Umpiring Round 2 Bulldogs v Collingwood

[Fadge]

Sure is, glad you agree.

If that's your compelling argument, your argument has failed.

 

[bzparkes]

If that's your compelling argument, your argument has failed.

Sorry, guess I should've used a laugh emoji instead.

 

[TruRoo]

So you didn't get the positive affirmation you were hoping for?

I don't really care about the braves, but Razor Ray was nauseating

 

[Obeanie1]

There is 1 MCG tenant in the top 10 +/- free kicks in the last 4 completed seasons but carry on with the MCG bias...

There is however 3 interstate teams in the top 5...surprisingly 2 Optus tenants....

2. Brisbane
4. Freo
5. WCE



don't let facts get in the way of your opinion.

So Pies don't get the rub of the green at the MCG?

Well they did last week. Big time.

 

[eddiesmith]

The Coll v GWS Prelim was atrocious

‘Neutral Fans’- “Ginnivan ducks, boo him he shouldn’t get free kicks”

AFL so in favour of Collingwood changes the rules…

‘Neutral Fans’- “GWS were robbed, Toby ducked and didn’t get a free kick”

 

[Walter H White]

They were bitter because they wanted a fairy tale ending and we ruined it. As another poster said there were plenty of obvious frees to the Pies which were missed but nobody has an issue with that. The hatred for Nick and Coxy is disgusting but also comforting as it tells me we are feared. We hate what we fear.

I was absolutely terrified of your performance against GWS

 

[Outback Footy]

oh really? you made the claim that all the "neutrals" were pissed off. My point is show me a genuine neutral in a Collingwood match. I stand by it.

Yep, pick that tiny part of my comment to respond to. I made a fair few statements, how bout you answer the others?

 

[RCAB]

@freekickhawthorn

That's right, Hawthorn the heat free kicks of any team in history and also in recent times.

Well done for outing yourself MagpieJo

 

[domus]

I was absolutely terrified of your performance against GWS

Exactly. At least you are being honest now.

 

[Vankri]

Ah, this one is still going. I’ll be monitoring the rest of the season to see if the same level of ‘neutral’ fan outrage and media commentary is applied to other games where the free kick count is lopsided, and specifically to games where the decisions and non decisions were not critical to scoring (sure that deliberate out of bounds for Nick Daicos would have changed the game of course). I’ll think I’ll be waiting a while though.

 

[HBFlanker]

Did you factor in the two goals we had stolen from us by poor umpiring? Elliott placed in a headlock 15m out from our goal and ump ignores it or didn't see it-poor positioning. Cox belted after he marked-no 50m which would have placed him 20m out directly in front. Oh-and Darcy shoved McStay so hard in the back he was last seen heading over the fence on the northern stand wing and the Darcy grab led to a Bulldogs goal.

No but i saw the 20 free kick differential and the game handed to the pies on a platter. I had seen enough.

 

[domus]

No but i saw the 20 free kick differential and the game handed to the pies on a platter. I had seen enough.

That's ridiculous. All of the frees were there. It's so childish to think the frees must be even or close. The review cleared all but two for us and that was ignoring the two that robbed us of certain goals. So bitter.

And we were clearly the better side after quarter time and should have won comfortably had we not missed a series of sitters which let them back into the game.

 

[Andronicus]

That's ridiculous. All of the frees were there.

Hahahahahahahahahahaha hahaha.

 

[HBFlanker]

That's ridiculous. All of the frees were there. It's so childish to think the frees must be even or close. The review cleared all but two for us and that was ignoring the two that robbed us of certain goals. So bitter.

And we were clearly the better side after quarter time and should have won comfortably had we not missed a series of sitters which let them back into the game.

This could be the most one eyed, ridiculous comment ive seen on this site. Extraordinary.

Werent the better team at all. Wouldnt have won without the lopsided free kick count.

 

[domus]

This could be the most one eyed, ridiculous comment ive seen on this site. Extraordinary.

Werent the better team at all. Wouldnt have won without the lopsided free kick count.

Grow up. Every commentator conceded that we were the better side for three quarters. We controlled the game. It shouldn't have been close.

 

[Nvent]

Grow up. Every commentator conceded that we were the better side for three quarters. We controlled the game. It shouldn't have been close.

The better side did 3 quarters yet just fell over the line with everything going your way.

Yeah nah

 

[HBFlanker]

Grow up. Every commentator conceded that we were the better side for three quarters. We controlled the game. It shouldn't have been close.

No. You didnt.

You were gifted the game, and its not the first time its happened either.

 

[Reg Grundy35]

No. You didnt.

You were gifted the game, and its not the first time its happened either.

is this still going on?!!! FMD!

 

[Stax on the mill]

The better side did 3 quarters yet just fell over the line with everything going your way.

Yeah nah

How many aliases now Nvent? To my knowledge it’s been The Finger, Adam H, Christian Boy, Holden Megroin and now Nvent. No doubt there have been others.

Admin no sooner ban you and you start up another bogus account. But it’s always the same modus operandi, that is, trolling Pies threads. Hopefully you might grow up one day. But I doubt it.

 

[Outback Footy]

Compelling.

In summary, according to Razor, the only decision that was incorrect was the Bailey Dale deliberate out of bounds, only because he didn't 'hit the ball hard enough toward the boundary line'....

Razor only looked at some of the frees paid in the last quarter. And you seem to have forgotten his comment about the non-free from Quainor, lets not forget that one. He didnt review most of the non-paid marks where Darcy was chopped, didnt comment on Naughtons mark not being paid in the goal square and didnt look at any of the first 3 quarters.

 

[Sentinel]

All of the frees were there.

The review cleared all but two for us

 

[Fadge]

Razor only looked at some of the frees paid in the last quarter. And you seem to have forgotten his comment about the non-free from Quainor, lets not forget that one. He didnt review most of the non-paid marks where Darcy was chopped, didnt comment on Naughtons mark not being paid in the goal square and didnt look at any of the first 3 quarters.

I think it's time for you guys to get over it...

 

[MagpieJo]

Well they aren't correct.
Cox was in the contest - Just a free kick.
Plenty of arm chops to Darcy not paid.
Clear front on to Naughton at the start of the 4th not paid
Deliberate out of bounds by Daicos Not paid.

His comments that you missed a couple are very pro Collingwood view.

You need to open both eyes sometimes.

Watch the game again. It’s ok, you are allowed to be wrong!

 

[Bulldog Joe]

Watch the game again. It’s ok, you are allowed to be wrong!

You clearly know about being wrong

 

[Professor Knowall]

So where’s all the outrage over the free kick disparity in last nights Pies v Blés clash?