Round 19 Trades

[chdaf]

Two options, which will get me the most points in finals

Martin to Fyfe/ Chappy
or Lake to Waters.
Would like to know what you guys think, thanks

 

[BVIB]

Two options, which will get me the most points in finals

Martin to Fyfe/ Chappy
or Lake to Waters.
Would like to know what you guys think, thanks

I would go Lake to Waters, I'm keeping Martin he is doing alright atm and should smash it during SC finals - well I hope so anyway!

Also I'm going Broughton -> Fisher. What are people's thoughts on Buddy? Not sure if I should persist, I need the win and % this week to finish on top

 

[SteveRFC]

Two options, which will get me the most points in finals

Martin to Fyfe/ Chappy
or Lake to Waters.
Would like to know what you guys think, thanks

Why trade Martin so late in the season when he's A: Fresh from suspension. B: Starting to find some good SC form?

 

[Balony_pony16]

how many more weeks does Chris Judd have again? and should I trade him? Brock McClean, Ablett, peds, boyd, kennedy, S Selwood are my current mids (Judd on the bench)

 

[RBW_007]

So for my last trade I was thinking of either trading Dempsey to Scotland and improve my backline or trade McDonald to Fyfe to get cover for my mids as well as a link to my forwards.

The Dempsey trade gets me a better back but leaves my mids vunerable with Williams out for the year and McDonald not being named in a while. The Fyfe trade will leave my team with prety good cover but figuring out who to bench out of Fyfe, Porps, Zorko and Martin will be a headache.

Thoughts?

 

[zannnn]

Just used my last 2 trades to bring in Pav, it was him or Chapman (or even upgrading Dempsey/Lake to Waters, but I didn't want left over money so I went all out on Pav)

Broughton > T.Bell
T.Dickson > Pavlich

Final lineup:

DEF: Deledio, Goddard, Suckling, H.Shaw, Lake, Dempsey, Carrazzo (Darley, Bell)
MID: Watson, Abblett, Swallow, S.Selwood, Priddis, Pendlebury (McDonald, Sexton)
RUC: Goldstein, Mumford (Redden, Stephenson)
FWD: Dangerfield, Pavlich, Beams, Sidebottom, N.Riewoldt, Zorko, Goodes (Adams, Couch)

A couple mates are playing for the highest spot in our league to win a few slabs, this is me and my mate with the highest position within the bet:

We're both set to win against even opponents, so I need to juice as much points this round to take home the slabs on percentage! Wish me luck.

 

[Sir Grenvold]

So for my last trade I was thinking of either trading Dempsey to Scotland and improve my backline or trade McDonald to Fyfe to get cover for my mids as well as a link to my forwards.

The Dempsey trade gets me a better back but leaves my mids vunerable with Williams out for the year and McDonald not being named in a while. The Fyfe trade will leave my team with prety good cover but figuring out who to bench out of Fyfe, Porps, Zorko and Martin will be a headache.

Thoughts?

That's a dilly of a pickle. If anything, I'd probably leave it for a week and bring Shaw in for Dempsey. Why make a decision now when you can put it off for next week!?!?!

Me? I just used my last two trades. Going to make finals comfortably in all three of my leagues but not quite as invested in it all this year as I have been. Anyhoo, here they are (unless I wuss out and reverse them later tomorrow):
Dempsey -> Scotland
Horsley -> Baguley
This way I can pop Stanton on the bench, swap Bags (mid) with Scotland (def), then bring Shaw back on for Bags

OR

Horsley -> Baguley
Stanton -> Swan (or any other premium mid)
Less flexibility with the squad but... SWAN (or any other premium mid)!

 

[Youdy]

Alright i'm in a bit of a strange position
Focus on dreamteam so forgot about my supercoach team yet still somehow find myself definately in the finals in 2 leagues and a possibility in a third
Currently my team is

Deledio, Goddard, Enright, Adcock, Birchall, Duffield, Morris (Smedts, Darley)
Ablett, Thompson, Selwood, Mitchell, Priddis, Treloar (Baguley, Williams)
Maric, Kreuzer (Giles, Hall)
Beams, Sidebottom, Franklin, S Johnson, Lewis, Martin, Zorko (Sexton, Saad)

172,900 in the bank and 12 trades
The 2 most needed upgrades are another premium in the backs and in the mids
With Franklin out it means before trades im starting both Treloar and Saad

Thinking of going Darley to Bell
Then trading out Williams to Probably a choice of Murphy/NDS/Redden Anyone under 528,300

Other option I have considered is to go Morris>Bell
Put Smedts on the field
Then Go Saad>Pendlebury/Swan
Putting Treloar into the forward line
This would remove my dpp link though


I think it comes down to Smedts + Pendles/Swan vs Morris +Murphy/NDS
As immediate gains in points are crucial for me
Thoughts?
Sorry for the long read, is essentially my thoughts written down :/

 

[Dizzy Stuff]

I think it comes down to Smedts + Pendles/Swan vs Morris +Murphy/NDS
As immediate gains in points are crucial for me
Thoughts?
Sorry for the long read, is essentially my thoughts written down :/

Of those options, I prefer the first, and would bring in Pendles over Swan. Pendles has averaged 130+ since coming back from injury, and hopefully because of that little break he's unlikely to get rested in any of the remaining rounds. I wouldn't worry too much about losing your DPP link, because you have so many trades left - you could use 2 a week and still have 2 left over. Normally, DPP links are helpful for avoiding zeros, but if you're facing any donuts you can simply trade and not think twice about it.

I've got a dilemma this week, although it's not the worst one to have. Team is:

Deledio, Goddard, H. Shaw, Carrazzo, Lake, S. Shaw, Spurr (Ellis, Darley)

Ablett, Pendlebury, Swan, Priddis, Cotchin, Boyd (C. Smith, Gibson)

Naitanui, Roughead (Redden, Stephenson)

Franklin, Beams, Sidebottom, Pavlich, Zorko, Martin, Goodes (Porplyzia, Treloar)

6 trades and 36k left.

Clearly I need to make a couple of backline upgrades. I had planned to downgrade Porplyzia to generate the cash needed for those last two upgrades, however now Porplyzia is playing so well that it feels silly to trade him out - especially with Franklin not playing, he's providing great cover. The dilemma is whether I:

a) trade Porplyzia to Casboult, make the final two backline upgrades before finals, and have Treloar as my backup forward; or
b) trade Treloar to Casboult, just make one backline upgrade and sit on that extra trade; or
c) trade someone else to Casboult, to generate the cash needed for those two upgrades ... Zorko? Martin? Goodes?

Anyone have any thoughts?

 

[EyeloveRichmond]

Fisher does look temping doesn't he, I say grab him.

Who should I trade in for Stanton?

Deledio, Hurn, Enright, Scotland, Carrazzo, Lake, Dempsey (Guthrie, S.Sahw)
Stanton, Pendles, Ablett, J.Selwood, Boyd, Priddis (C.Smith, Pfieffer)
Mumford, Maric (Stephenson, Campbell)
Sidebottom, Cloke, Martin, Goodes, Porps, Dangerfield, Adams (Hall, Smedts)

3 trades, $193,000 in the bank

Dane Swan $617,200
JP Kennedy $564,100
Marc Murphy $493,300
Dayne Beams $601,600

Swan every day of the week.

 

[JustMe53]

Broughton out fisher in 1 trade left.

Lids waters scottland birchall Goddard Thompson fisher (yagmoor shaw)

Ablett pendlas swan Watson Boyd Mitchell (sutcliffe sexton)

Jacobs kruezzz (orren campbell)

Danger chappy Robinson cloke Martin zorko goodes (Franklin couch)

 

[SteveRFC]

Last minute help.

Swan and Fisher or
Thompson and Goddard

 

[viking12]

trading out steve morris
who to get between waters, hurn or scotland ?

 

[SteveRFC]

trading out steve morris
who to get between waters, hurn or scotland ?

Hurn has a pretty tough final month. I'd go Scotland personally.

Post your DEF side so we can look.

 

[viking12]

Hurn has a pretty tough final month. I'd go Scotland personally.

Post your DEF side so we can look.

Def: Deledio, Goddard, Shaw, Carrazzo, Dempsey, Morris, Ellis (Golby, M.Clarke)

currently 6 trades left and $117,600 in the bank

 

[dlanod]

trading out steve morris
who to get between waters, hurn or scotland ?

Scotland, easy run home.

 

[Seppo]

Just made my last 2 trades.

OUT:Lake
IN: Scotland

OUT: Broughton
Shifted M.Johnson to DEF:
IN: This guy!

 

[raymagoo]

Pendles or swan in? I can't split them

 

[rocker_oz33]

Just went darley to redpath (fwd/def) purley to make cash can throw smebts back if needed.Will be up grading either Sshaw or spurr next week.

 

[Satan]

lake to fisher? got 478900, leaves 120,000 cash and 2 trades

delido, goddard, newman, dempsey, s shaw, hurn(mcinnes/boumann)

 

[JustMe53]

Better option suckling or fisher??

 

[SCchamp]

Pendles or swan in? I can't split them

just toss a coin really! Swanny pulls out the odd bigger score but Pendles is more consistent. Can't go wrong with either....

 

[raymagoo]

Better option suckling or fisher??

Hope suckling wasn't your man! Downhill skier IMO