
play Clisby as D6 for this week, move Staker back next week (via XRichards DPP - I presume?)
Nicholls to play for NicNat

next week - Crouch > Cyril (DPP) or MMurphy ($$)

3 trades left (not a lot of $$) for LTI's,

Thanks for the feedback guys. Wasnt sure whether to burn 2 trades and go Goodes to Enright/McKenzie/Heppell/S Thompson and Crouch to M Murphy or go Goodes to Grimes/Duffield and Crouch to Cotchin/Montagna.

Might just do the 1 trade and go Goodes to Enright/McKenzie/Heppell/S Thompson and hold fire on Crouch as mentioned.

Thanks.